bug with skills-telling me i have 1 more to pick but wont let me - Downloaded from the Wizards Community, all coding removed by Solauren

bug with skills-telling me i have 1 more to pick but wont let me

Post/Author/DateTime Post
#1
frothsof
Jun 21, 2011 15:24:31 title explains it, its telling me to pick one more but wont let me (no option to check)
#2
paolom
Jun 21, 2011 15:46:35
title explains it, its telling me to pick one more but wont let me (no option to check)

Works for me. Do you have any more detailed repro steps?
#3
frothsof
Jun 21, 2011 16:00:19 human hybrid fighter/ranger, picked 4 skills and is telling me to pick one more but wont let me. if i say choose for me it picks another one
#4
tanker1973
Jun 21, 2011 20:55:09
human hybrid fighter/ranger, picked 4 skills and is telling me to pick one more but wont let me. if i say choose for me it picks another one

same problem here, hybrid swordmage|warlock/avenger.
#5
frothsof
Jun 21, 2011 20:57:59 its a new problem too, it wasnt like that yesterday
#6
cakemage
Jun 22, 2011 21:38:57 Same weid problem with my hybrid warlord warlock. I had hm at level to everything all set two weeks ago. Go to update something today and it says I have to pick one more skill even though I have 4 already. I start unchecking them one a time and find that its the arcane skill that seems to be causeing the problem. When I uncheck that the oragne "not lega" color on the skills tab goes away but says I need to pick two more skill but there is no skills to choose from (all greyed out). I select choose for me and it selects stealth, unselect that and click on choose for me again (still everything is all geyed out) and it selects arcana again and it goes back to the orange colored tab on the skills and says I need to select one more skill...

#7
frothsof
Jun 23, 2011 16:46:04 yeah thats whats happening to everyone it looks like
#8
bronski113
Jun 24, 2011 1:55:50 I encountered the same problem with a Hybrid Warlord/Fighter.
#9
salla
Jun 24, 2011 18:33:06 Hmm. I just checked my Artificer/Warlord, and it didn't do that; I clicked 'level up to 3' and nothing happened on the skills front. Not sure if this was helpful, but thought I'd at least chime in.
#10
nightwalker450
Jun 26, 2011 22:44:25 Had the same thing the other day on hybrid ranger/cleric. Of note, if your background gives you skills this is a way around it (then you can at least choose your background skills with the extra 1)

#11
fortman
Jun 28, 2011 1:04:17 Assuming all of us here only have problem with Human Hybrid characters, look like Human Bonus Trained Class Skills does not work for Hybrid?
#12
orosian
Jun 29, 2011 1:19:37 human hybrid fighter/monk that i had not edited or altered for some months has had this occur too. other race hybrids appear unaffected. human bonus skill on hybrids only appears to be norked
#13
Duskweaver
Jun 29, 2011 7:34:32 A possibly related bug: I'm finding the CB is allowing eladrin hybrid characters to choose from the entire list of skills, rather than just the combined list for their two classes. It seems to be applying the conditions for the bonus trained skill from Eladrin Education to all their skill training slots.

EDIT: OK, further testing shows the situation is a little wierder, and does not only affect hybrids. The skills list allows all skills for your first skill training pick, which is correct if this first pick is meant to be for Eladrin Education. If you pick either Arcana or History, however, the list then gives you another unrestricted choice. Only after picking a skill other than Arcana or History to train in does the list 'grey out' skills not on your class skills list.

EDIT2: Ever odder, this affects certain classes (besides hybrid), but not others.

EDIT3: OK, it's not a matter of different classes. When you start a new character, it has this problem, but if you go back and change the character's class and return to the skills screen, the problem goes away. It then works fine even if you change back to the original class.

EDIT4: Oh, and it turns out there's nothing special about History and Arcana. It seems that the problem is picking one of your class skills as your Eladrin Education skill. This means that this is actually purely a cosmetic error. It won't actually let you end up with illegal trained skills. It just looks as though it will.
#14
mattador666
Jun 29, 2011 7:39:45 had this problem last night, a human hybrid fighter/something.
#15
fortman
Jun 29, 2011 14:19:59
Snipped Eladrin Skill picking problem.

