Battle of the Optimization All-Stars!!!!!!!!!! [Archive] - Wizards Community

Post/Author/DateTimePost
Eye_of_Vecna

04-06-05, 02:45 PM
There's a lot of postings for this and that build, but for people who are new to the board it may not be readily apparent without searching through hundreds of previous threads which builds are the strongest. So, it is time for you to voice your opinions. Which builds are strongest? Here are our contenders, some local favorites, others are proven sluggers:

Skill Rogue vs. Sneak Attack Rogue

Frenzied Barbarian takes on all Barbarian challengers (Can he survive?)

Artifacer vs. Warlock

Divine Metamagic Cleric vs. Cleric Archer

Gish vs. Trip-monkey vs. Champion of Corellon in a battle royal cage match!

Cheater of Mystra vs. Ur-Priest

Arcane Trickster vs. Daggerspell Mage



It's time for Smackdown!
carnivore

04-06-05, 03:08 PM
WINNERS BOLDED.....just my opinion
Skill Rogue vs. Sneak Attack Rogue......... cant really tell the difference

Frenzied Barbarian takes on all Barbarian challengers (Can he survive?)yes

Artifacer, by a long shot vs. Warlock

Divine Metamagic Cleric vs. Cleric Archer

Gish,...wears steadfast boots and polymorphs into kelvezu vs. Trip-monkey vs. Champion of Corellon in a battle royal cage match!

Cheater of Mystra vs. Ur-Priest

Arcane Trickster vs. Daggerspell Mage
Phaxi

04-06-05, 03:18 PM
No H.I.V.E or hulking hurler?
Kolo

04-06-05, 03:21 PM
No H.I.V.E or hulking hurler?

Wouldn't that be a bit like throwing basketballs at peas and expect a fair fight? :P
Gol

04-06-05, 03:23 PM
Divine Metamagic Cleric vs. Cleric Archer
What is this? Schizophrenic mind combat?
warpdragon

04-06-05, 05:30 PM
How about Supermount, SupererCharger, King of Smack, or Divine Minion?
Eye_of_Vecna

04-06-05, 05:47 PM
This isn't the WWF unless someone else jumps into the ring, preferably carrying a +5 folding chair, here are some more fighters who just can't keep out of it!!


Looks like Hurking Hulker should be included. He'll be fighting UberCharge!

Divine Minion vs. King of Smack (Who's side will God be on?)

Exalted (but Poor) Monk vs. Blood Magus!

Mystic Thurge vs. Fochluran Lysrist

Psychic Warrior Tank vs. Master Transmogrifist
Otto the Bugbear

04-06-05, 08:00 PM
What? No AC through the roof guy?

I'm hurt.

Really.

Cheers

Otto :)
Kolo

04-06-05, 08:05 PM
I concur with Otto. Let's get that saint ac-of-150+ of his into the ring and see just how badly the hulking hurler can miss... :)
The Thing in the Night

04-06-05, 08:45 PM
Hulking Hurler vs Ubercharge: Whoever wins initiative

Divine Minion vs King of Smack: The king takes this one (unless he goes down in one round)

VoP Monk vs Blood Magus: VoP all the way
slade_caizer

04-06-05, 10:54 PM
And suddenly all contenders are flattened by a halfling commoner with a spoon. :embarrass
zivpeled

04-07-05, 04:34 AM
And suddenly all contenders are flattened by a halfling commoner with a spoon. :embarrass
:P :evillaugh :ayyyy!: :rofl: :rofl: :heehee :tongue:
thats a good one



but where is the sadisem masochisem dude with -AC
Blade2718

04-07-05, 09:55 AM
What about the ninja pirate with a monkey Artificer cohort that has a giant transforming robot that shoots laser beams from its eyes? I think the robot will take them all down if it wins initiative.
Khazra Reborn

04-07-05, 10:19 AM
FB loses to normal barbarian because they suck...the only way to get a good will save is to be nothing like the hcracter you wanted! give me RB or CofG anyday..
Hartz404

04-07-05, 10:21 AM
Where can I find good builds of H.I.V.E, Champion of Corellon and the s/m dude?
Shebnar

04-07-05, 10:45 AM
And suddenly all contenders are flattened by a halfling commoner with a spoon. :embarrass

Yes. He is Lord Ao under disguise.

