| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1merrikcaleAug 06, 2008 21:11:48 | I know the Discoveries line is gone and Matt Forbeck in his blog sort of indicates that the Eberron novels are goners. is that true? Or is it just some books? |
| #2azazyllAug 06, 2008 21:18:23 | Well, they just published the second novel of the draconic prophecies line, and they're about to run another series by the guy who wrote the dragon below, plus keith is well into another novel series, so I'd say it's just some of the titles. |
| #3merrikcaleAug 06, 2008 21:58:35 | OK. I have read in places that they were cancelling the whole line. Although I am a Realms guy, i have enjoyed some of the books so thats good I know there is this press release http://ww2.wizards.com/books/Wizards/default.aspx?doc=main_discoveries07252008&=RSS-BOOKS |
| #4NivedAug 06, 2008 22:51:49 | I read the press release, Eberron is a Dungeons and Dragons brand so I don't see what the problem is. The Doom of Kings was just released this week marked as Book One of the Legacy of Dhakaan Trilogy. In October the second book of the Lanternlight Files is out. Jame's Wyatt's trilogy still has another book left to finish his Draconic Prophecy Trilogy, and the first two were hardbound. Keith has mentioned that he has been writting a new Eberron Trilogy. |
| #5merrikcaleAug 07, 2008 9:39:23 | I read the press release, Eberron is a Dungeons and Dragons brand so I don't see what the problem is. Well, thats good. I guess its just some books (like Mr. Forbecks) that were cancelled |
| #6NivedAug 07, 2008 11:21:14 | Well we should find out more soon, I'm sure questions will be raised at Gen Con. |
| #7HellcowAug 07, 2008 12:08:00 | I've got a novel coming out in November, The Queen of Stone. The subject of the cancellations is discussed at some length (and by most of the authors affected) here. |
| #8AshlockAug 07, 2008 12:52:29 | The short version of this is that some series-in-the-works novels were canceled, but the Eberron novel line will continue. There will be fewer novels but with more marketing behind them. And that's that. |
| #9NivedAug 07, 2008 14:01:21 | Thanks for the link guys, mixed news to be sure. Confirmation that the novels will continue, but fewer and some got axed. Might not be a bad thing, I mean sure I've bought all the Eberron Novels so far, but one of TSR's downfalls was they published too many novels, hardcovers specifically. They increased the number of novels produced but didn't seen an increase in number of books sold (for the year) increased costs, unsold books... it was a bad place to be, its one of the things often cited as being a death blow to TSR. Not saying its the same situation, but even so its a bitter pill to swallow more books is not always better. In any case I'm going to keep voting with my wallet and keep buying Eberron. |
| #10merrikcaleAug 07, 2008 15:31:37 | Thanks for the link guys, mixed news to be sure. Confirmation that the novels will continue, but fewer and some got axed. I would say a reduction in novels is a bad thing. period. I like to have some choices |
| #11mystrichAug 08, 2008 11:54:33 | Ya, but as he said, more costly for Wizards to produce (especially when you consider it's producing books for other settings and DnD, paying editors, publishers, binders, etc) and more costly for the user to buy because there's so many. It is probably better. And if what Nived said is right, Wizards is probably going to be extra cautious since the last company to own DnD's license went out of business from producing too many novels. |
| #12merrikcaleAug 10, 2008 0:29:02 | I suppose you're right. Oh well, I like the novels. Its actually one of the few things I get for Eberron. Of course, now with the death of my Realms who knows |
| #13OgiwanAug 12, 2008 20:52:30 | The thing is, of the Eberron books that are out, pretty much all of them rock. The only kinda weak series was the War-Torn series, and even that had the superlative Claws of the Tiger. With Keith's book still coming out, I'm satisfied, but I do have to say that I am very dissapointed to not have any more from Jeff LaSala or Ed Bolme, both of whom contributed excellent works to the fantastic Inquisitives series. Matt Forbeck, too, wrote the very solid Mark of Death series; while I liked the Inquisitives series better, MoD was still a good series to pick up. I am honestly scratching my head as to why Wizards is letting these talented writers go to waste. I mean, there are some writers who I'll pick up as soon as I see their names on a book; the bulk of them seem to be Eberron writers, oddly enough. In any case, Don Bassingwaithe is one of those people, as The Binding Stone trilogy is a very good series (i've read it multiple times). Because I like Don's work, when I saw Doom of Kings in a Borders, I picked it up immediately. I like Keith Bakers work, and when Queen of Stone comes out, I'll get that. I like Rich Wulf's work, and if he wrote another book (I found a mention of a Sentinal Marshals book; is