What happend to my post?

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

lokiare

Jun 02, 2009 22:29:02
Where did my post go? did it get moved? it was the petition post. Weird.

Was the server reset? I really don't know what happened to it. I can't find it anywhere even using the forum search tool. Oh well I posted it again at EnWorld for anyone interested in what it had to say.
#2

mudbunny

Jun 02, 2009 22:30:03
Where did my post go? did it get moved? it was the petition post. Weird.

Was the server reset? I really don't know what happened to it. I can't find it anywhere even using the forum search tool. Oh well I posted it again at EnWorld for anyone interested in what it had to say.

Petitions are against the CoC and are removed.
#3

whitebaron

Jun 03, 2009 8:48:37
i can see nothing in the coc that supports this statement by bunny.


as for removed posts: usually you should get an email to the adress you entered when registering to the forums when this happens.

if this did not happen, someone violated the ORC-rules - they always have to tell you why they did such stuff.
#4

mudbunny

Jun 03, 2009 8:57:38
i can see nothing in the coc that supports this statement by bunny.

Polls and petitions are considered disruptive and are thus against the CoC.
#5

Mock

Jun 03, 2009 9:04:40
i can see nothing in the coc that supports this statement by bunny.


as for removed posts: usually you should get an email to the adress you entered when registering to the forums when this happens.

if this did not happen, someone violated the ORC-rules - they always have to tell you why they did such stuff.

This is true. I got one when I posted text from a feat; it does depend on having a working email address in the system. Lokiare should have received such a thing.
#6

whitebaron

Jun 03, 2009 9:12:56
Polls and petitions are considered disruptive and are thus against the CoC.

looked it up - polls are just mentioned as part of "spam". i can go by the definition that this petition was spam, as it just included stuff like "signed", but just saying such stuff is outright not allowed is NOT what is written within the coc.
#7

mudbunny

Jun 03, 2009 12:05:55
Not sure what more I can tell you. Any type of poll or petition (unless started by WotC or with their approval) has always (or at least as long as I have been a regular on the boards, so about 2 years now) been considered disruptive and been removed, no matter the subject of the poll.

As this is getting fairly off-topic for the DDI General forum, Iwill be moving this thread to the D&D -> D&D HQ -> Community Business forum, where it is on-topic, and the people are much more knowledgeable about it.
#8

RUMPLESTIX

Jun 04, 2009 21:51:04
This is true. I got one when I posted text from a feat; it does depend on having a working email address in the system. Lokiare should have received such a thing.

Are you saying that we can't post such things in these forums?

So, does that mean if we wish to discuss how the wording of a feat should be interpreted (such as in what's a dm to do...) then we have to discuss it without actually saying (by that I mean posting, but I think you get it...) what it is we are discussing?
#9

Mock

Jun 04, 2009 22:09:45
Are you saying that we can't post such things in these forums?

So, does that mean if we wish to discuss how the wording of a feat should be interpreted (such as in what's a dm to do...) then we have to discuss it without actually saying (by that I mean posting, but I think you get it...) what it is we are discussing?

Well...if I recall, there was a discussion of a feat, in which another poster asserted that a feat meant Interpretation A but claimed that to post the text to illustrate Interpretation A would violate copyright and EULA and Code of Conduct and such.

Other posters including myself asserted that in fact, the feat as written supported Interpretation B, and - having seen it done elsewhere in these forums - I posted the text of the feat for clarity in the discussion. About 10 minutes later, I got an email that posting copyrighted material was a CoC violation, and the post was edited by one of the ORCs to remove the feat text.

Personally, I suspect that someone simply did the responsible thing and reported that my post violated the CoC.
#10

eldritch_lord

Jun 04, 2009 22:54:50
Other posters including myself asserted that in fact, the feat as written supported Interpretation B, and - having seen it done elsewhere in these forums - I posted the text of the feat for clarity in the discussion. About 10 minutes later, I got an email that posting copyrighted material was a CoC violation, and the post was edited by one of the ORCs to remove the feat text.

First, posting the exact text of the feat for purposes of discussion has always (well, until recently, I suppose) been considered fair use and thus not infringement; second, you're correct that others do so all the time, and whether posting the text infringement or not that's an example of inconsistent moderation, which isn't very nice either.

What exactly is a violation of the CoC seems to depend on the posters and WizOs/ORCs involved as well as the context of the discussion...but polls have always been against it as Mudbunny said, no exceptions, so it's safe to say that's why the OP's post was removed.
#11

Mock

Jun 05, 2009 7:01:20
First, posting the exact text of the feat for purposes of discussion has always (well, until recently, I suppose) been considered fair use and thus not infringement; second, you're correct that others do so all the time, and whether posting the text infringement or not that's an example of inconsistent moderation, which isn't very nice either.

What exactly is a violation of the CoC seems to depend on the posters and WizOs/ORCs involved as well as the context of the discussion...but polls have always been against it as Mudbunny said, no exceptions, so it's safe to say that's why the OP's post was removed.

My guess is that the post was reported, and once reported, the ORC's must take action on it. It's not that big a deal (I mean, that issue wasn't that big a deal, obviously - a rules argument does not herald the End of Days).