Exalted Feats in Antimagic Field. [Archive] - Wizards Community

Exalted Feats in Antimagic Field. [Archive] - Wizards Community

Post/Author/DateTime Post
Blackstorm_SK
03-14-08, 11:27 PM Does they work? It's something strange... Can anyone quote an official faq or similar that clarify the question? It seems to me strange that the exalted feats are actually supernatural, but on page 39 it say that exalted feats are supernatural in nature. Does this mean that if you have an exalted PrC and run into an AMF you lose the exalted feats (and thus ALL the benefits of the feats and the PrC)?
nameneeded
03-15-08, 12:26 AM When you read through the feats/ abilities some will say they are Supernatural and some say they are exrtaordinary. In an AMF the SU ones are negated.
risner
03-15-08, 02:27 AM Does they work?

Exalted feats are supernatural. Think about it, they come from a god or very powerful outsider. They can't be Ex and it doesn't make sense to be Sp, so they must be Su.

If AMF negates Su, then AMF negates all Exalted feats. There isn't any way around that. The DM is free to change it if he wishes just like he can say there are no elves in his world.
Nezkrul
03-18-08, 11:13 AM or that there is no AMF in his world... :P
jaelis
03-18-08, 11:19 AM Does this mean that if you have an exalted PrC and run into an AMF you lose the exalted feats (and thus ALL the benefits of the feats and the PrC)?
You don't actually lose the feats, you just can't use them in an AMF. So you would still meet your PrC prereqs and everything, and you could use any Ex abilities granted by the class.
NoldorForce
03-18-08, 12:39 PM Exalted feats are supernatural. Think about it, they come from a god or very powerful outsider. They can't be Ex and it doesn't make sense to be Sp, so they must be Su.

If AMF negates Su, then AMF negates all Exalted feats. There isn't any way around that. The DM is free to change it if he wishes just like he can say there are no elves in his world.Though Vow of Poverty is badly written, considering that it's a supernatural ability that grants multiple extraordinary abilities. So if you enter an AMF with it...your extraordinary stuff from VoP vanishes. Despite the fact that it's not supposed to because that's the ONLY distinction between the two sets of abilities.

Post/Author/DateTime	Post
Blackstorm_SK 03-14-08, 11:27 PM	Does they work? It's something strange... Can anyone quote an official faq or similar that clarify the question? It seems to me strange that the exalted feats are actually supernatural, but on page 39 it say that exalted feats are supernatural in nature. Does this mean that if you have an exalted PrC and run into an AMF you lose the exalted feats (and thus ALL the benefits of the feats and the PrC)?
nameneeded 03-15-08, 12:26 AM	When you read through the feats/ abilities some will say they are Supernatural and some say they are exrtaordinary. In an AMF the SU ones are negated.
risner 03-15-08, 02:27 AM	Does they work? Exalted feats are supernatural. Think about it, they come from a god or very powerful outsider. They can't be Ex and it doesn't make sense to be Sp, so they must be Su. If AMF negates Su, then AMF negates all Exalted feats. There isn't any way around that. The DM is free to change it if he wishes just like he can say there are no elves in his world.
Nezkrul 03-18-08, 11:13 AM	or that there is no AMF in his world... :P
jaelis 03-18-08, 11:19 AM	Does this mean that if you have an exalted PrC and run into an AMF you lose the exalted feats (and thus ALL the benefits of the feats and the PrC)? You don't actually lose the feats, you just can't use them in an AMF. So you would still meet your PrC prereqs and everything, and you could use any Ex abilities granted by the class.
NoldorForce 03-18-08, 12:39 PM	Exalted feats are supernatural. Think about it, they come from a god or very powerful outsider. They can't be Ex and it doesn't make sense to be Sp, so they must be Su. If AMF negates Su, then AMF negates all Exalted feats. There isn't any way around that. The DM is free to change it if he wishes just like he can say there are no elves in his world.Though Vow of Poverty is badly written, considering that it's a supernatural ability that grants multiple extraordinary abilities. So if you enter an AMF with it...your extraordinary stuff from VoP vanishes. Despite the fact that it's not supposed to because that's the ONLY distinction between the two sets of abilities.