this one of the ones that got axed?), I would pick it up. When James Wyatt releases the next book for the Draconic Prophecies series (in paperback; I'm a poor grad student), I'd get that. Even if it'll be April 09 ![]() If Jeff LaSala wrote it, I'd get it. If Ed Bolme wrote it, I'd get it. If Matt Forbeck wrote it, I'd get it. I'd get them all, sight unseen, because I know these people are good writers. I can't understand why Wizards would willingly throw away a pretty much guaranteed revenue stream (I say guaranteed 'cause I know I'd buy them and sing their praises to the world, and there are bound to be tens of thousands like me). The only reason i can think of would be to have them write a movie script or something (we all know an Eberron movie would be pimp as hell), and if that's not it, well then I will have to kindly ask Wizards to screw their heads on straight and let those three (four?) write again. Like, seriously. Get on it. Ask around; I know I'm not the only one who's a fan of these people's writing. |
| #14mystrichAug 12, 2008 21:04:03 | I'd get them all, sight unseen, because I know these people are good writers. I can't understand why Wizards would willingly throw away a pretty much guaranteed revenue stream (I say guaranteed 'cause I know I'd buy them and sing their praises to the world, and there are bound to be tens of thousands like me). The only reason i can think of would be to have them write a movie script or something (we all know an Eberron movie would be pimp as hell), and if that's not it, well then I will have to kindly ask Wizards to screw their heads on straight and let those three (four?) write again. Easy, there aren't (or I doubt anyway) there are tens of thousands of players of Eberron, as popular as the setting in. Now, how many of those like to read or read fantasy, maybe they like playing it better. Next, how many can afford those books. And it's a newer setting, compared to something like FR that's been around almost as long as the game itself. And there are thousands who buy FR books that have never even heard of DnD. Now compare to Magic the Gathering too. They aren't divided by a setting, and so while the same fractions come in, they're going to be a bigger audience than an individual DnD setting. And you prove another point. People look by author. Someone who's never published a book, or at least not a DnD series, is less likely to have their book sell than someone like Keith Baker or other established authors of already popular book lines. To sum it up. Wizards is a buisness. Which is better? Producing 100 different book series, 25 of which bring in a profit, or producing 25 books, all of which bring in a profit. |
| #15rauricAug 12, 2008 23:59:28 | S0 far I liked Keiths series and James Wyatts books best. THe one Inquisitive book was alot of fun (Night of Long Shadows). |
| #16merrikcaleAug 13, 2008 9:48:29 | S0 far I liked Keiths series and James Wyatts books best. THe one Inquisitive book was alot of fun (Night of Long Shadows). I really enjoyed the Waggonner series myself |
| #17joelhuebnerAug 13, 2008 10:19:45 | I currently own every single published novel of the Eberron line (the paperbacks anyway, as I am cheap. + they are easier to tote around:D ) I have to honestly say that I have liked every single one and am eagerly awaiting more. Certainly I liked some better than others, The Left Hand of Death and the Night of Long shadows were the least liked by me personally. I think it was because they were less "Heroic" for lack of a better word, but at the same time they also show off "The Dark side" that is so much a part of Eberron. My hat is off to Jeff LaSala, I recently finished reading the Darkwood Mask and I loved every minute of it, it had nice tie ins to the other Inquisitives series! That said, I will continue to buy Eberron novels from any author as long as they are published, whether 1 a month or 5 a month. I eagerly await more. I can't say the same for the Forgotten Realms or Dragonlance. In Forgotten Realms I will only buy books from R.A. Salvatore, Richard Baker or Richard Lee Byers unless something upon closer examination moves me to buy. On the Dragonlance side I will only buy books from Margaret Weis and/or Tracy Hickman. As always those are my two cents for what it's worth to you, take it or leave it. Bring me more EBERRON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Please!! |
| #18rauricAug 13, 2008 23:58:54 | I want the novels to focus on characters and locales. The characters are so the readers can actually enjoy the story and the locales so the reader can get a better idea of what the world is about. The latter part helps the gamer understand the game world better and build more of an interest. I do not think the books need to be cano, only good. ;) |
| #19merrikcaleAug 14, 2008 18:16:47 | IThat said, I will continue to buy Eberron novels from any author as long as they are published, whether 1 a month or 5 a month. I eagerly await more. I think it will be less than 1 a month |