Yeap, Eladrin Education is any skill. CB will put the skill you choose into the most-restrictive-but-valid slot first, so if you pick Class Skill to be Trained Skill, Eladrin Education slot is still available. Once you pick a non-Class Skill, the Eladrin Education slot goes away.

#16
Mommy_was_an_Orc
Jul 04, 2011 13:27:15 I loaded up my 6th level Avenger|Psion for the 1st time since the new update and her Train Skills came up as houseruled. She has Arcana, Insight, Perception, and Religion.

She's human and that appears to be where the problem is coming from, in the bonus skill. If I try to change things, I have to hit choose for me to pick the 4th skill as it won't let me otherwise.
#17
GelatinousOctahedron
Jul 06, 2011 11:08:40 I am joining the chorus and confirming the problem is with human hybirds.

I was updating the one human hybrid fighter/paladin build I have and had the same problem.
#18
tiornys
Jul 09, 2011 6:14:20 Definitely humans. I hit the same bug earlier today. Someone has reported this, yes?

I just reported a somewhat related, obscure bug, where I had 3 (non-Cleric) Ranger skills selected (Acrobatics, Nature, Perception) for a Cleric|Ranger, and was being forced into the Ranger list for my 4th skill (originally Stealth before I started playing with my skills). Selecting Stealth and deselecting any of the other skills correctly gives me the full combined class skill lists to pick from. Not sure if Stealth got "committed" as the bonus Ranger skill or if something else is going on, but regardless, I should have the full combined lists to choose from when unselecting Stealth.

t~
#19
Todd
Jul 09, 2011 22:48:34 I'm seeing the same bug in Malec-Keth Janissary Paragon Path when choosing "Gain Training in a Skill" for the Devshirme Training Option. Happens on non-Human Hybrids as well. Works fine for non-Hybrids.
#20
fortman
Jul 12, 2011 20:32:06 Okay, it seems to be fixed with the new update. Anyone still has problem?

