Sun Elves v.s Grey Elves [Archive] - Wizards Community

Post/Author/DateTimePost
Zaistars69

04-06-07, 12:18 PM
Are the sun elves the same as the Grey elves just as the moon elves
are the same as the high elves? If I remember right all of the other
elven types have the same racial ability adjustments and such as the
ones in the MM just with different names. The aquatic elf (appears in
the races of Faerun) has the same racial adj as the ones in the SRD and
MM. It seems like the newer material should supersede the old 3.0
stuff unless I'm missing a 3.5 FR book (which is easily possible).
AZNsupermarket

04-06-07, 12:58 PM
Sun elves and Gray Elves are actually two different races. Although, they are confused with each other all the time. The confusion dates back to the fact that their are less 10 races ever published by wotc with a bonus to int and LA +0; three of them are elven sub-races. With the plethora of elven sub-races, this will of course lead to some confusion.

The three elven sub-races with a bonus to int are:

Sun Elf: +2 int -2 con (Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting)
Gray Elf: +2 dex +2 int -2 con -2 str (Monster Manual)
Fire Elf: +2 dex +2 int -2 con -2 cha (Unearthed Arcana)

Note that they all have different stats, have different names, and come from different books.
Zaistars69

04-06-07, 03:49 PM
Sun elves and Gray Elves are actually two different races. Although, they are confused with each other all the time. The confusion dates back to the fact that their are less 10 races ever published by wotc with a bonus to int and LA +0; three of them are elven sub-races. With the plethora of elven sub-races, this will of course lead to some confusion.

The three elven sub-races with a bonus to int are:

Sun Elf: +2 int -2 con (Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting)
Gray Elf: +2 dex +2 int -2 con -2 str (Monster Manual)
Fire Elf: +2 dex +2 int -2 con -2 cha (Unearthed Arcana)

Note that they all have different stats, have different names, and come from different books.
Well I'll be darned.
Treymordin

04-06-07, 10:36 PM
I prefer the grey elves.
AZNsupermarket

04-06-07, 11:20 PM
I prefer the grey elves.

Gray elves are great, but I have always had a predisposition for fire elves because of the whole fire instead of hair thing (it just looks so cool!:cool:). From my own experiences, I have found that sun elves are almost never a better choice than fire elves or gray elves.
WayneTheGame

04-07-07, 09:30 AM
They're not the same. The Forgotten Realms campaign does not have Grey Elves (as per the MM); Sun Elves are the FR equivalent to Grey Elves just as Moon Elves are the equivalent to High Elves (FR doesn't have "High Elves" either, they have Moon Elves which just so happen to have the same racial abilities of the Core-D&D "High Elf").

To be technical about it, a Sun Elf should not be allowed in non-FR campaigns, just like a Grey Elf shouldn't be allowed IN an FR campaign.
AMGriffin

04-07-07, 11:05 AM
I prefer Sun elves myself, but purely from a balance perspective.
Treymordin

04-07-07, 05:12 PM
What do you mean?
Xinha

04-10-07, 07:44 AM
In wich book can I see the high elf characteristics?
Wolf72

04-10-07, 08:22 AM
the PHb or SRD ...

High Elf's are +2 dex, -2 con.

Sun Elves and Grey elves used to be the same stats back in 1e/2e ... similar type of culture too (stuck up, haughty)

the analogy went something like this:

Grey Elf ... Sun Elf ... Silvenesti Elf (your uppity-elfs)

High Elf ... Moon Elf ... Qualinesti Elf (your not-so-uppity elfs)

(that was from the 2e Book of Elves)
thepsionicbard

04-10-07, 11:02 AM
where can i find fire elves???
Xinha

04-10-07, 11:06 AM
Fire Elves :Unearthed Arcana.

I was confused about High Elves because in PHB they are simply called elves... and not high elves.
Thanks.