| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1nopityforacowardMay 26, 2008 22:55:50 | Funny how scoiety can raise you from the actual truth. After reading and destroying my mind on these usless Drow novels, I came to see that every indivdual drow of some great acomplishment other than presitess or matron mother belonged to the males. All the house masters...magic..meele, Males? As for legendary adventures..drizzt...jarlaxell? Zak? Overall because of shere numbers and fear, Women would win in the udnerdark, yet as a single entitie of a drow, hands down for the males. None to less...drow filth is irrelivent. I wonder if RAS did this as a inside joke.Also I'm sure they're many more that some can mention that I have not. |
| #2iakhovasMay 26, 2008 23:19:59 | You need to read the Starlight and Shadows trilogy. And the War of the Spiderqueen series. Both series have powerful female drow protagonists. |
| #3rauricMay 26, 2008 23:26:23 | Nooooo! Don't feed it Brian, please don't! |
| #4nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 0:00:55 | You need to read the Starlight and Shadows trilogy. And the War of the Spiderqueen series. Both series have powerful female drow protagonists. Yes in that, there was a some Drow protagonists the meele master. I have read the 1st 3..but uh..it was so slow to take off. And I'm tired of seeing Monsters vs humnoids. I wanted The war of the spider queen to be about a bunch of Paladins from Lathander raiding the underark riding FR of potential evil. Like, how often do you see the "good guys" being on the offensive attack, and I don't mean just battle-wise, I mean as a whole war wise. |
| #5rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 27, 2008 10:28:10 | You need to read the Starlight and Shadows trilogy. And the War of the Spiderqueen series. Both series have powerful female drow protagonists. Ignore him, he's a troll. |
| #6StiggerMay 27, 2008 11:01:56 | Nah, can't be with such a cute punkin'head... |
| #7nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 11:26:14 | Ignore him, he's a troll. I'd wish you would take advantage of your own advice. Would you kindly leave me be Rinonalyrna Fathomlin? |
| #8zananMay 27, 2008 12:17:15 | I'd wish you would take advantage of your own advice. Would you kindly leave me be Rinonalyrna Fathomlin? Suddenly, the spelling reverts back to normal. How come? As for your inital post, all the characters you mentioned are novel figures and do exactly as their author planned. Not that hard to work out. Uh ... BTW, Rino is right. |
| #9nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 12:28:02 | Suddenly, the spelling reverts back to normal. How come? I don't understand what you are implying? No, I'm not a great speller if that's what you mean though. As for your inital post, all the characters you mentioned are novel figures and do exactly as their author planned. Not that hard to work out. And all the Drow Females do exactly as their author planned them to be. Not that hard to work out. Logic+1 Uh ... BTW, Rino is right. If she is, why aren't you taking to her advice as well? Being that she is right, you AND her should have not of posted any reply to this so called "trolling" that I am apperently guilty of. Instead, the both of you posting are keeping the 3 of us off topic. It was fine until the you and her felt the need to say something unrelated to a related FR topic. I honestly don't care though what anyone says (online;) ), and I've already stated that I will never report anyone. If there is something bothering you about me, feel free to PM me, it's better than bashing me publicly. Oh, for the record, I saw you re-added that last part about her being right at the last minute, it was not included on the post, when I hit quote, I saw it and was a bit confused. |
| #10chbushMay 27, 2008 12:53:05 | I've noticed a trend for darkelf females. There are plenty of powerful ones, but only backed by their Goddess. I don't think I've ever seen a powerful female that wasn't backed by Loth or Elistraee (or however its spelled). I think it was in Starlight and Shadows where Liryn's Father (who's name i cant remember or i would have just put that) said that Females have no aptitude for Magic its all passed down from the Fathers. (this doesn't mean females can't use magic it just means they would have gotten the talent from their Father not Mother) So they are not even a mentally or physically stronger gender, infact they are weaker as far as natural talents in magic and such. Anyone and their brother can use divine magic you just need to follow a faith so that doesn't help them. If not for Loth they would just be another male dominated society. But I guess thats all it takes is a powerful God/Goddess backing EVERY member of your race that is a particular gender. But personally I think Liryn could take Drizzt and by far I would say the most powerful darkelf is a female, Qilue. But she's an exception i guess...backed by 2 Goddess's Do you ever notice you don't see to many Epic leveled Darkelves. Despite everything Drizzt has gone through, the many powerful Matron Mothers and wizards, even Qilue. They all stop at level 19 maybe a 20. Every other race just craps out epic level characters. |
