called shot penalties [Archive] - Wizards Community

Post/Author/DateTimePost
squiglylon

11-18-07, 11:55 AM
what are the called shot penalties for trying dismemberment in combat(head, arm, leg, hand, etc......). last i recall called shots were a -4 on the attack roll with no 20 auto hit. would that be the case in a dismemberment . i was just skimming the rules and couldnt find it.

thanks for you help
Malchius

11-18-07, 11:57 AM
called shots in D&D don't strictly exist, but if you want to do somethign like it. There's pecision based damage, eg. sneak attack, and then ambush feats or to dismember peple you need a vorpal weapon. Also Crits are generally "called shots" but with no extra effects except more damage.
squiglylon

11-18-07, 12:09 PM
maybe it was a house rule we were playing with. we had a ranger that liked shooting mages in the mouth or throat. pretty helpful i might say
Malchius

11-18-07, 12:10 PM
There's a ambush feat called Throat Punch in complete scoundrel that achieves what your ranger wanted to.
squiglylon

11-18-07, 12:17 PM
i would have thought that precise shot would cover it but it doesnt. i dont have that book currently. been a while since i played and just now getting books back. then they say they are coming out with 4e will this madness ever end lol
risner

11-18-07, 02:00 PM
what are the called shot penalties for trying dismemberment in combat(head, arm, leg, hand, etc......). last i recall called shots were a -4 on the attack roll with no 20 auto hit. would that be the case in a dismemberment . i was just skimming the rules and couldnt find it.

thanks for you help

The only called shots in D&D are:
1) Critical (on a natural 20 roll)
2) Sneak Attack
3) Power Attack

The system is designed around there being no called shots. If you did have called shots, you would need to remove half the system including True Strike spell, Sneak Attack, and pretty much everything else in the system.
Rulebook

11-18-07, 05:06 PM
find the book 3rd party Torn Asunder: Critical Hits if you want halfway decent called shots and crit tables