| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1Style75Feb 04, 2010 13:41:41 | A stroke of genius is how I describe the new RedBox D&D set. My greatest dnd memory of all time is my mom buying me the old red box, sitting on the floor of my bedroom and flipping through those pages. I still have it today, 25 years later, and it holds a place of honor on my bookshelf. I think this is brilliant marketing. Thousands of people like myself grew up with the RedBox and now have kids of their own. I can't wait until my son is old enough to start playing (right now he'd eat the dice) so I can buy him his own RedBox. Yes, people will complain about dumbing down the rules to attract the playstation generation, but were we any different? If it gets them playing, I say go for it. Once they're hooked, they'll opt for the full rules anyways. The best part about the new RedBox...... The near total copy of the design. Colors, text, font size and placement. Near perfect. Marketing genius. I can't wait to buy one so I can put it on my shelf next to my 1985 version. So what does everyone else think? Are you feeling the love? |
| #2erleniFeb 04, 2010 13:56:28 | I still have my RedBox too. Got it for Christmas in 1989 (italian version). I'll go and look at the new one. |
| #3MarkAtkinsonFeb 04, 2010 14:34:03 | I LOVE the design. Its just the content that i'm dubious about. |
| #4undraveFeb 04, 2010 15:18:44 | I LOVE the design. Its just the content that i'm dubious about. Why? What could be wrong with it? |
| #5MarkAtkinsonFeb 04, 2010 15:28:20 | I LOVE the design. Its just the content that i'm dubious about. It is pretty much there just to introduce n00bs to the game. The art work is a marketing ploy to grab the attention of older players but if you already have the core books you won't find anything new in the red box. |
| #6MDosantosFeb 04, 2010 16:19:40 | So? They don't pretend to sell something new to players who are already into the game... |
| #7Style75Feb 04, 2010 18:18:08 | I LOVE the design. Its just the content that i'm dubious about. Remember that we were all noobs once. This hobby will live or die depending on how many of today's youth it can attract, the same as it did back in the early 80's. IMHO The fact that D&D still exists is largely due to the success of the first RedBox. WoTC is a business, not a charity, and having a twin track approach makes huge sense for their bottom line. They can keep their hard core happy but still bring in new players. A percentage of those new players will go on to become hard core and the cycle repeats. I'm extremely happy that WoTC is taking this strategy because it shows they're thinking about the long term health of this game. Noobs are always welcome at my table. |
| #8MarkAtkinsonFeb 04, 2010 18:24:30 | Don't get me wrong. All I ment is that the box won't be for seasoned players. I appologise if I caused offence. |
| #9warfeindFeb 04, 2010 18:36:42 | Don't get me wrong. All I ment is that the box won't be for seasoned players. I appologise if I caused offence. I think you might be wrong. Here's why I think going to incorporate a lot of new options like builds, feats, rituals, and monsters. This way they get to sell to the noobs and veterans alike. I could be wrong it's happened before. |
| #10MarandahirFeb 04, 2010 18:39:46 | I'm a seasoned player and DM, but I'm still going to buy it. I want to see it with my own eyes, and I like the token movement and the other material packaged in. Also, I want the builds in the two Essentials expansions. |
| #11ShadowsireFeb 04, 2010 22:30:06 | I started playing D&D in the 3.5 era and I'm still pretty excited about the new red box. It looks way better than the starter set. It has character creation rules, it has separate books for players and DMs, hopefully it's in a better box, it seems to have more adventure content, it will include all the important errata the starter set missed. It's probably not worth it for experienced players who aren't looking to introduce new players to the game. They'd get a set of dice, a simple short adventure, a dungeon map (likely a big thin glossy paper one), some cardboard tokens, for $20 retail. I'm impressed by a lot of the 2010 catalog, really. |
| #12lizardmageFeb 05, 2010 9:14:10 | I just might pick this up as I get roped into doing D&D Game Days at my LGS as the DM and typically have plenty of first time D&Ders at those tables. I'll wait it out though and decide upon release. |
| #13AcryliumFeb 05, 2010 11:01:58 | I think it might be realy a good idea to sell this legendary red box again, althoug I don't think I'll buy one for myself. Will there be any content exclusive to this new red box or will it be something like a starter-set for new players? |