| #11rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 27, 2008 12:57:49 | I think it was in Starlight and Shadows where Liryn's Father (who's name i cant remember or i would have just put that) said that Females have no aptitude for Magic its all passed down from the Fathers. (this doesn't mean females can't use magic it just means they would have gotten the talent from their Father not Mother) So they are not even a mentally or physically stronger gender, infact they are weaker as far as natural talents in magic and such. Gromph's opinion was just that--an opinion, not a statement of fact. Liriel turned out to be more of a wizard than anything else, and she was quite good at it. |
| #12nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 12:58:55 | I've noticed a trend for darkelf females. There are plenty of powerful ones, but only backed by their Goddess. I don't think I've ever seen a powerful female that wasn't backed by Loth or Elistraee (or however its spelled). GG No Re K thx Yw |
| #13rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 27, 2008 13:01:19 | So, you prove that you don't actually want a discussion, you just want people to confirm what you already believe. Nothing new there. |
| #14rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 27, 2008 13:05:50 | But I guess thats all it takes is a powerful God/Goddess backing EVERY member of your race that is a particular gender. The problem with your argument is that being "backed by a deity" kind of applies to almost every character (male or female) because it's rare for a person in the Realms not to worship any deity. |
| #15nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 13:06:48 | So, you prove that you don't actually want a discussion, you just want people to confirm what you already believe. Correction, I want someone to confirm my assumption. The problem with your argument is that being "backed by a deity" kind of applies to almost every character (male or female) because it's rare for a person in the Realms not to worship any deity. Well when your diety backs only 1 Gender, or leans more towards them simply because of their birth outcome, you can't really say it applies to the Drow in specific, for Lolth does not favor the Males. |
| #16chbushMay 27, 2008 13:17:09 | Liriel that was her name (its been a long time since i've read the novels). Why does Liryn seem so familiar to me....*ponders* I guess you're right about everyone worshipping God's/Goddess. Its just not everyone has a Goddess that backs every female of a race. |
| #17rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 27, 2008 13:36:24 | Its just not everyone has a Goddess that backs every female of a race. Lolth doesn't back every female of the drow race. If that were true, why do many drow females fail and/or die horribly? |
| #18the_shamanMay 27, 2008 13:46:25 | Well, she back them in general - at least, she backs females worshipping her. I guess some drow females are more equal than others, though ![]() |
| #19nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 13:51:04 | Lolth doesn't back every female of the drow race. If that were true, why do many drow females fail and/or die horribly? Isn't that the same as saying God loves you but you're going to hell? Anyway, basically your point is contridictory because, according to your logic, no one would die because there god would back them. So in theory, no one that has ever served a God has died. Simple because a God won't wipe someones ass for them doesnt mean they dont back them up, they are not invinceable, and drow die horribly because other women do it to other women, and also Lolth enjoys chaos. It's like saying: "I'm an evil person and I like doing evil things, I love both of my evil sons, but I want to see which one is evilier, they will have my blessings" |
| #20chbushMay 27, 2008 13:51:22 | Thats because Lolth also loves backstabbing and ruthlessness, and promotes it to her females. So the ones that are better at it have more "backing" than the others :P And i would say Gromph was correct or atleast that his statement was accurate. He is probably one of the top 2 or 3 darkelf wizards. i'm sure he has probably done some form of research on it. I would rate him around the Khelben "Blackstaff" of darkelves, he might not be the most powerful wizard of the darkelves and he might not know the most about magic of all the darkelves...but he's close. You know everytime i seem to type a post NoPity seems to put something up just moments before I do and it says some of the same things :P :P was just noticing this coincidence, its not intentional. But i still stick to my guns, and say that gender-wise males are probably more powerful than the females. But the most powerful darkelves are still females. |
