am I any good? [Archive] - Wizards Community

Post/Author/DateTimePost
bandchick

04-29-07, 05:32 PM
I just started playing like last summer. I'm a level two Skeleton Necromancer and my party has loads of gp. I'm the only constant player in my party but I'm trying to get my two friends to start playing once every other week. My DM is my brother and we talk about D&D all the time and play it whenever we're bored and he has a dugeon ready. I think I'm OK at D&D but since I'm new it might just be my opinion...
trapspringer

04-29-07, 05:38 PM
Ok.

First things first, shorten your sig. It is great and all that you like fallout boy, but your signature is obnoxiously large.

Secondly, you can't actually be "good" at D&D, accepting of course being a particularly capable fun-haver. (That is to say, when one is "good" at a game, they are particularly adept and achieving some goal. The sole constant objective in D&D is to have fun.)

Third thing, you didn't actually tell us anything. If you are looking for some thoughts or opinions, you would need to tell us more than your class and level. There are hundreds of thousands of necromancers floating around, and each is a unique character, and further most are mechanically distinct.

Anyway. Welcome to the game and the boards.
Zorminster

04-29-07, 11:45 PM
fourth, you misspelled mountain Dew.

Good Dnd player = someone who enjoys the game and makes it more enjoyable for everyone playing
AffableDoomwalker

04-30-07, 12:25 AM
Fifth, Peter Wentz got knocked out by a bottle. Wuss.
Shan_TheBabau_Burke

04-30-07, 05:22 PM
Like the others already mentioned, if you are having fun, you are doing everything right!
Remembering the basic rules is a good shot too, but it's not as important, at least right away.
Sounds like you have an awesome brother just writing stuff up to play whenever.
Have a good time and if you have any questions ask the people on these boards. They will jeer at your sig and make fun of your spelling, but eventually, someone with good advice will come along to help.
Tell your bro if he's looking for ideas to check the Master DM Competitions. Those, as well as the other contests they have going on, are good places to look for inspiration.
Toast_recon

04-30-07, 08:31 PM
Ok.

First things first, shorten your sig. It is great and all that you like fallout boy, but your signature is obnoxiously large.

Amen Brother!
it is called spoilers!
type [sblocc]sig in here[/sblock]
just replace the second c with a k.
so you get this sig in here
as said before welcome to the boards!
Anyway, you can't be "good". Why?
because, you could be level 16, but only because your dm gives a s***load of xp, or has easy house rules, or only rolls the top half of the "Random" treasure chart( or maybe the bottom half, I can't remeber which gives the more treasure...) anyway, dnd is about haveing fun....as said before. SO basically I have nothing to add.......
YAY!!!!!!
see, that is how annoying your sig is.
I just wasted 5 minutes of your life!
trapspringer

04-30-07, 09:57 PM
Lucky for me I read fast and type faster. Your post only cost me about 55 seconds.
Aminvelos

04-30-07, 11:17 PM
Good for you.

(Woman Speaking) giggles, I love you. Hello?

Intro

Singer

Somethings missing in our life. I want you for my wife.
I love you too. Still I can’t help but think twice
The one on one is nice, It just won‘t do.

Chorusà

Throw away your dads morality
Your moms conventionality, it’s not for me.
If it were me and you and you and her and her and me we’d be so happy together
(Me and you and you and her and her and me) Backup Singers
Woah
Woah
Me and you and her

She could help you cook and clean
And she’d know just what you mean
(Someone who listens) Backup Singers
And as I snore away that night
Well she could always hold you tight
(It’s what we’re missing) Backup Singers

Chorus

Guitar Solo

Throw away your dads morality
Your moms conventionality, it’s not for me.
Because it’s me and you and you and her and her and me
We’ll be so happy together
(Me and you and you and her and her and me) Backup Singers
Woah
Woah
Me and you and her

Nothings missing in our lives. I got you for my wives.
I love you two.
AffableDoomwalker

05-01-07, 01:49 AM
Do we get a cookie if we name the band or something?

Or... is that just your signature?
Karish

05-01-07, 08:25 AM
Well, if you are having fun in the game and you aren't making things rough or not fun for other players, then you're doing fine for now.

I suggest getting a somewhat smaller signature though, it will not be making you any friends.
trapspringer

05-01-07, 02:57 PM
Do we get a cookie if we name the band or something?

