| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1entombmentofamachineAug 10, 2008 13:59:56 | I think I've seen somewhere saying Selune and Shar are sisters? Or 2 of the Godesses if not. Anyway..I am curious to how they are? Dieties can reproduce? Who was the mother/father? And how did they become opposites if born under a God/Godesses? So in that case...if 2 dieties..let's say for some crazy example...Lathander and Shar have a offspring...would that be holy-darkness God/Godess? P.S. Drizzt sucks |
| #2gomeztooAug 10, 2008 14:47:25 | Selune and Shar are the daughters of Chauntea. I don't know if there is a father, but Chauntea is a goddes. She doesn't need one to get kids. |
| #3lord_karsusAug 10, 2008 14:50:42 | Selune and Shar are the daughters of Chauntea. -Reverse that. Seûne and Shar, in the myths, were the first two deities of Realmspace, and from them stemmed Mystra, Chauntea, and others. |
| #4MirtekAug 10, 2008 14:54:37 | I always though that Selune and Share were there first and then Chauntea came into being sometime later. |
| #5meldreadAug 10, 2008 17:51:00 | In the beginning Shar and Selune were essentially a two-faced deity. In some versions of the myth there were beings that existed before them, and in others, they were the only ones in existence. None of the myths speak of how Chauntea was formed, she just appears randomly. When she appears it's to complain that her "body" (the world of Toril) is cold and cannot bring about life. At this time it is clear that the only light is Selune - the Moon. Shar is not evil at this time. They happily get along and co-exist. However, they become separated and at odds over whether or not to bring light to the world. It is obvious, however, why Shar would be opposed to that as she is the deity of the night. Light effectively weakens her. Shar and Selune have a sisterly spat, that results in the formation of more gods, and eventually, Selune reaches outside the confines of the world - into the Plane of Fire - and pulls out a large part of it. She burns herself badly and is weakened, but she creates the sun which gives the needed warmth to Chauntea. This, of course, is a betrayal in Shar's eyes and Shar attempts to snuff it out. However, Selune, ripping off a part of her divine essence hurls it at Shar. It passes through her, ripping off part of her divine essence. The two parts then merged into a single form which was Mystryl. Mystryl then sides with Selune putting an end to the conflict. At least for the time being. Shar then skulks off, to nurse her bitterness and wounds in secret while plotting revenge. It is important to keep in mind that all of these deities are Netherese deities and this is a Netherese creation myth. At one point in time there were many different pantheons of human deities. However, after the fall of many of the old empires of old (Jhaamdath, Netheril, etc.) humans began to migrate across the world, bringing with them their gods. Many of the gods, such as Auppenser and Amaunator faded away due to lack of worship. (Although Auppenser was kept alive by Mystra in a deep sleep.) The gods you see today in the Faerunian Pantheon are simply a mish-mash of the most popular gods that survived over the centuries. The Netherese deities did very well, and most of them are still alive in one form or another. Shar, Selune and Mystra were powerful deities with central key roles that were easily understood by mortals (Shar is the night and darkness, Selune is the Moon and Mystra is Magic) and thus this creation myth gained popularity. However, it was not the only creation myth. |
| #6phelf_der_zemitAug 10, 2008 17:54:31 | Another example would be Lolth (then Araushnee) and Corellon Larethian had the offspring known as Vhaeraun and Eilisetraee. That was of course before the whole betrayal and attempted overthrow went and soured the relationship. I think about 90% of the deities though are from Acendency, not birth. |
| #7lord_karsusAug 10, 2008 18:25:36 | I think about 90% of the deities though are from Acendency, not birth. -On a whole, I don't think so. The list of deities who came to become divine via mortal apotheosis is fairly small, in relation to the total number of deities active in Realmspace. The proverbial "90% of deities", we simply don't know the circumstances as to how they came about. |
| #8phelf_der_zemitAug 10, 2008 20:11:35 | Now that I think about it your right and that was some sort of a naive comment. I guess it was like 10% born, 10% acended, 80% unknown. |
| #9markustay63Aug 10, 2008 21:10:41 | There were a group of beings that were mentioned somwhere -somehing like 'Shadow Lords' or some-such - that either preceeded the deities, or were contemporaries of Shar and Selune. I can't remember what reference they were in (a novel?), but I remember there was some discussion about them over at CKawhile back. They didn't appear to be gods - they were something else entirely. I suppose with all this new 4e lore, they may have been primordials. |
| #10lord_karsusAug 10, 2008 22:56:45 | Now that I think about it your right and that was some sort of a naive comment. -Yeah, that's more like it. There were a group of beings that were mentioned somwhere -somehing like 'Shadow Lords' or some-such - that either preceeded the deities, or were contemporaries of Shar and Selune. -The Shadevari, yes, featured in the Crypt of the Shadowking and Curse of the Shadowmage novels, with stats in the Villain's Lorebook. |
