| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1AvonRekaesOct 13, 2008 20:23:26 | Was wondering what the timeline was for getting the advertised 4e support for this book. (Said advertisement is on the back cover of the book and reads as follows: 4th Edition Compatible Though designed for version 3.5 of the Dungeons and Dragons game, you can get free online updates of this book to 4th Edition after those rules are released. Check out dndinsider.com for details!") I put my campaign on hiatus and started a new one in the meantime, but when my game comes back we're going to Stormreach. I'd like to know if the update to City of Stormreach is going to be available when the 4th edition Eberron Campaign Guide comes out or sometime after. |
| #2NivedOct 13, 2008 21:31:57 | It was asked at Gen Con which was damn near two months ago now and they said that the update had gone to R&D. Not much is known beyond that other than they are presumably still planning on honoring their commitment. However I'd imagine that on the grand list of priorities versus new books and magazine content it probably gets shelved more often than now causing a slow development time sadly. I'm annoyed about it too, but hey there is no reason you can't use CoT for a 4th edition game now, I do. Granted I don't really need the mechanics none of my players have expressed any interest in joining any of the organizations and most of the monsters and NPCs are easy swap outs... its not like most of the NPCs had stats beyond race, class, and level anyway. |
| #3HellcowOct 15, 2008 2:40:50 | It's a good question; I know that someone (Nic Logue, I think) had been working on this. I'll ask around. |
| #4need_a_lifeOct 15, 2008 9:26:46 | Now, that's what I love about this forum. If someone drops the ball, there's always a certain Infernal Bovine who comes to help or simply offer input. ![]() |
| #5JohnLynchApr 08, 2009 8:56:28 | So did anything come from your queries Keith? Considering we're nearing the arrival of 4th ed Eberron, it'd be nice to know if WotC actually intends to fulfill this promise. John Whose somewhat grouchy at WotC at the moment due to the sheer ignorance, stupidity and/or lies in relation to the whole PDF affair. |
| #6skrapsanApr 08, 2009 9:32:44 | John I see I'm not the only one "confused" by this whole PDF thing... And on the note of the "conversions" I have somewhat given up on them. In my mind it was more of a marketing "stunt" to get people to buy the last two books rather than anything else... |
| #7GiloApr 08, 2009 9:54:22 | I figured WotC will only release the Stormreach update after the 4e Eberron Campaign Guide comes out (so not before July 21, 2009). |
| #8Elemental_ElfApr 08, 2009 10:45:16 | I figured it was just lost in the hustle of getting 4E finished and out the door. I mean it did come out in February of '08 which was just a few short months prior to 4E's arrival. Actually, thinking about it, wasn't CoS the last official 3.5 book? ![]() |
| #9rauricApr 08, 2009 12:30:00 | I bought it knowing I was going to be restarting my 3.5 EB game but as a 4E game. There was a gamer in the store and asked me why I was buying it because I was going to have to rework the NPCs and change the rules around. I looked at how much fluff was in the book and pretty much ignored much of what he had to say. I have used that book and the old ones since Sept 08 in my current EB 4E game and have had no problems with it. Anyway I hope they don't do anything with Stormreach and give us EB Planar articles or other remote, interesting towns like Graywall. Plus I think I understand about the whole PDF thing. I know folks that got illegal copies or bought a copy and gave it out to hteir buds. That is alot of dough that WOTC could have had but in this economy people are looking for any deal they can. If WOTC can sell their books on their site and figure out a way to stop the illegal copies that is great. It would be better if when they sold them online it was at halfprice or something also. |
| #10skrapsanApr 08, 2009 13:59:28 | I'm with Rauric on this one. I have great use for most of my books still. Most of them are as stated hundreds of times over and over again on these boards quite fluff heavy and light on the actual mechanics. |
| #11NivedApr 08, 2009 16:26:14 | Weird reading my own comment from that far back... I'd forgotten that it was even supposed to have an update (my own first 4e campaign which was set in Stormreach ran its course.... Xarkon was soundly vanquished). I doubt we'll ever hear anything about it... ever... like that Tome of Battle Eberron Expanded article Keith said he wrote and turned in that never ever saw the light of day. |
| #12rauricApr 08, 2009 17:15:36 | What? That is why we never saw a Planes article because he was doing silly TOB/EB conversion articles!!! ;) |