Or... is that just your signature?

I think it was an attempt at a pick-up line. :rolleyes:
MrSpaceBear

05-01-07, 03:04 PM
Ah..... nerd love. :love: How cute and geeky. :clap: Like ugly Betty. :D
Toast_recon

05-01-07, 03:20 PM
I believe the OP has abandoned us..... Guess she thought our answers were to corny.
ANd as for you trapspriger, I assumed any one who read as fast as that would have been smart enough not to read my post after they saw a big red YAY at the bottom.
And yes, 5 minutes would be waaaayyyy below average.
tahngarth40

05-01-07, 03:52 PM
I don't think this is a 2nd level skeleton necromancer

I'm pretty sure its a 3rd level troll bard (their DM doesn't make them use HD or level adjustments)
trapspringer

05-01-07, 05:06 PM
I believe the OP has abandoned us..... Guess she thought our answers were to corny.
ANd as for you trapspriger, I assumed any one who read as fast as that would have been smart enough not to read my post after they saw a big red YAY at the bottom.
And yes, 5 minutes would be waaaayyyy below average.

Eesh, that sounded a little more spiteful than seems necessary. What gives? Did I say something to **** you off?
Toast_recon

05-01-07, 06:00 PM
Sorry about that. I was going for a stern schoolteacher kind of ring. sorry if I sounded too spiteful. 'cause I love you man!:pint:
You know, now rereading it, it does sound a little like I am a jacka**. Sorry for the misunderstanding. (did I say sorry yet?;))
trapspringer

05-01-07, 09:26 PM
....

No problem, dude. Just askin'.
AffableDoomwalker

05-02-07, 01:41 AM
This thread is made of epic and win.

Kind of.
Toast_recon

05-02-07, 04:33 PM
....
hmm, when did I say that?....Oh, you are good. How do you quote into the future?
I am kinda ticked right now though. Not at you, just at some people in the mirror image thread.
AtmaWeapon

05-02-07, 04:35 PM
How do I mine for fish?
Toast_recon

05-02-07, 05:15 PM
How do I mine for fish?

ahhh, the classics.
DM_Anubis

05-02-07, 08:10 PM
Its a fact that is stated in the players guide that if you like fall out boy you cant be good at dnd. sorry
Magrus

05-02-07, 08:25 PM
I just started playing like last summer. I'm a level two Skeleton Necromancer and my party has loads of gp. I'm the only constant player in my party but I'm trying to get my two friends to start playing once every other week. My DM is my brother and we talk about D&D all the time and play it whenever we're bored and he has a dugeon ready. I think I'm OK at D&D but since I'm new it might just be my opinion...

Yeah, it's entirely subjective on what "good" is. It's different for everyone. For example, it's different to be a stereotypical "good player" and a stereotypical "good DM". Then, there are different stereotypes, and on top of that, many different variations. That covers the common ground. There are then the more uncommon variations, and the rare ones that everyone considers strange, but they love how they play, so they don't care.

All in all, that's like asking if you are a good person. Highly subjective and, well, just have fun. Don't worry about being "good" if you are actually having fun. When the fun stops, thats when you get all worried and analytical. ;)

Anyhow, welcome, and what in all hell is Fallout Boy? Some guy that survived a nuclear test site disaster and started a band or something? Argh, I feel old. :weep:
AffableDoomwalker

05-03-07, 01:25 AM
How do I mine for fish?

The same way you shot web.
bandchick

05-06-07, 09:49 PM
I believe the OP has abandoned us..... Guess she thought our answers were to corny.
ANd as for you trapspriger, I assumed any one who read as fast as that would have been smart enough not to read my post after they saw a big red YAY at the bottom.
And yes, 5 minutes would be waaaayyyy below average.

sowwy, i diddnt abondon you, i just cant get on the internet on weekdays!
bandchick

05-06-07, 09:55 PM
Yeah, it's entirely subjective on what "good" is. It's different for everyone. For example, it's different to be a stereotypical "good player" and a stereotypical "good DM". Then, there are different stereotypes, and on top of that, many different variations. That covers the common ground. There are then the more uncommon variations, and the rare ones that everyone considers strange, but they love how they play, so they don't care.

