Do any of you have problems with Magical Secrets?

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

Slit518

Aug 16, 2015 20:09:04

A Bard gets an ability where they can choose any spell of their spell level that they can cast, including half caster classes, such as the Ranger or Paladin.  The Ranger and the Paladin get some exclusive spells only obtainable to them, especially when they can get level 5 spells at level 17, which are quite powerful for their class.  A Bard can pick these up at level 10.

 

This article explains it,

http://blogofholding.com/?p=6610

 

I know as a DM you can limit what your players can and can't do.  But how do you feel on this?  If you didn't want to abolish the option for the spells, how do you handle it?  Do you make all half caster spells count as twice their spell level while picking up?  Do you only allow them to use those spells as a bonus spell once per long rest outside of their normal spell pool?  So they don't use up higher spell slots to spam them?

 

Please, leave your opinions here.

Thanks in advance!

#2

cowleymen

Aug 16, 2015 22:32:35

honestly im not that worried about it. only thing i would be worried about is if said paladins or rangers where in the group with the bard. I could see it annoying them, and I understand why those 5th level ranger and paladin spells have the exxtra omph they have. But over all, i dont think its worth making a fuss over really

#3

Danny_Montanny

Aug 17, 2015 4:23:29

There's no problem whatsoever. They're using their limited resources to cast the spell, what does it really matter what spell it is? Oh no, a Bard can use Swift Quiver at level 10 to make 3-4 attacks (not to mention having to use their bonus action to do it), the game's broken! 

#4

CCS

Aug 17, 2015 8:32:18
I've no problem with it. And I doubt anyone I play 5e with do either. It's just something a bard can do at 10th lv....
#5

Jeggrim

Aug 17, 2015 15:33:48

Nothing wrong in my opinion. Just a neat ability. There are far too many other balancing options for it to be broken. Its a neat trick, but not game breaking. Working as intended IMO.

​Cheers