| #13JohnLynchApr 08, 2009 19:53:33 | Plus I think I understand about the whole PDF thing. I know folks that got illegal copies or bought a copy and gave it out to hteir buds. That is alot of dough that WOTC could have had but in this economy people are looking for any deal they can. People who pirated the books will continue to pirate the books. People who bought the PDFs may now choose to pirate the books. If WOTC can sell their books on their site and figure out a way to stop the illegal copies that is great. Two points: 1) That isn't their stated aim for removing the PDFs from the online stores. So if this is true, they're outright lying once more. 2) What part of WotC's digital endeavours makes you think they'll actually manage to sell the PDFs? First they had advertisements in the 4th ed books for services that have yet to materialise. Second they can't even produce a PDF to convert the crunch from a fluff-heavy book to 4th ed. I'm with Rauric on this one. I have great use for most of my books still. Most of them are as stated hundreds of times over and over again on these boards quite fluff heavy and light on the actual mechanics. Oh sure. I bought the book literally days ago knowing full well WotC probably isn't going to honour their promise. But I get annoyed when a company lies to me. Its one of the few things a company can do to make me angry. |
| #14rauricApr 08, 2009 20:46:40 | Like my sig says, I worry about spots on my x-rays not this stuff. As long as my wife is not lying to me I don't give a fig. Breathing air is all that matters.:D |
| #15JohnLynchApr 08, 2009 23:33:08 | Like my sig says, I worry about spots on my x-rays not this stuff. As long as my wife is not lying to me I don't give a fig. Breathing air is all that matters.:D Well to be fair your wife to lying to you isn't life threatening so you shouldn't worry about that either :P |
| #16skrapsanApr 09, 2009 2:47:57 | Well to be fair your wife to lying to you isn't life threatening so you shouldn't worry about that either :P It might be... "No no, I did not have zombie fever darling, the doctor says I'm healthy as a lich... um horse, I meant horse" But all jokes aside, I don't really care about delayed or never coming updates any more. I spent a good time of my teenage years waiting for videogames that never really got out. I mean, its not like wizards have monopoly on that kind of stuff. Sure its annoying as hell, but its not worth all the stress. So I'm in Raurics boat here, and besides, there is nothing stopping you from stopping to buy 4th ed books. After all, its the only answer they understand, us not buying their stuff. Personally I'm just not angry enough to even consider it, (although I feel it's building). |
| #17JohnLynchApr 09, 2009 3:51:17 | there is nothing stopping you from stopping to buy 4th ed books. After all, its the only answer they understand, us not buying their stuff. Personally I'm just not angry enough to even consider it, (although I feel it's building). I wasn't actually planning on buying any of their 4th ed PDFs. What I was planning on doing was buying any Eberron books I couldn't get my hands on ;) Now I'll just have to hope that Amazon's customers aren't big fans of 3.5e Eberron books. |
| #18skrapsanApr 09, 2009 16:26:04 | Good luck, and stay away from my books. They are my precious ones... :P |
| #19AvonRekaesApr 09, 2009 17:52:25 | Well, with setting support being rolled out in full for Dragon, here's hoping we get an update as a Dragon article. To anyone who says they don't care anymore, that's nice. But I want my advertised support for this book, as I plan on running a campaign out of Stormreach. Sure I can just make up my own stats for everyone and everything in the book, but you could make the same argument to make all DnD books going forward nothing but fluff and leaving it up to you to make your own mechanics for it. City of Stormreach was supposed to be edition proof. It was supposed to have 4e support. I want it. |
| #20rauricApr 09, 2009 20:16:51 | Gotcha. I kinda hope to see less mechanics and stats for NPCs in any article from EB though. I like that NpCs can be whatever level you need them at without any static levels or powers. I just need names (because I loathe making those up) of NPCs, personalities for them and a short history. Then I am good to go. :D |
| #21AvonRekaesApr 09, 2009 23:05:44 | NPCs you're not supposed to fight, sure, but I'd want stat blocks for militias and gangs, at the very least. And for the more evil secret identities of the Coin Lords. And that kobold. And the hunter's lodge. And Two-Maw. And the Iron Watch.... |
| #22PJammaGodApr 10, 2009 2:13:41 | And a certain Quabalrin necromancer... :P |
| #23_radagast__dupApr 13, 2009 4:55:54 | I seriously can't believe this isn't out yet... Sigh. |
| #24AvonRekaesApr 13, 2009 11:52:30 | Hear hear. |