| #21StiggerMay 27, 2008 13:51:37 | Divine backing isn't a promise of automatic success... simply an edge to achieving it. And not always a particularly big edge. As to the rest, the males that are exceptional seem more noteworthy, but just because someone hasn't told their stories doesn't mean they don't have stories that are waiting to be told... |
| #22rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 27, 2008 14:05:35 | Isn't that the same as saying God loves you but you're going to hell? No, because Lolth loves no one. |
| #23rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 27, 2008 14:06:46 | Thats because Lolth also loves backstabbing and ruthlessness, and promotes it to her females. So the ones that are better at it have more "backing" than the others :P Which means she doesn't back all females, just the one's she "likes" at the moment. |
| #24chbushMay 27, 2008 14:09:38 | She is capricious isn't she. |
| #25zananMay 27, 2008 15:10:19 | No, because Lolth loves no one. Speak for yourself, speak for yourself. NoPityForACoward I don't understand what you are implying? No, I'm not a great speller if that's what you mean though. But of course you are. Have a look at all your replies after the original post and you get what I was pointing at. BTW, it does help to read rule and setting material aside from the novels, as the latter only give you a glimpse at the whole picture. |
| #26nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 17:19:57 | Speak for yourself, speak for yourself. Assuming you know who I am, you know I don't play this DnD game. So what else would I look into? More importantly, why would I look into it? Other than stats, I don't see how the novels can't get you the information you need since they are based on detail of FR. |
| #27red_wizardMay 27, 2008 17:45:48 | Don't worry, we all know who you are, and by now we should all know you're never going to try to learn about what it is you troll about. So why not agree to disagree, we'll continue enjoying the Realms, and you can continue --Silently preferably-- ignoring everything written on them. We'll all be happy then. -RW |
| #28rauricMay 27, 2008 18:09:27 | Loth is a horrible deity that "backs" someone until not backing them will cause the most chaos possible. The only beings who worship her are individuals that are raised into the religion. The other DE gods make more sense to follow because they represent a certain aspect and they may be less mean spirited towards their loyal worshipers that Loth. This is similar to my Shar/Mask arguement. Both gods are evil but Masks religion teaches things that common, sane mortals can understand while Shar is all about the destruction of the cosmos. People don't want to go to the afterlife and keep suffering for all eternity under the same douchebags they had to work with/for in their living days. Mask asks ya ta steal and gain power, Shar wants you to cut yourself and listen to My Chemical Romance. I know who I would worship if I was a sane bad guy.;) |
| #29JudgeDookieMay 27, 2008 18:13:55 | Assuming you know who I am, you know I don't play this DnD game. So what else would I look into? More importantly, why would I look into it? Other than stats, I don't see how the novels can't get you the information you need since they are based on detail of FR. You "don't play this DnD game," huh? Don't think I've heard that one before. Maybe heard of not playing for a while, but never that. As somebody who is currently not playing and focused primarily on the novels, I can assure you that picking up an FR supplement now and then is worth the time. FR novels do not cover everything. And supplements aren't necessarily just "stats" either. In fact, they give greater meaning and insight to the novels you are reading. |
| #30red_wizardMay 27, 2008 18:21:15 | You're wasting your time. This is his third incarnation at least on the boards, and each time he comes just to argue the same thing, occasionally taking offense when someone tells him some facet of the many things he doesn't know regarding this game, and the accompanying setting. -RW |
