Post/Author/DateTime	Post
#1 Sorsohka Aug 06, 2015 5:01:35	In one of the expedition you can find a spellbook with the silence spell, a spell NOT on the wizard spell list Show boltmelter book
#2 Pauper Aug 06, 2015 7:43:55	That would seem to be the simplest solution -- simply remove silence from the spellbook, since there's no legal way for it to get there in the first place, and even if you hand-wave it being there, a wizard can't copy it into her own spellbook, as it's not a wizard spell.   -- Pauper
#3 SteveMND Aug 06, 2015 9:05:48	Pauper wrote:
(Reply to #3) Pauper	SteveMND wrote:
#5 transcendantviewer Aug 06, 2015 11:07:09	Silence is a Ritual Spell on the Cleric Spell List. Just rule that it's a Ritual Book. Or maybe even just make it a Spell Scroll that's in addition to the book. Does that resolve the issue? I don't actually know, since I don't know the adventure, but that's what I'd go with.
#6 abanathie Aug 06, 2015 11:12:45	Silence could be copied by a book warlock with the right invocation or a character with the ritual caster feat.
(Reply to #5) Pauper	transcendantviewer wrote:
#8 Sorsohka Aug 06, 2015 11:32:59	the issues is not how to handle the book, the issue was how to reward it to the player and I got my answer, the wizard cannot copy the silence spell, and untill they bring a subclass cleric that use a prayer book for his spell the mention of the written silence spell is purely RP and have no mechanic effect. Just like saying the first page of the bok have a reference the the shoe siz of the owner.
#9 ZHDarkstar Aug 06, 2015 12:41:41	Since we're on the topic of learning spells from recovered spellbooks/ritual books, was there ever a ruling made about the cantrips in the 1-14 spellbook?
#10 Kalani Aug 06, 2015 12:52:42	You cannot learn cantrips via spell scribing. The AL rule allows copying spells as a downtime activity - it does not alter the rules of how copying a spell works. As such, characters must follow the rules for copying a spell into their spellbook (wizard sidebar), Ritual Book, or Book of Ancient Secrets   Copying a Spell into the Book. When you find a wizard spell of 1st level or higher, you can add it to your spellbook if it is of a level for which you have spell slots and if you can spare the time to decipher and copy it.
#11 ZHDarkstar Aug 06, 2015 13:09:34	Gotcha, I'll just assume that they were a typo then.
#12 Coredump00 Aug 06, 2015 14:23:37	IIRC I just saw a season 2 NPC spellbook with cantrips in it also...
#13 Ravix Aug 06, 2015 17:10:09	Maybe they just like to write it down so they don't forget? I mean, you wrote down your cantrips on your spellbook...right?
#14 ZHDarkstar Aug 06, 2015 18:22:21	Ravix wrote:
#15 Ravix Aug 06, 2015 18:27:37	ZHDarkstar wrote: