About creating a Holy weapon? [Archive] - Wizards Community

About creating a Holy weapon? [Archive] - Wizards Community

Post/Author/DateTime Post
slayeryang
12-10-03, 02:55 PM Can a rogueX/wizardX with [feat : Craft Magic Arms and Armor]

use his [skill:USE MAGIC DEVICE] to activate the Holy smite scroll

(or anything that can provide the same effect) in order to creat a

holy weapon?:confused:

IMO, [skill:USE MAGIC DEVICE] can not be used in this way, and

he could not creat such a weapon, am I correct?:confused:
Seeker95
12-10-03, 04:12 PM No. The crafter must have the spell prepared. A scroll does not count as a prepared spell.
El_Machinae
12-10-03, 09:39 PM Though personally, if the person had a new scroll for every day required to make the item, I'd allow it. Not 100% legit, but since scrolls have an XP cost, I figure it's okay.
Ryll
12-11-03, 05:44 AM Unless they changed it in 3.5 , the crafter could make it if he/she:

1) had a scroll (and could read it successfully) for every day of the creation

-or-

2) had an item that cast the spell, and could cast it everyday that was needed in creating the item

-or-

3) had someone who has this spell assist him/her in the making of the item.

Post/Author/DateTime	Post
slayeryang 12-10-03, 02:55 PM	Can a rogueX/wizardX with [feat : Craft Magic Arms and Armor] use his [skill:USE MAGIC DEVICE] to activate the Holy smite scroll (or anything that can provide the same effect) in order to creat a holy weapon?:confused: IMO, [skill:USE MAGIC DEVICE] can not be used in this way, and he could not creat such a weapon, am I correct?:confused:
Seeker95 12-10-03, 04:12 PM	No. The crafter must have the spell prepared. A scroll does not count as a prepared spell.
El_Machinae 12-10-03, 09:39 PM	Though personally, if the person had a new scroll for every day required to make the item, I'd allow it. Not 100% legit, but since scrolls have an XP cost, I figure it's okay.
Ryll 12-11-03, 05:44 AM	Unless they changed it in 3.5 , the crafter could make it if he/she: 1) had a scroll (and could read it successfully) for every day of the creation -or- 2) had an item that cast the spell, and could cast it everyday that was needed in creating the item -or- 3) had someone who has this spell assist him/her in the making of the item.