The ignore feature seems to be working selectively.

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

opskt

Jun 28, 2010 12:05:42
I have about 12-15 people on my block list. As the list grows it seems that the boards are more selective about when it blocks those people's posts. In some threads, Block X will not show, while Block Y does, then in a different thread, X will show while Y will not.

The block feature is kinda useless if it still lets you see 25% of the stupid.
#2

salla

Jun 28, 2010 12:24:37
I have about 12-15 people on my block list. As the list grows it seems that the boards are more selective about when it blocks those people's posts. In some threads, Block X will not show, while Block Y does, then in a different thread, X will show while Y will not.

The block feature is kinda useless if it still lets you see 25% of the stupid.



I'm in the same boat, with about ten times as many people I don't care about (though most of them don't post at all anymore).
#3

opskt

Jun 28, 2010 12:40:50
Then they need to either fix it or stop censuring me from calling BS on the stupids.
#4

calronmoonflower

Jun 29, 2010 1:30:56
Still! I've heard these complaints sense about the time the new board came online.

Posting here might get a VCL to push this with WotC, but unless that happens they are not likely to hear about it from this thread. I suggest that everyone with this problem e-mail Customer Service and include as much detail as possible.
#5

Webster

Jun 29, 2010 2:20:57
I'll bring it to their attention.
#6

kalastos

Jul 05, 2010 11:24:11
The block feature is kinda useless if it still lets you see 25% of the stupid.



I'm just excited to discover that there is an ignore equiv, period.  I haven't been on these boards for very long but have already built up a list of posters who I would rather be blissfully ignorant of their existance but I'll settle for 75% less of them for the moment. 
#7

sevoo

Jul 13, 2010 19:29:51
Apparently, according to the "Online Response Crew," this feature doesn't exist:

Thank you for contacting us. The ignore feature on our forums will only prevent people from private messaging you. I apologize for any offensive posts that you are seeing. I will pass along your concern to the web team as feedback and a request for a new feature. Though I cannot guarantee a direct response I can assure you that they will receive it.

Thank you for your cooperation and understanding in this matter.

I have no idea what that's supposed to mean, since a number of us are seeing some-but-not-all posts blocked in the forums, once we've blocked someone.  I followed up with them, providing a screenshot of an actual blocked post on an actual public forum.  Not heard a response yet.
#8

EscherEnigma

Jul 13, 2010 19:43:20
... they denied that when you block someone you stop seeing (most) of their posts and just get a message that you have that person blocked?  That's... curious...
#9

calronmoonflower

Jul 14, 2010 1:48:38
Alrighty, take a screen cap of a blocked post and another screen cap of the same poster that is not blocked.
Update your complaint with the info that posts are sometimes blocked by the ignore feature and attach the screen caps to prove it.
#10

WotC_Michelle

Jul 15, 2010 14:58:36
The “block” function prevents the member from contacting you. It does not block their posts from your view. If it appears to be blocking posts from time to time, it is likely that those posts were moderated. If someone is abusing the code of conduct, please report the post and/or the user.
#11

WotC_Michelle

Jul 15, 2010 15:00:38
Also, if you *do* have any details that suggest the behavior is partially functioning as you described, please send them to me so that we can investigate.
#12

EscherEnigma

Jul 15, 2010 16:12:09
The “block” function prevents the member from contacting you. It does not block their posts from your view. If it appears to be blocking posts from time to time, it is likely that those posts were moderated. If someone is abusing the code of conduct, please report the post and/or the user.


... really?  So what do you say to this?

#13

WotC_Michelle

Jul 15, 2010 16:23:50
The “block” function prevents the member from contacting you. It does not block their posts from your view. If it appears to be blocking posts from time to time, it is likely that those posts were moderated. If someone is abusing the code of conduct, please report the post and/or the user.


... really?  So what do you say to this?

#14

calronmoonflower

Jul 16, 2010 2:08:31
Perfect. That's exactly the information I needed to troubleshoot this...thanks
Looks like a feature that we didn't specifically ask for (at least not recently), but that we quietly got as a benefit of work done for the whole platform. I will pass this along to the forums developer and we will sort out the bug.

What? Are quietly added benefites common in the programming business?

It might not have been added. It could be a part of the standard package and the feature overlooked.

Then again, they could have accidentally added it as well.
#15

Zireael

Jul 16, 2010 5:07:13
Perfect. That's exactly the information I needed to troubleshoot this...thanks
Looks like a feature that we didn't specifically ask for (at least not recently), but that we quietly got as a benefit of work done for the whole platform.   I will pass this along to the forums developer and we will sort out the bug.

I may need some examples of users or posts that are not working. Thanks for your help.



"Sort out the bug"? I hope that stays. Because being able to block some idiotic posts and people who start flame wars is a good thing.

#16

zombie_babies

Jul 16, 2010 8:13:51
Yeah, that's pretty much exactly how the Ignore/Block feature worked on the old forums.  Seems to me like it'd have been something added on purpose, but who knows.  At any rate, it's imperative that the block function blocks posts because that's why people use it.  Helps a hell of a lot with avoiding arguments, you know.
#17

Dane_McArdy

Jul 16, 2010 9:18:33
The “block” function prevents the member from contacting you. It does not block their posts from your view. If it appears to be blocking posts from time to time, it is likely that those posts were moderated. If someone is abusing the code of conduct, please report the post and/or the user.


... really?  So what do you say to this?

#18

WotC_Michelle

Jul 16, 2010 12:01:00
 What? Are quietly added benefites common in the programming business?




Not usually, which is why I too-confidently described how the block feature used to work without double checking to see if there was a change I wasn't aware of. There are two kinds of feature enhancements we get to our site: The ones that we request, plan, and schedule, and the ones that we get "for free" as a benefit of working with a software as a service company that regularly makes upgrades for other clients or to improve their core platform. We are usually notified of both kinds of changes before they roll out, but sometimes one slips through.

To clarify, I'm not trying to remove the feature (we've had many requests to have "block user" work like the vBulletin forums did), I'm just looking into why it doesn't work consistently.

Thanks all!
#19

calronmoonflower

Jul 17, 2010 2:37:36
@WotC_Michelle: You messed up your quote tags in that last post.
#20

XunValDorl_of_HouseKilsek

Jul 17, 2010 5:50:28
@WotC_Michelle: You messed up your quote tags in that last post.

Shut up! She is a professional!




Not knowing after all this time that there is an option that lets you ignore other users kind of makes me wonder. 
#21

WotC_Michelle

Jul 19, 2010 11:51:06
 
@WotC_Michelle: You messed up your quote tags in that last post.

Shut up! She is a professional!




Not knowing after all this time that there is an option that lets you ignore other users kind of makes me wonder. 




That's fair
We got many requests for an ignore feature right when we launched because block user *didn't* work that way. I looked into it at the time & we weren't able to get it changed then. I'm glad that it has rolled out despite the confusion, and I didn't notice because I don't ignore people on the site
#22

kilpatds

Jul 19, 2010 14:19:34
It's worked this way for ... quite a while.  I first checked not that long after the rollout...