Post/Author/DateTime	Post
#1 frothsof Jun 21, 2011 15:24:31	title explains it, its telling me to pick one more but wont let me (no option to check)
#2 paolom Jun 21, 2011 15:46:35	title explains it, its telling me to pick one more but wont let me (no option to check) Works for me. Do you have any more detailed repro steps?
#3 frothsof Jun 21, 2011 16:00:19	human hybrid fighter/ranger, picked 4 skills and is telling me to pick one more but wont let me. if i say choose for me it picks another one
#4 tanker1973 Jun 21, 2011 20:55:09	human hybrid fighter/ranger, picked 4 skills and is telling me to pick one more but wont let me. if i say choose for me it picks another one same problem here, hybrid swordmage\|warlock/avenger.
#5 frothsof Jun 21, 2011 20:57:59	its a new problem too, it wasnt like that yesterday
#6 cakemage Jun 22, 2011 21:38:57	Same weid problem with my hybrid warlord warlock. I had hm at level to everything all set two weeks ago. Go to update something today and it says I have to pick one more skill even though I have 4 already. I start unchecking them one a time and find that its the arcane skill that seems to be causeing the problem. When I uncheck that the oragne "not lega" color on the skills tab goes away but says I need to pick two more skill but there is no skills to choose from (all greyed out). I select choose for me and it selects stealth, unselect that and click on choose for me again (still everything is all geyed out) and it selects arcana again and it goes back to the orange colored tab on the skills and says I need to select one more skill...
#7 frothsof Jun 23, 2011 16:46:04	yeah thats whats happening to everyone it looks like
#8 bronski113 Jun 24, 2011 1:55:50	I encountered the same problem with a Hybrid Warlord/Fighter.
#9 salla Jun 24, 2011 18:33:06	Hmm. I just checked my Artificer/Warlord, and it didn't do that; I clicked 'level up to 3' and nothing happened on the skills front. Not sure if this was helpful, but thought I'd at least chime in.
#10 nightwalker450 Jun 26, 2011 22:44:25	Had the same thing the other day on hybrid ranger/cleric. Of note, if your background gives you skills this is a way around it (then you can at least choose your background skills with the extra 1)
#11 fortman Jun 28, 2011 1:04:17	Assuming all of us here only have problem with Human Hybrid characters, look like Human Bonus Trained Class Skills does not work for Hybrid?
#12 orosian Jun 29, 2011 1:19:37	human hybrid fighter/monk that i had not edited or altered for some months has had this occur too. other race hybrids appear unaffected. human bonus skill on hybrids only appears to be norked
#13 Duskweaver Jun 29, 2011 7:34:32	A possibly related bug: I'm finding the CB is allowing eladrin hybrid characters to choose from the entire list of skills, rather than just the combined list for their two classes. It seems to be applying the conditions for the bonus trained skill from Eladrin Education to all their skill training slots. EDIT: OK, further testing shows the situation is a little wierder, and does not only affect hybrids. The skills list allows all skills for your first skill training pick, which is correct if this first pick is meant to be for Eladrin Education. If you pick either Arcana or History, however, the list then gives you another unrestricted choice. Only after picking a skill other than Arcana or History to train in does the list 'grey out' skills not on your class skills list. EDIT2: Ever odder, this affects certain classes (besides hybrid), but not others. EDIT3: OK, it's not a matter of different classes. When you start a new character, it has this problem, but if you go back and change the character's class and return to the skills screen, the problem goes away. It then works fine even if you change back to the original class. EDIT4: Oh, and it turns out there's nothing special about History and Arcana. It seems that the problem is picking one of your class skills as your Eladrin Education skill. This means that this is actually purely a cosmetic error. It won't actually let you end up with illegal trained skills. It just looks as though it will.
#14 mattador666 Jun 29, 2011 7:39:45	had this problem last night, a human hybrid fighter/something.
#15 fortman Jun 29, 2011 14:19:59	Snipped Eladrin Skill picking problem. Yeap, Eladrin Education is any skill. CB will put the skill you choose into the most-restrictive-but-valid slot first, so if you pick Class Skill to be Trained Skill, Eladrin Education slot is still available. Once you pick a non-Class Skill, the Eladrin Education slot goes away.
#16 Mommy_was_an_Orc Jul 04, 2011 13:27:15	I loaded up my 6th level Avenger\|Psion for the 1st time since the new update and her Train Skills came up as houseruled. She has Arcana, Insight, Perception, and Religion. She's human and that appears to be where the problem is coming from, in the bonus skill. If I try to change things, I have to hit choose for me to pick the 4th skill as it won't let me otherwise.
#17 GelatinousOctahedron Jul 06, 2011 11:08:40	I am joining the chorus and confirming the problem is with human hybirds. I was updating the one human hybrid fighter/paladin build I have and had the same problem.
#18 tiornys Jul 09, 2011 6:14:20	Definitely humans. I hit the same bug earlier today. Someone has reported this, yes? I just reported a somewhat related, obscure bug, where I had 3 (non-Cleric) Ranger skills selected (Acrobatics, Nature, Perception) for a Cleric\|Ranger, and was being forced into the Ranger list for my 4th skill (originally Stealth before I started playing with my skills). Selecting Stealth and deselecting any of the other skills correctly gives me the full combined class skill lists to pick from. Not sure if Stealth got "committed" as the bonus Ranger skill or if something else is going on, but regardless, I should have the full combined lists to choose from when unselecting Stealth. t~
#19 Todd Jul 09, 2011 22:48:34	I'm seeing the same bug in Malec-Keth Janissary Paragon Path when choosing "Gain Training in a Skill" for the Devshirme Training Option. Happens on non-Human Hybrids as well. Works fine for non-Hybrids.
#20 fortman Jul 12, 2011 20:32:06	Okay, it seems to be fixed with the new update. Anyone still has problem?