All in all, that's like asking if you are a good person. Highly subjective and, well, just have fun. Don't worry about being "good" if you are actually having fun. When the fun stops, thats when you get all worried and analytical. ;)

Anyhow, welcome, and what in all hell is Fallout Boy? Some guy that survived a nuclear test site disaster and started a band or something? Argh, I feel old. :weep:


Fallout Boy= GOOD BAND!!! :) lol and I diddnt undersand some of the words you used there so uh I feel stupid and therefor we make eachother feel bad :)!
bandchick

05-06-07, 09:58 PM
I think it was an attempt at a pick-up line. :rolleyes:

Band as in.... I play the clarinet in my school band and I am going to be in marching band next year kinda band! GOSH! lol!
trapspringer

05-06-07, 10:38 PM
...
trapspringer

05-06-07, 10:40 PM
...
trapspringer

05-06-07, 10:41 PM
NM, that came off as harsh.

My post was in response to the recitation by Amnivelos or what ever his name was.
AffableDoomwalker

05-06-07, 11:35 PM
It was back in '49 when times were hard,
he had a colt .45 and a deck of cards,
Stagger Lee...
Toast_recon

05-09-07, 04:50 PM
trapspringer, you realize that in arguing about triple posting you triple posted, right? Or was that the irony you were going for?
trapspringer

05-09-07, 05:18 PM
"Edited for triple posting and lack of content."

Better?

'Course now that's four whole posts on not a whole lot. Some moderator should really delete some of that....
Toast_recon

05-09-07, 05:30 PM
{please imagine the following in an explaining voice, not a hostile one}
well, you didn't have to then post a follow up post on how you edited, it would have been a double post otherwise, and yes, I wrote my last post aware of your reason for editing.
you had one post"..."
then another post"...." Edited, and obviously deleted,
and a third post explaining why you edited.
Why not have the second post say"EDIT: I deleted this because it seemed hostile" instead of creating another post, thus triple posting. I am not trying to sound hostile, keep that in mind.
Enchanter_Tom

05-09-07, 05:33 PM
Thread closure imminent.
trapspringer

05-09-07, 09:43 PM
Ibtl!

...oh, wait.
AffableDoomwalker

05-10-07, 02:18 AM
Some things we plan, we sit and we invent and we plot and cook up; others are works of inspiration, of poetry...
Fend

05-10-07, 02:49 AM
:) kudos for becoming more nerdy.

If only we all had a sister like you. =le shame=

PS. Fallout boy rulez.
Sunic_Flames

05-10-07, 08:27 AM
...I think it's about time this thread be deluged in fire. *starts casting meteor swarm... repeatedly*
trapspringer

05-10-07, 02:21 PM
Well, you didn't have to then post a follow up post on how you edited, it would have been a double post otherwise, and yes, I wrote my last post aware of your reason for editing.


Because it was a triple post. Three posts were posted, only one of which was necessary. There was no additional postage of any kind (save for the explanations and spam which were to follow).
Toast_recon

05-10-07, 09:00 PM
never mind, this is just like arguing about who started an argument:completely pointless. It doesn't matter what happened and it is useless trying to get a point accross that even if we resolved the argument it wouldn't make a difference.
trapspringer

05-10-07, 11:58 PM
never mind, this is just like arguing about who started an argument:completely pointless. It doesn't matter what happened and it is useless trying to get a point accross that even if we resolved the argument it wouldn't make a difference.

+1

Also, good show.
AffableDoomwalker

05-11-07, 03:21 AM
Where is Mona? (shes long gone...) Where is Michael? Where is Mark? Where is Matthew? - Now its getting dark... Oh, where is Joan? They're all out back, under fifteen feet of pure white snow...
bandchick

05-19-07, 11:04 PM
ummmmm.... this is getting to be a VERY random thread! and ummm... thank you for posting... i think....:confused: lol, jk!

lovey doveys,
Bandchick, lolololololol!
Magrus

05-19-07, 11:20 PM
Fallout Boy= GOOD BAND!!! :) lol and I diddnt undersand some of the words you used there so uh I feel stupid and therefor we make eachother feel bad :)!