| #14Plaguescarred1Feb 05, 2010 11:44:51 | A stroke of genius is how I describe the new RedBox D&D set. My greatest dnd memory of all time is my mom buying me the old red box, sitting on the floor of my bedroom and flipping through those pages. I still have it today, 25 years later, and it holds a place of honor on my bookshelf. I share your words. I don't have mine anymore but got myself a copy in PDF after many years. Just the nostalgia of peering back into those pages looking at images i still remembered was something. This is where it all started for me. I've spent my time in my bed reading it. Seeing such project is good for getting new players into it. But the new cover doesn't rivalise with Elmoore's Red Dragon ! Then in 3-4 years you'll have people saying they started playing D&D with the Red Box and we will think they are old-timer ! LOL Good initiative overall. If the game thrive from this marketing attempt, it can only be good for the business. |
| #15tai_saitouFeb 05, 2010 14:54:12 | I'm probably going to buy it. But then again I've been buying all the 4e stuff. Guess WotC hooked me like a fish. Anyway, I think it's going to be a really good product. |
| #16bugleymanFeb 08, 2010 14:09:09 | At first glance I thought this thread was about renting DVDs. ![]() Anyway, let me add my voice to the chorus: Nice homage. ![]() |
| #17wiggelsworthFeb 08, 2010 16:31:18 | My enthusiasm for this is lukewarm at best. I might pick it up, though, and give 4e a whirl, if the new Red Box is for levels 1-3 (rather than the rumored 1-2) and is relatively complete, within the restrictions placed upon it (ie. F/M/T/C, and a limited number of races) I'm 4e-curious, but not interested in purchasing crippleware. Wiggy |
| #18Duke5150Feb 09, 2010 2:41:55 | My enthusiasm for this is lukewarm at best. lol. Define crippleware, please. |
| #19areolaFeb 09, 2010 2:46:32 | I guess wiggy meant you're massively having fun at 2nd level , then when it's time to level up to 3rd level BAM! |
| #20Dragon9Feb 09, 2010 8:31:51 | I think it might be realy a good idea to sell this legendary red box again, althoug I don't think I'll buy one for myself. I don't think there will be anythign new in the red box. The Player's Essentials books will, apparently, have some exclusive stuff. If one infers that from their statement of: "Each class comes with a set of new powers, class features, paragon paths, epic destinies, and more that beginning players can use to build the characters they want to play and experienced players can plunder for existing 4th Edition characters." |
| #21wiggelsworthFeb 09, 2010 14:06:15 | My enthusiasm for this is lukewarm at best. Crippleware is any product whose functions have been limited (or "crippled") with the sole purpose of encouraging or requiring the user to pay for additional functions (either by paying a one-time fee or an on-going subscription fee) Wiggy |
| #22Fabio_Milito_PagliaraFeb 10, 2010 4:39:08 | with star wars out a new iteration of star frontiers would be nice |
| #23granpappy77Feb 10, 2010 7:00:42 | I'm pretty excited about the new red box. My fiance's oldest nephew is 11 and he doesn't know much about D&D but he's very intrigued by the idea. I got him a couple WotC's tween-focused monster books that he really liked and he hasn't stopped talking about getting into the game since I showed him my collection of minis and Dwarven Forge stuff. It seems the red box is specifically designed with kids like him in mind. |
| #24kalstrandFeb 10, 2010 12:04:17 | I will admit that I havn't kept up totally up to date and don't subscribe to ddi but what is the actual product name of this red box? |
| #25Silver_BlazeFeb 10, 2010 14:24:22 | I initially was going to avoid the Essentials line altogether. But now, after reading most of product pages for them, I know I will definitely be getting the Red Box (SOLO ADVENTURE!), the Dungeon Tiles Master Sets, and the Player's Essentials. The best part is that I will be spending significantly less money for more stuff than usual. |
| #26dannoeFeb 15, 2010 6:34:43 | It is pretty much there just to introduce n00bs to the game. The art work is a marketing ploy to grab the attention of older players but if you already have the core books you won't find anything new in the red box. It's not there to teach something new to established players. It's there so that you can teach your 10-year-old to play without making him read a 300-page book right off the bat. Not too many utter D&D noobs are gonna sign up for that. I personally LOVE the idea because I've been trying to teach my wife to play for about 2 years, and it's just daunting. There's too much, and I've struggled to cut to just the core essentials. So yeah, a smaller version of the game would be MOST useful. |
| #27bonsFeb 15, 2010 8:39:31 | It's there so that you can teach your 10-year-old to play without making him read a 300-page book right off the bat. Not too many utter D&D noobs are gonna sign up for that. Having been though the flip side, having to read 300 page books because my 10 year old son wanted to play D&D, I really could have used the red box. Heck, I think I still can use the red box. I'm still not sure I'm doing this right. |