Did you all forget the Wish and the Word?
:P


Where can I find the Divine Minion build? :confused:
Lilt

04-07-05, 10:55 AM
Hulking Hurler Vs The World

I think Sneak-attack rogue woudl win in a combat versus a pure skill rogue if this is just combat. If it's as part of an optimised party then I'd go for the skill rogue.
Caelic

04-07-05, 04:24 PM
Did you all forget the Wish and the Word?
:P




Nope. The Wish isn't even really a character--he's an abuse of the magic item creation rules. The Word, as presented, was illegal on a half-dozen fronts.

An Artificer can make BOTH tricks work, if they're being allowed.
SigmaJargon

04-07-05, 07:49 PM
Hulking Hurler Vs The WorldThe Hurler is a stellar example of the heights (or depths) that min/maxing can take a character to - it can deal such a studendously large amount of damage that anything it hits (assuming it to be subject to weapon damage) will be instantly flattened, obliterated, reduced to dust and debris.

However, it should be kept in mind that while the Hurler is mind-bogglingly powerful in the realm of damage dealing, he fails in almost every other area. Whack him with a forcecage, a hide n' poke sneak attack rogue, dispel the shrink item or polymorph on his weapon or his buffs. Heck, even face him up against something like a swarm that is immune to weapon damage, and watch his huge ball of doom fly through them with no effect whatsoever. Have a Frenzied Berserker melee him with Deathless Frenzy. Snipe him, perferably from some position he can't reach easily (i.e, in the air).

Basically, something or someone in the world certainly can take the Hurler. As long as they win initative ;)

Some interesting fights might be:
---------------------------------
Optimized Melee Cleric vs. Gish
Optimized Melee Cleric vs. Otto's AC build
Cleric Archer vs. KSB Snow Combat Archer
Artificer vs. Cheater of Mystra
Shadowcraft Gnome vs. Supermount
Warforged Juggernaut vs. Gish
slade_caizer

04-07-05, 07:49 PM
How about that Troll/Half-RedDragon/FrenziedBerserker/Warshaper/Mentalist-thingy from hell that's nearly immortal? Then again I'll stick with the kender and a 2-liter of Mountain Dew.
incubus

04-07-05, 08:30 PM
The Hurler is a stellar example of the heights (or depths) that min/maxing can take a character to - it can deal such a studendously large amount of damage that anything it hits (assuming it to be subject to weapon damage) will be instantly flattened, obliterated, reduced to dust and debris.

However, it should be kept in mind that while the Hurler is mind-bogglingly powerful in the realm of damage dealing, he fails in almost every other area. Whack him with a forcecage, a hide n' poke sneak attack rogue, dispel the shrink item or polymorph on his weapon or his buffs. Heck, even face him up against something like a swarm that is immune to weapon damage, and watch his huge ball of doom fly through them with no effect whatsoever. Have a Frenzied Berserker melee him with Deathless Frenzy. Snipe him, perferably from some position he can't reach easily (i.e, in the air).

HH kills swarms. His attack gets transmuted to an AOE with meteoric strike (IIRC).

And I think the guy actually intended HH versus the world itself, not versus the people within the world...
slade_caizer

04-07-05, 08:40 PM
And I think the guy actually intended HH versus the world itself, not versus the people within the world...

OMG

:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

:bounce: :heehee

Are we going a little too DBZ here? (Though I'd like to see the look on a DM's face...)
The Thing in the Night

04-07-05, 11:26 PM
How 'bout the Cheater of Mystra vs Ultimate AC?
NineInchNall

04-08-05, 12:25 AM
Nope. The Wish isn't even really a character--he's an abuse of the magic item creation rules. The Word, as presented, was illegal on a half-dozen fronts.

An Artificer can make BOTH tricks work, if they're being allowed.


Now, dude, you know that a good case can be made for each side in that argument. *slap wrist* No more absolutes for Caelic. Tsk tsk. You know it all depends on how you're reading things.

In any case, you're right: the Artificer, as the single most poorly balanced class ever designed, and yet another reason I will never ever go near an Eberron game, can do anything it damned well pleases. :D