| #31nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 18:34:29 | Loth is a horrible deity that "backs" someone until not backing them will cause the most chaos possible. The only beings who worship her are individuals that are raised into the religion. The other DE gods make more sense to follow because they represent a certain aspect and they may be less mean spirited towards their loyal worshipers that Loth. Thanks, for the new perspective. You "don't play this DnD game," huh? Don't think I've heard that one before. Maybe heard of not playing for a while, but never that. Thanks, I will look into it more than, can you give me a few suggestions of where to look first? You're wasting your time. No thanks...hey uh RW, talk sexy to me. Always glad to see those who stay on topic out number those who don't and are out to bash others. |
| #32red_wizardMay 27, 2008 18:38:04 | lol, we'll see how well you learn this time, before I change my tune. Agreeing with one person now, doesn't change the past. ;) -RW p.s. Decided to edit your post back to immaturity I see. Good call. ![]() |
| #33JudgeDookieMay 27, 2008 18:47:57 | Thanks, I will look into it more than, can you give me a few suggestions of where to look first? Where to look or what to look for? I'll assume you know where to look. What? Well, from a readers standpoint, I suggest Faiths & Pantheons, Races of Faerun, and, of course, the FR campaign guide itself. These cover the three primary elements that you are going to run into when reading an FR novel. Slim on stats and good on history, relations, and lore. A "stat" book I would suggest looking into, though I don't find to be so necessary, is the MM. Sometimes you'll be reading and come across a monster you have no clue of. I just go look it up online if need be, but I always keep thinking I should pick on up. |
| #34nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 18:50:05 | Where to look or what to look for? What I meant by I don't play this DnD game is, simply just that. I just read the novels, I don't play the dice rpg thing. Never have. I don't like the candle keep, suffice to say, they suck up and kick you out for any negitave feedback that would only help the errors of such novels in my opinion. |
| #35JudgeDookieMay 27, 2008 18:50:13 | lol, we'll see how well you learn this time, before I change my tune. Do I dare ask what was originally posted? |
| #36ORC_ChaosMay 27, 2008 18:59:35 | I’ve removed content from this thread because flaming is a violation of the Code of Conduct. You can review the Code of Conduct here: http://forums.gleemax.com/community_coc.php Please return discussion to the topic of the thread, or it may need to be closed. |
| #37nopityforacowardMay 27, 2008 18:59:42 | Do I dare ask what was originally posted? Was: Thanks to 1st post Thanks to 2nd post No thanks to 3rd post All other typing you see are what was edited/added. But uh anyway, if I don't play the rpg thing, what do you suggest then. |
| #38JudgeDookieMay 27, 2008 19:00:11 | What I meant by I don't play this DnD game is, simply just that. I just read the novels, I don't play the dice rpg thing. Never have. I don't like the candle keep, suffice to say, they suck up and kick you out for any negitave feedback that would only help the errors of such novels in my opinion. Well, you do have a certain...charm...perhaps your "negative" feedback is seen as a bit hostile? I know you haven't seemed to be the most pleasant fellow to me. Yet, I'm trying to keep it on the level with you. As long as you respect me, then I respect you. And its just fine that you don't do the "dice thing." Yet, there are few that don't around here. And, simply because they do do the dice thing, generally means they feel much more personal about this stuff than just a reader. Perhaps that's why your input on somethings isn't greatly appreciated. Just voicing my thoughts--nothing more. |
| #39red_wizardMay 27, 2008 19:06:09 | I don't think there would be a problem if certain people could admit their shortcomings for ignoring all the material. However, some like to remain steadfast in their one sided arguments, and don't wish to branch out for more. I have made note many a time of various resources, as have others, to follow up on. Yet still, we remain here, arguing relatively simple matters of lore to no end. -RW |
| #40JudgeDookieMay 27, 2008 19:06:12 | Was: Then I'll assume that it was Red Wizard that got this: I’ve removed content from this thread because flaming is a violation of the Code of Conduct. You can review the Code of Conduct here: http://forums.gleemax.com/community_coc.php Either way, to return to topic, based off the current deviation, your view on drow may clash with most because they have a bit deeper insight because they do read the supplement material. Especially in the case of drow, you start getting into sourcebook stats and stuff, you see a different picture than what you do with the novels. |