| #11meldreadAug 10, 2008 23:08:31 | MarkusTay63- Yes, the Shadevari were the beings I was speaking about when I said: "In some versions of the myth there were beings that existed before them, and in others, they were the only ones in existence." The Shadevari appeared in the 2E version of the Myth, but in 3rd and now apparently 4th Edition they were given no mention. It is logical to conclude that there are a number of different variations of the myth floating around. Especially based on who is telling it. |
| #12lord_karsusAug 10, 2008 23:13:29 | -As evidenced by the two aforementioned novels, whatever their origins, the Shadevari are indeed quite real, however. |
| #13naexAug 10, 2008 23:33:30 | Many of the gods, such as Auppenser and Amaunator faded away due to lack of worship. (Although Auppenser was kept alive by Mystra in a deep sleep.) Where did you find the bit about Mystra? The only lore that I have seen (LEoF) says Auppenser was gravely weakened by the destruction of Jhaamdath, and his faith simply dwindled into nonexistence over the next few centuries. Of all the ancient gods, however, Auppenser alone still maintains a glimmer of awareness and a handful of devoted worshipers. And when the Well of Elders is reawakened so to shall he be reawakened, and from him will come balance in the realms. (This last bit is from the prophesies of Tegasta, last High Seer of Jhaamdath, found in a rieldoxia in an ancient Sembian tomb). |
| #14meldreadAug 11, 2008 0:52:20 | I forget exactly where the information came from, but I do remember a discussion about it on these forums roughly a year back. |
| #15PsiphyreAug 11, 2008 7:04:38 | I forget exactly where the information came from, but I do remember a discussion about it on these forums roughly a year back. The reference you're thinking of is from The Grand History of the Realms, in one of the side-blocks of lore if I remember correctly. Hope that helps. ![]() |
| #16whatdemonsdotosaintsAug 11, 2008 9:12:28 | -Reverse that. Seûne and Shar, in the myths, were the first two deities of Realmspace So where the hell did AO come from? Just magically became supreame God ruler? How did he rank above them if they were 1st? |
| #17phelf_der_zemitAug 11, 2008 9:28:07 | Good luck with the latter statement. And AO created everything didn't he? He is the ultimate being. More than an actual being. Normal Mortals don't even know of him do they? |
| #18whatdemonsdotosaintsAug 11, 2008 9:37:20 | AO created everything didn't he? He is the ultimate being. More than an actual being. Normal Mortals don't even know of him do they? So if what you say is true, than the statment LK made is irrelivent? Seûne and Shar, in the myths, were the first two deities of Realmspace Would that not be a contridiction? AO is the ultimate Diety none to less, yet if Seûne and Shar were the 1st, how are you going to tell me AO created everything? |
| #19rauricAug 11, 2008 10:20:47 | I don't really get involved with a discussion that has Betaextinction in it but I am jumping in and hopes it clears things up for Beta and his two new identities. Some designers back in 2E created AO out of the blue. He/She is not part of Eds original concept of the FR. The current designers did not like AO even back in 3E and would like to totally Retcon him/her out but will not do so, they will just never mention AO much at all. They will instead "push" Selune and Shar more into the role that Ao had in past editions. Maybe they will explain the reasoning canonly and perhaps they will not. SO we can say that the sisters were the first, but AO created them. He is not a deity but some being of order that looks over the planet. So the sisters were thew first deities. |
| #2018DELTAAug 11, 2008 10:24:12 | -You noticed that too, and I thought I was going crazy! ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() 18DELTA ![]() |
| #21MirtekAug 11, 2008 11:14:26 | Would that not be a contridiction? AO is the ultimate Diety none to less, yet if Seûne and Shar were the 1st, how are you going to tell me AO created everything? Ao isn't a deity, so he doesn't count. About the origin of the unknown deities, it's also said that the first deities of war, murder and all the other ugly things formed from the hostility between Shar and Selune as they clashed with each other after the lighting of the sun (the first sun deity could have been born that very moment but took some time before becoming conscious to manifest himself) |
| #22rauricAug 11, 2008 11:41:31 | -You noticed that too, and I thought I was going crazy! Rauric sees and hears all. Plus I am very paranoid. ;) |
| #23markustay63Aug 11, 2008 11:43:14 | Ao would work better as a primordial... unless he created them as well. |
| #24lord_karsusAug 11, 2008 12:33:21 | The reference you're thinking of is from The Grand History of the Realms, in one of the side-blocks of lore if I remember correctly. -Which, mind everyone, comes from a character perspective, and may or may not be the truth. Ao would work better as a primordial... unless he created them as well. -Not really. Ao is what Ao is. That's all. |
| #2518DELTAAug 11, 2008 12:35:39 | -Maybe in Second Edition, but this is 4th Edition. :P 18DELTA ![]() |
