So, how do you pronounce "Mul?"

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

Tal-eth

Jun 18, 2010 16:10:14
Does "Mul" rhyme with "dull" or "yule?"

Thanks!
#2

scottmcmillan

Jun 18, 2010 16:18:51
Everyone I know always said it like "yule," as in mule, which makes sense if you think about it.
#3

xlorep_darkhelm

Jun 18, 2010 16:22:54
Does "Mul" rhyme with "dull" or "yule?"

Thanks!



I have always pronounced it like "mule", as that is a reference to a sterile, yet strong beast of burden made by crossbreeding horses and donkeys. And an Athasian Mul is a sterile, yet strong race (frequently slaves, or "beasts of burden" if you will) made by crossbreeding Humans with Dwarves. Seems to make sense to me.
#4

ascottbay

Jun 18, 2010 16:51:10
D&DXP Seminar Podcast 4, time index 41 minutes, Rich Baker says it's pronounced like dull, and that the book will include the pronunciation in parenthetical.
#5

diggles

Jun 18, 2010 16:56:26
Mul, like Dull. everyone I know uses that pronunciation
#6

ian.thomson

Jun 18, 2010 17:00:16
While the name "mul" is obviously derived from the word "mule," because they dropped off the E I kinda feel like it should be pronounced differently.  Since there aren't mules on Athas, if it was pronounced the same they could have just used "mule."

Then again, I will alternate between "Pea-can", "Peh-can," or "Peh-kahn" depending on whether it's just a nut, a bunch of nuts, a cookie, a candy, or a pie.  I'm a southerner that loves Chinese food and Mexican food, raised by a mother with a degree in English and a babysitter that spoke Gullah, and most of the television I watch is either mostly British casts or stars either Arnold Schwarzenegger, Dolph Lundgren, or Keanu Reeves.  Pronounce whatever you want however you want to.
#7

sir_sparhawk

Jun 18, 2010 17:26:22
I've always used the "Dull" proununciation.  What makes the "Mule" sound like "Mule" is the "e" in "Mule."  There's no "e" in "Mul" so it's pronounced "Mul" as in "Dull." 


lol...confused yet?
#8

phoenix_m

Jun 18, 2010 17:36:17
Sorry to say I'm (as is everyone else I game with) in dull group also, though iirc the proper pronounciation does rhyme yule, which never sounded right to me.
#9

Pennarin

Jun 18, 2010 17:45:19
I always got Mul(e).

But once I (french-speaking) went to Nathan's (NytCrawlr) house in the US, where we met up with Corey (Mach2.5) also from the US, and pronounciations came up in the conversation and you wouldn't believe the differences. It was amazing.

Just imagine saying Andropinis...
#10

xlorep_darkhelm

Jun 18, 2010 17:59:41
I always got Mul(e).

But once I (french-speaking) went to Nathan's (NytCrawlr) house in the US, where we met up with Corey (Mach2.5) also from the US, and pronounciations came up in the conversation and you wouldn't believe the differences. It was amazing.

Just imagine saying Andropinis...



I always pronounce Andropinis as very similar to "Metropolis" (replacing the ol with in)
#11

ludwig5

Jun 18, 2010 18:01:20
dull for me ,but I'm italian
#12

diggles

Jun 18, 2010 19:47:19
Mool for me ,but I'm italian



Fixed for you

#13

Silverblade_The_Enchanter

Jun 18, 2010 19:47:46
yeah always said "mul" as in "Mull it over", "muhl" 
iirc thats' what the original boxed set SAID it was prpnounced

however, I always saw "drow" as "Thr ow ", "droh", me being Scot's it's long on the "rrr" hehe. officially itis "drow as in cow" which I hate so I stick to "droh"

for ages I thought "Melee" was spoken as "me lee", where as it should be said "May lay" or rather "mayhh lay"? I got german not french at school *shrugs*
#14

outlaw68

Jun 18, 2010 21:16:16
I have always pronounced it and heard it pronounce Mul(e), if my memory serves me correctly, one of the books actually suggests that is the correct spelling (or it may have been a dragon article - or even a sage advice column?)..

Besides, I am not sure about overseas, but in Australia "mul" (like Dull) is a nick name for pot.. 
#15

firesnakearies

Jun 18, 2010 21:26:36
I pronounce it like "mule", I always have.  That's how the original creators of Dark Sun pronounced it.  It was at one time the official pronunciation.

 Now, however, the 4th edition guys have officially declared that it's pronounced like "mull".  So that'll be the "correct" answer according to authorities.

I'm still gonna pronounce it "mule" though. 
#16

diggles

Jun 18, 2010 21:35:59
I pronounce it like "mule", I always have.  That's how the original creators of Dark Sun pronounced it.  It was at one time the official pronunciation.

 Now, however, the 4th edition guys have officially declared that it's pronounced like "mull".  So that'll be the "correct" answer according to authorities.