| #41red_wizardMay 27, 2008 19:08:38 | Then I'll assume that it was Red Wizard that got this I'd not assume as such. That was for a post now removed on "NoPitys" part. -RW |
| #42JudgeDookieMay 27, 2008 19:17:28 | I'd not assume as such. That was for a post now removed on "NoPitys" part. I'm sure the text came off different than the context there, RW. Just trying to keep it civil. |
| #4318DELTAMay 27, 2008 20:45:36 | 18D ![]() |
| #44JudgeDookieMay 27, 2008 21:00:43 |
Eh!? I feed you, you happy smiley freak! Why not feed something that actually SPEAKS!!! :D Wanna peanut? Do you? ![]() :raincloud :rolleye2: ![]() ![]() :invasion: :pile: ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
| #45StiggerMay 28, 2008 2:11:05 | If you don't want to feed him, ignore the damned thread and maybe we can avoid keeping the Wiz-O's busy for a while... perhaps there would be less 'trolling' if you didn't give him things to respond to. On to the topic at hand... I'd agree with JD's list there, but I'd add in Power of Faerun to the list as well, great book that gives a lot of fluffy stuff on the way the halls of power work in the Realms that might help the books make a bit more sense. Lost Empires of Faerun is pretty good for the historical background as well, and not much crunch to get in the way. |
| #46heroofchaosMay 28, 2008 10:12:26 | Matron Banre 'nuff said |
| #47ranielkMay 28, 2008 12:20:16 | Well, you do have a certain...charm...perhaps your "negative" feedback is seen as a bit hostile? I know you haven't seemed to be the most pleasant fellow to me. Yeah, I'd have to back up the Judge here. There is much in the way of setting and content in the rule books. After all, this is a RPG setting that happens to be supported by novels. It isn't a group of novels that has had an RPG created for it. If we were discussing the Harry Potter RPG or the Green Rider RPG and you said "No thanks, I only read the books. Show me canon sources from the books and not the RPG." I'd get the point. But El, er I mean Ed, created Faerun as a Campaign Setting to run D&D games in. After that, novels were written to showcase the style of the setting and draw more people to the setting. The novels are just marketing for the RPG. You want to know lore, you've got to go to the sourcebooks. This is especially true of 3.x D&D sourcebooks. They are written 3rd person, so there is no ambiguity. If a 3.x sourcebook says Drizzt could take Ao in a fair fight, then that is so, and not the opinion of a narrator (though the author of the book would need his head examined). 2nd Ed sourcebooks use a narrator who isn't omniscient and may be pushing an agenda. All that adds up to the info in 2e sourcebooks being not 100% "The Truth." (tm) |
| #48blackball8_dupMay 28, 2008 23:52:53 | I think this whole thread is irony. |
| #4918DELTAMay 29, 2008 6:38:30 | Eh!? I feed you, you happy smiley freak! Why not feed something that actually SPEAKS!!! - ![]() 18D:P |
| #50jenrockMay 29, 2008 10:25:56 | I think that the reason that male drow tend to accomplish more impressive feats is because they (typically) have more to overcome. They grow up in a society where they are essentially breeders and bodyguards (wizards excluded from the latter, obviously). When you consider that the drow's monstrous slaves can fill the role of bodyguard (and even the breeder's role depending on the predilections of their masters), males would then have to be extraordinary in order to progress in such a society. EDIT: As Rinonalyrna pointed out, my first statement is not neccessarily true. My entire post, however (in my opinion) answers the question asked in the orignal post and the first statement is simply me rephrasing said question. Often times, in my drow campaigns, the females and males are both equally well accomplished, although the women understandably get the glory. |
| #51rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 29, 2008 11:47:04 | Always remember that we don't see the whole picture--the bits we see of drow society in novels and sourcebooks (which tend to focus on one city, Menzoberranzan) are just the tip of the iceberg and not necessarily representative of all drow everywhere. In other words, I don't think we can say with certainty that in general drow males "accomplish more impressive feats than females." |
| #52JudgeDookieMay 29, 2008 16:14:41 | - That's it, 18D--get all those things expelled from your system. You'll feel like a new man in no time. I think that the reason that male drow tend to accomplish more impressive feats is because they (typically) have more to overcome. They grow up in a society where they are essentially breeders and bodyguards (wizards excluded from the latter, obviously). When you consider that the drow's monstrous slaves can fill the role of bodyguard (and even the breeder's role depending on the predilections of their masters), males would then have to be extraordinary in order to progress in such a society. Right on. |