| #26lord_karsusAug 11, 2008 12:36:14 | -And, that matters how? ;) -Ao is Ao. That's all. |
| #27BelorinAug 11, 2008 14:02:27 | Yeah, but AO was a plot device that got canonized and now can't be gotten rid of. I'm gonna houserule the spellplague cut realmspace off from AO. J/K Bel |
| #28lord_karsusAug 11, 2008 14:19:17 | Yeah, but AO was a plot device that got canonized and now can't be gotten rid of. I'm gonna houserule the spellplague cut realmspace off from AO. J/K -Rich Baker has mentioned that Ao will get 0 air time from now on. And, the part about Shar and Selûne creating the universe that Toril exists in is certainly the first step in ignoring and "forgetting" Ao. Which is regrettable. |
| #29rauricAug 11, 2008 14:24:16 | -Rich Baker has mentioned that Ao will get 0 air time from now on. And, the part about Shar and Selûne creating the universe that Toril exists in is certainly the first step in ignoring and "forgetting" Ao. Which is regrettable. LK is right, AO is AO and the edition changes never mattered when dealing with him/her. I am happy that they decided to let Selune and Shar create everything. That is always how I saw it. I am glad Ao is being written out in the end. Another change I am happy with I guess.:D |
| #30MirtekAug 11, 2008 14:30:00 | And, the part about Shar and Selûne creating the universe that Toril exists in is certainly the first step in ignoring and "forgetting" Ao. Which is regrettable. Where does it say that they created the universe? AFAIK the story is just the same which has been told in other sources before: Shar and Selune were the first entities to come to conscious within realmspace, yet realmspace itself was already there (just mostly empty) Also the two don't seem to have created the world of Abeir-Toril, which was already their (just barren and lifeless) and some time after them developed it's own consciousness as Chauntea So they were the firsts to build castles in the sandbox, but someone still had to build the sandbox for them |
| #31lord_karsusAug 11, 2008 14:40:24 | Where does it say that they created the universe? -The recent Shar and her church excerpt. In 4e, the story has been retconned and revised such that Shar and Selûne "created the universe that Toril" is in. |
| #32meldreadAug 11, 2008 15:05:20 | I don't think a myth can be retconned. It's just a myth and there are no doubt many versions floating around. Cannonly speaking Ao has been trying to erase his memory from the minds of mortals since the Time of Troubles. The new myth simply reflects what Ao has been attempting to do since that time. For me personally I am happy to forget. |
| #33BelorinAug 11, 2008 15:29:08 | Forget who?:P Bel |
| #34meldreadAug 11, 2008 16:02:09 | I don't remember. I've forgotten what we were talking about already. :P |
| #35lord_karsusAug 11, 2008 16:31:16 | I don't think a myth can be retconned. It's just a myth and there are no doubt many versions floating around. -It's already been retconned, from 2e to 3e. |
| #36lord_karsusAug 11, 2008 16:31:47 | Forget who?:P -I think we were talking about that Drow deity of Undeath whose name escapes me at the moment...? |
| #37phelf_der_zemitAug 11, 2008 16:44:18 | Classy. :P |
| #3818DELTAAug 11, 2008 17:18:49 | -![]() 18DELTA ;) |
| #39markustay63Aug 11, 2008 18:01:29 | I think I got too heavy a dose... Who the hell am I, again? ![]() |
| #40markustay_dupAug 11, 2008 18:03:53 | I have NO idea... |
| #41markustay63Aug 11, 2008 18:04:33 | Damn... I was hoping you at least would know... ![]() |
| #42BelorinAug 11, 2008 18:40:28 | So it seems alot of the racial pantheons survived with some surprising additions and subtractions, if we go by the list from the Huzzah thread. Interesting is that the elemental princes are now primordials along with Bazim-Gorag, Dendur, Kezef and Borem of the Boiling Mud, the last three being three of the seven Lost Gods. Bel |
| #43vulpesAug 11, 2008 21:47:06 | From what I remember, the 3E FRCS said the following (taken from Wikipedia, but I'm almost positive it's practically the same as the passage I remember): Lord Ao created the universe that holds the world of Abeir-Toril. After he created the universe, it was just an empty, gray, and misty void, a timeless place of nothingness that existed before light and darkness became two separate things. Out of this shadowy realm came the two beautiful twin goddesses Selûne and Shar, goddess of light and goddess of darkness. The Shadevari would have been in the "misty void," if they're still a part of canon (and there's been no word one way or another since the Shadowking novels, so they technically still are). One can't talk about divine families without thinking of that mass of cobwebby dysfunction that is (well, was) the Dark Seldarine. Poor Selevtarm. He never stood a chance, what with crazy Grandma Dearest, uninvolved/enemy Grampy Corellon, deadbeat Dad Vhaeraun, and hippie black sheep (how appropriate) Eilisteraee. Now Grandma Dearest has bumped the rest of them off. |
| #44lord_karsusAug 11, 2008 22:15:19 | -The nasty dude was falling in love with his aunt...![]() |
| #45entombmentofamachineAug 12, 2008 15:15:53 | Betaextinction Who the hell is that? |
| #46merrikcaleAug 13, 2008 21:21:06 | Damn... I was hoping you at least would know... that was odd |