What words didn't you understand? Maybe I can help.
AffableDoomwalker

05-20-07, 02:46 AM
... and the mercy seat is waitin, and I think my head is burning, and in a way I'm yearning... to be done with all this measuring of truth; an eye for an eye; a tooth for a tooth. And anyway I told the truth. And I'm not afraid to die.
bandchick

05-25-07, 11:56 PM
What words didn't you understand? Maybe I can help.
ummm... analytical..... and ummmm... subjective.... i dunno, im kinda retarted... :)
sensestaker

05-26-07, 12:11 AM
If you've been playing since last summer and you're still only level 2 then no, I'm sorry, you're not very good.:P
UltimateReality

05-26-07, 02:30 PM
ummm... analytical..... and ummmm... subjective....
Because I'm not articulate enough to explain word meanings, I'll direct you to this website instead: www.dictionary.com
MCage

05-26-07, 02:44 PM
Even if the jetski loses a wheel while it flies off the mountain it still requires the same amount of pancakes to cover the doghouse.
AffableDoomwalker

05-27-07, 01:56 AM
Well, then in came a sailior with
mermaids tattooed on his arms,
Followed by the man with the wing-nut ears
who was waitin' in the car
Well, Robert Moore sensed trouble,
he'd seen it comin' from afar
and Betty Coltrain she gasped beneath the table.
Enigmous

05-27-07, 02:39 AM
am I any good?

No.
PwnageLlama

05-27-07, 01:34 PM
Are you asking if your character is optimized?
If so, you will need to post much more info on your character.
AffableDoomwalker

05-31-07, 02:59 AM
oh come on now, why remove the Abattoir Blues lyrics? Oy veigh... true poetry is so unappreciated nowadays... or... did I even post them at all? Deja Vu?

Meh, who knows... regradless...

Come sail your ships around me,
And burn your bridges down,
We make a little history, baby,
Every time you come around.
Come loose your dogs upon me,
And let your hair hang down,
You are a little mystery to me,
Every time you come around.
maharai23

05-31-07, 07:32 PM
Any good? Well, there's a lot of hallmarks that denote an experienced character, and some people find that some are more important than others. Here's a few.

1) Meta = Bad. Metagaming is essentially using player knowledge that your character wouldn't have, and using it as if he did have it. This is usually a failing of people that have a firm grasp of the rules, but not as firm a grasp on character development and such. As such, it's not a newbie mistake, more of a sophomore error.

2) Sophomoric humor has its place. Sure, it's funny at first, but you're gonna get tired of being known as the great "Medium Rary" by 15th level. Some groups like this, and if yours does, great. If not, then it falls into number 3.

3) Play well with others. Do you find yourself on the lising side of a lot of arguements? What about the winning? You shouldn't be on either in game. Why? Cause when D&D devolves into rules arguements, it usually ceases to be fun. Accept the DM ruling, bring it up later. Also in this area, learn whether you like rich storylines, glorious cracked out battles, or a blend, and find players that suit that.

4) Rules competency. Comes with time, and even experienced players may be less familiar with non standard interactions.

5) Be prepared. Whether you're bringin' Doritos, planning a backup character for a particularly unforgiving campaign, or just playing your character, have it on hand when needed. Especially with spells and critters. That way, if clarification is needed, it doesn't take up time.


The number one goal in D&D is to have fun. Keeping things moving smoothly and either being with compatible players, or learning to be compatible, these are major parts of that. So anything you can do to further those is generally a step in the right direction.
Toast_recon

06-07-07, 08:36 PM
and band chick, you still haven't made your sig less obnoxious.
Put it in sblocks!!! people will still read it and space will be saved. How would you like it if I Always typed REAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLY BBBBBBBBBIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGGGGGGGGGG?
Edit: ok, now reallly big in sblocks!
UltimateReality

06-08-07, 03:11 AM
Toast Recon, you made the baby jebus cry.

Why did you has to break my pageview?!

http://www.garmentdistrict.com/store/popculture/familyguy/poster_9097.jpg
AffableDoomwalker

06-08-07, 04:06 AM
Go son, go down to the water
And see the women weeping there
Then go up into the mountains
The men, they are weeping too

Father, why are all the women weeping?
They are weeping for their men
Then why are all the men there weeping?
They are weeping back at them

This is a weeping song
A song in which to weep
While all the men and women sleep
This is a weeping song
But I won't be weeping long