| #53zananMay 29, 2008 16:36:14 | Always remember that we don't see the whole picture--the bits we see of drow society in novels and sourcebooks (which tend to focus on one city, Menzoberranzan) are just the tip of the iceberg and not necessarily representative of all drow everywhere. Exactly! It's like reading the Ulster or Fenian Cycle (Cúchullainn, Finn mac Cumhaill et al) and trying to create a picture of the ancient Irish males in their society based upon those heroes. |
| #54rauricMay 29, 2008 19:49:50 | I think it is time for the drow concept in FR to get turned on its ear. I too am tired of the Matron society that is what we see in most FR novels about DEs. At least can we make them less..."witchy"? Perhaps they could be portrayed more like the Witches of Rasheman and less.... like "witches"? I am trying to be nice here but it is tough. The stereotype of the women being shrews because they can is getting old, I was hoping we could see a new spin on them all. |
| #55JudgeDookieMay 29, 2008 19:56:47 | I think it is time for the drow concept in FR to get turned on its ear. I too am tired of the Matron society that is what we see in most FR novels about DEs. Dude, I so agree. I hoped the War of the Spider Queen would accomplish that at the time, but it didn't. As is, I'm almost glad the Shade came around to share the evil. Drow--and their constant focus--has become overbearing and without change for far too long. |
| #56rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 29, 2008 19:58:49 | Well, remember what I said about the focus mainly being on Menzoberranzan--not all drow cities are like that. Some cities are focused on other deities besides Lolth, and in some cities males actually have power. |
| #57JudgeDookieMay 29, 2008 21:48:38 | Well, remember what I said about the focus mainly being on Menzoberranzan--not all drow cities are like that. Some cities are focused on other deities besides Lolth, and in some cities males actually have power. No, I didn't forget. I read what you posted. I'm just saying that they brought forth a Patriarchal sect that could have changed things. Didn't happen. ![]() Therefore, nothing changed, Lloth gained even greater power--in a sense--and we end up at square one, dealing with the same old crap in a more oppressive manner. |
| #58blackball8_dupMay 29, 2008 22:11:45 | --- |
| #59lord_karsusMay 29, 2008 22:52:15 | -Would a story about a great Male Amazonian hero make people think that, because of said individual, Amazonian Males are somehow "superior" to Amazonian Females? -That said, the word "superior" is a very general term, and must be further defined for any serious debate to continue. |
| #60rauricMay 29, 2008 22:54:35 | Well, remember what I said about the focus mainly being on Menzoberranzan--not all drow cities are like that. Some cities are focused on other deities besides Lolth, and in some cities males actually have power. Yep. Until another author does a writeup or story on another city where the women are less shrewish or a city where men dominate people will think of women drow as all being like the Menzo drow. |
| #61lord_karsusMay 29, 2008 22:58:46 | Yep. Until another author does a writeup or story on another city where the women are less shrewish or a city where men dominate people will think of women drow as all being like the Menzo drow. -Sshamath. Chaulssin. Ched Nesad (Current). |
| #62rauricMay 29, 2008 23:17:20 | I know those areas were touched uposn and Ched Nesad was quasi-detailed in one book but it was not enough or the stigma that all drow women are shrews would not still be around. |
| #63StiggerMay 30, 2008 0:52:37 | Sure it would... you just get them saying that its an exception to the rule, but still keeping the belief that the rest of the drow are just how they viewed them previously. Once you establish a stereotype in people's minds, its incredibly hard to shift it, even if you explain to them how it should be in details... Mystra & her Chosen being a case in point. |
| #64rauricMay 30, 2008 10:02:43 | Sure it would... you just get them saying that its an exception to the rule, but still keeping the belief that the rest of the drow are just how they viewed them previously. Once you establish a stereotype in people's minds, its incredibly hard to shift it, even if you explain to them how it should be in details... Mystra & her Chosen being a case in point. Too true. I can deal with both of those concepts (drow and the Chosen) and work with them but others have a tough time with it. Now that i think of it though I was never any sort of fan of Mystra. Hopefully Selune fills the gap and becomes what Myssy should have been. |