I'm still gonna pronounce it "mule" though. 



You're as stubborn as a MUL!
#17

greyorm

Jun 18, 2010 21:57:56
I've always pronounced it Mull, even though I know it's supposed to be pronounced Mule. Just liked the former better.
#18

nimblegrund

Jun 19, 2010 1:15:01
I pronounced it "mull" for a very long time, but once I found out about the 2nd edition pronounciation, "mule" made a lot of sense.

However, I can also see why wizards may want to distance themselves from an etymology that compares a person with a mule.
#19

MrCelsius

Jun 19, 2010 4:55:29
     I don't think anyone in this thread has gone with the pronunciation I had settled on; 'mool' with the 'oo' of 'book' rather than of 'fool'.  Mul as rhyming with 'pull'.  That way it's not homonymous with extant words 'mull' or 'mule' and is thus more easily distinguished as a word.  Besides, I like the sound/feel of the word a lot more my way, and it feels more exotic/characteristic if it doesn't sound like a word which already exists.
#20

ChrisTheS

Jun 19, 2010 10:11:23
I always thought it should be spelled mûl, but then I like accent marks :P
#21

Duke5150

Jun 20, 2010 1:28:39

Don't ask why, but I pronounce it like "dual". Mual.
Wink

#22

freeborntoad

Jun 20, 2010 12:56:43

I know it was originally intended to be pronounced just like "mule", but I never favored that pronunciation.


"Mull" for me.

#23

nomoremaybes

Jun 20, 2010 18:26:25

Don't ask why, but I pronounce it like "dual". Mual.




This is what I was wondering too. I too, think it should be an "ool" sound, but is it m-yool (like mule) or just mool (like tool [unless you prounounce it as ty-ool {in which case, you probably have bigger problems to deal with}])?
#24

Duke5150

Jun 21, 2010 0:18:42

Yeah, That's basically how I say it. Sounds like tool, like toolbelt. Mool.

#25

RalofTyr

Jun 21, 2010 0:51:30
In Soviet Athas, Mul pronounces you.
#26

nomoremaybes

Jun 21, 2010 0:52:04
Can't wait to get my level 4 Mul-Belt of pronunciation!
#27

Pennarin

Jun 21, 2010 12:23:54
In Soviet Athas, psionics think you.
#28

cadence73

Jun 21, 2010 12:50:57
It 2nd edition it was pronounced "mule" like the animal, it was actually pointed out in one of the Dark Sun sourcebooks.

I've been calling them mules for 19 years, it'll be interesting to see what they say officially.
#29

crabheart

Jun 21, 2010 13:39:15

I just read it in the ad&d wanderers journal pronounced Mül

as in rule, youth, union \'yün-y&n\, few \'fyü\. As an unstressed vowel before another vowel, \ü\ is often pronounced as a schwa with slight lip rounding that is separated from the following vowel by the glide \w\, as valuing \'val-y&-wi[ng]\. This reduced variant is not usually shown at individual entries. Younger speakers of American English often use a more centralized and less rounded pronunciation of \ü\ in certain words (as news and musician), both in stressed and especially in unstressed syllables.

This just proves how stupid our english spelling is. (enuf is enuf, enough is too much!)

Myool = mule 

muul = mouth makes a frowny face
mool = mouth makes a kissy face

#30

guest689870068

Jun 21, 2010 15:40:23
I always pronounced it "half dwarf".
#31

Duke5150

Jun 21, 2010 16:18:58
I always pronounced it "half dwarf".



lol, which is completely correct.
#32

jknevitt

Jul 05, 2010 9:12:22
My group always pronounced it "mool". Even now, saying "mule" just seems silly and "mull" seems clumsy.
#33

Duskweaver

Jul 05, 2010 9:25:47
Mul as rhyming with 'pull'.


That's how I've always pronounced it too. So you're not alone. ;)
#34

Earthdawn

Jul 07, 2010 9:21:52

Here in NoVA (Northern Virginia), everyone I game with pronounces "Mul" as if it rhymed with "Cool".

I disagree it should rhyme with "Dull" when pronounced.  It lacks the second L and thus wouldn't have any emphasis at the end of the word.  All the emphasis would be on the vowel.

#35

imperialx

Jul 07, 2010 11:22:24
Does "Mul" rhyme with "dull" or "yule?"

Thanks!

i'd pronounce it like dull but thats just my opinion >.>
#36

wraith_form

Jul 10, 2010 3:16:54
     I don't think anyone in this thread has gone with the pronunciation I had settled on; 'mool' with the 'oo' of 'book' rather than of 'fool'.  Mul as rhyming with 'pull'.  That way it's not homonymous with extant words 'mull' or 'mule' and is thus more easily distinguished as a word.  Besides, I like the sound/feel of the word a lot more my way, and it feels more exotic/characteristic if it doesn't sound like a word which already exists.




This ^ FTW.