Cirumstantial Circumstance [Archive] - Wizards Community

Cirumstantial Circumstance [Archive] - Wizards Community

Post/Author/DateTime Post
Ramacass
06-25-07, 07:02 AM Ok, so I recently learned that while circumstance bonuses do stack "unless they arise from essentially the same circumstance" metaorgs are considered to be the same circumstance.

Woulds the circumstance bonus to diplomacy my pc has from a metaorg stack with the circumstance bonus granted from rich or luxury upkeep?

Thanks
_metz_
06-25-07, 07:06 AM Rich and Luxury Upkeep aren't from the same metaorg so yes. You cited the rule that says so in your question.

And I am positive bonuses from different Metaorgs do in fact stack. (Unless there is some LG ruling I am unaware of).
Ramacass
06-25-07, 07:18 AM Rich and Luxury Upkeep aren't from the same metaorg so yes. You cited the rule that says so in your question.

And I am positive bonuses from different Metaorgs do in fact stack. (Unless there is some LG ruling I am unaware of).

Yeah there's a link to a dispel confusion twords the bottom of the Expert Taction thread that says for LG all Meta-orgs are considered the same circumstance. Rather than hijack Squirrel's thread I thought I'd start my own.

What about luxury upkeep granted by metaorgs?:)
_metz_
06-25-07, 07:21 AM Yeah there's a link to a dispel confusion twords the bottom of the Expert Taction thread that says for LG all Meta-orgs are considered the same circumstance. Rather than hijack Squirrel's thread I thought I'd start my own.

What about luxury upkeep granted by metaorgs?:)

That is luxury upkeep granted. the bonus still comes from luxury upkeep, not the metaorg. (It just pays it for you.)

Luxury upkeep is a separate factor and is independent of metaorgs.
Ramacass
06-25-07, 07:43 AM That is luxury upkeep granted. the bonus still comes from luxury upkeep, not the metaorg. (It just pays it for you.)

Luxury upkeep is a separate factor and is independent of metaorgs.

Makes sense
Southernskies
06-25-07, 08:59 AM Circumstance bonuses from metaorgs are considered the "same" bonus (and most have had their wording updated to remind players that they don't stack).

Post/Author/DateTime	Post
Ramacass 06-25-07, 07:02 AM	Ok, so I recently learned that while circumstance bonuses do stack "unless they arise from essentially the same circumstance" metaorgs are considered to be the same circumstance. Woulds the circumstance bonus to diplomacy my pc has from a metaorg stack with the circumstance bonus granted from rich or luxury upkeep? Thanks
_metz_ 06-25-07, 07:06 AM	Rich and Luxury Upkeep aren't from the same metaorg so yes. You cited the rule that says so in your question. And I am positive bonuses from different Metaorgs do in fact stack. (Unless there is some LG ruling I am unaware of).
Ramacass 06-25-07, 07:18 AM	Rich and Luxury Upkeep aren't from the same metaorg so yes. You cited the rule that says so in your question. And I am positive bonuses from different Metaorgs do in fact stack. (Unless there is some LG ruling I am unaware of). Yeah there's a link to a dispel confusion twords the bottom of the Expert Taction thread that says for LG all Meta-orgs are considered the same circumstance. Rather than hijack Squirrel's thread I thought I'd start my own. What about luxury upkeep granted by metaorgs?:)
_metz_ 06-25-07, 07:21 AM	Yeah there's a link to a dispel confusion twords the bottom of the Expert Taction thread that says for LG all Meta-orgs are considered the same circumstance. Rather than hijack Squirrel's thread I thought I'd start my own. What about luxury upkeep granted by metaorgs?:) That is luxury upkeep granted. the bonus still comes from luxury upkeep, not the metaorg. (It just pays it for you.) Luxury upkeep is a separate factor and is independent of metaorgs.
Ramacass 06-25-07, 07:43 AM	That is luxury upkeep granted. the bonus still comes from luxury upkeep, not the metaorg. (It just pays it for you.) Luxury upkeep is a separate factor and is independent of metaorgs. Makes sense
Southernskies 06-25-07, 08:59 AM	Circumstance bonuses from metaorgs are considered the "same" bonus (and most have had their wording updated to remind players that they don't stack).