| #65StiggerMay 30, 2008 10:09:14 | Blasphemy dwarf... go back to drinking and leave the magic to the sober Mystra-loving races... :P ;) |
| #66rauricMay 30, 2008 10:29:08 | I am afraid that I may like the warlord class so much I may end up switching my concept from wiz/rog to warl/wiz. A warlord that can throw a few AOE spells around seems fun. How I play the dwarf may change though. Hmmm... |
| #67zananMay 30, 2008 12:25:01 | Point here is that we usually get the drow only from one angle, or rather from two which essentially are one and the same: that of a (male) gamer's character against the usual MM drow (archetypical Menzo caters to that view) and that of a reader of Drizzt novels focussed on one male character rebelling aganist those very same drow. All these drow are ruthlessly dominated by the Lolthite clergy. You hardly get anything else, so there is no wonder that people think that drow society works much like this all over the place. Which, of course, is not so certain. Of course, drow society as such always seems to follow extremes. People love to point at the Vhaeraunians, yet those were essentially nothing but a simple gender reversal ... and somesuch essentially rules nigh 90% of the FR world. (Yes, there is the odd female ruler here and there, but they are hardly the norm.) Anyway, you wonder how the drow as such may have become somewhat boring, as within Realmspace, they are not really active ... at least with regards to the surface realms. They had their little humdrum with the WotSQ, but that concerned only them and a handful of Underdark races. Only now, during the Lady Penitent series, a few things happened to the surface as well. We know of about 40 drow cities by name within Realmspace and thus enough versions which can easily spice up any campaign. I guess those who think of the drow as boring and in need for change have not deeply enough exploited these possibilities so far. I mean, you surely don't use your everyday Zhentarim or Red Wizard evil-doer in the same way time and again, do you? IF I was looking for a change within drow society, I would have shifted the utter focus on religion somewhat, at least in non-Lolthite communities. Just switching from one deity to the next is not the way forward. |
| #68StiggerMay 30, 2008 13:05:37 | Interesting thought, though I was under the impression that it was fairly even in gender distribution... if not at the moment, then at least historically. Was the impression Volo's guides left me with anyway. |
| #69lord_karsusMay 30, 2008 13:06:59 | I know those areas were touched uposn and Ched Nesad was quasi-detailed in one book but it was not enough or the stigma that all drow women are shrews would not still be around. -Lolthite society, which is the Drow mainstream, statistically, prompts the "shrew" mentality, if you want to call it that. Those that don't (the aforementioned cities, for example) are in the statistical minority. |
| #70rinonalyrna_fathomlinMay 30, 2008 15:14:00 | -Lolthite society, which is the Drow mainstream, statistically, prompts the "shrew" mentality, if you want to call it that. Those that don't (the aforementioned cities, for example) are in the statistical minority. And of course, it's not like drow of either gender grow up being taught to be nice to each other. Drow females are no more "shrewish" than male drow are backstabbing bastards. |
| #71JudgeDookieMay 30, 2008 19:30:03 | And of course, it's not like drow of either gender grow up being taught to be nice to each other. Drow females are no more "shrewish" than male drow are backstabbing bastards. But, because they are female, they tend to be able to take bigger risks and get away with a lot more. Of course, in a Menzo-centric society, that is. |
| #72lord_karsusMay 30, 2008 22:24:22 | And of course, it's not like drow of either gender grow up being taught to be nice to each other. Drow females are no more "shrewish" than male drow are backstabbing bastards. -Of course. All Drow cultures, save the Eilistraeean Drow, promote such practices. |
| #73nopityforacowardMay 31, 2008 9:52:59 | Love how biased this topic is, go figure the only 2 females who replied to this topic, defended who? Female Drow! Well I guess the same goes for males. My intent was just to show that in the Drow era ruled by women, men acomplish more on a global scale in the underdark. Women who acomplish more only do so because they have more options (Preistess). If males had fewer obstacles to go around, they would put Drizzt to shame with thier names. And who was the person who said "Matron Barne, thanks". Yeah, 1st noble house, practically ruler of the underdark, not too much she can't do and get her name up there. It's like saying, you're an idiot but you are the President of USA, even if you're dumb, your name will be up there....Pssst...by the way...she got beat by Dwarves. |
| #74red_wizardMay 31, 2008 10:37:31 | Given the circumstances, her death had nothing to do with gender, power, level, or age. The Glabrezu behaved like a demon, and she was the one who suffered for it. Put a Marine and a bear in a cage, and jam the marines gun, and the bear wins. Same scenario when you strip a 2000 yr old Drow of her magic and defense suddenly. -RW |
| #75zananMay 31, 2008 10:43:10 | ... My intent was just to show that in the Drow era ruled by women, men acomplish more on a global scale in the underdark. ... As it looks, you have read only novels where males (as they say) are the prime figures. Having three novel heroes running about does not prove anything with regard to drow society as a whole. Hence there was a suggestion to read lore rather than fiction. And if you prefer fiction, help yourself to the Liriel Baenre or even the Lady Penitent series and soon your whole argument will collapse. Why did Matron Yvonnel Baenre (mark the spelling, if you please) die? Because the author wanted her to die. Much like tons of other FR folk are dying at the moment for the sake of 4E. It has absolutely nothing to do with their in-game and thus in-setting abilities. On a sidenote, the males you are talking about have accomplished nothing on a global scale in the Underdark. One was a pretty decent fighter in one drow city (before being slain by a priestess with 10 levels less than him); another was/is a pretty decent fighter who left his city and runs about on the surface doing little on a "global" scale. The third one leads a mercenary band who has at least a name known in other Underdark cities too. Gobal players in Faerûn are (in no particular order) the Zhentarim (Manshoon et al), Thay's Red Wizards, the Twisted Rune and somesuch. |
| #76nopityforacowardMay 31, 2008 10:49:33 | As it looks, you have read only novels where males (as they say) are the prime figures. Having three novel heroes running about does not prove anything with regard to drow society as a whole. Hence there was a suggestion to read lore rather than fiction. And if you prefer fiction, help yourself to the Liriel Baenre or even the Lady Penitent series and soon your whole argument will collapse. You see, you defend women, and Rino will soon come along to back you up, I'm 100% sure. Zanan of the underdark: "This is blastphemy, this is orginized!" EB of the surface: "Orginized..? THIS...IS...SURFACE!!" (Kicks Zanan into pit of death back into the underdark!!) Der underdark wird fallen, und die Zeit von den Elfen ist über, hat die Zeit von EB begonnen! |
| #77lord_karsusMay 31, 2008 12:54:04 | My intent was just to show that in the Drow era ruled by women, men acomplish more on a global scale in the underdark. -That you say this demonstrates that your grasp on the subject is lacking. Please, go into more detail and elaborate as to how this is true, that Male Drow accomplish more "on a global scale in the Underdark" than Female Drow. Your very next point seems to wholly contradict this statement, which, well, doesn't help your hypothesis very much. |
| #78JudgeDookieMay 31, 2008 14:34:56 | -That you say this demonstrates that your grasp on the subject is lacking. Please, go into more detail and elaborate as to how this is true, that Male Drow accomplish more "on a global scale in the Underdark" than Female Drow. Your very next point seems to wholly contradict this statement, which, well, doesn't help your hypothesis very much. I imagine his "global" scale encompasses the number of male character's in novels compared to those of female and nothing more. As for you NoPity, might it be that these drow females are taken to be a bit more evil and twisted than some of the males and, therefore, wouldn't make much in the way of good heroines for a story? Also, please note that the women, in such drow based stories, give the orders and, as such, leave the subservient males to do their bidding. Thus, where the action tends to take place for such novels. |
| #79zananMay 31, 2008 16:12:02 | You see, you defend women, and Rino will soon come along to back you up, I'm 100% sure. Maybe you start reading what I write and not assuming what I mean? I do not defend someone, I state lore facts. And these novels belong to lore, all of them. I would kindly advice you not to press this men vs women issue too long. You see, we are talking about male and female drow here - not men, women or children. There is some sort of border one should not cross too often, whatever your personal opinion is on the matter. Methinks, BTW, a WizO has already given you a strong hint to only use the language all of them can understand. And no, they won't take any German lessons from you and will most likely react adversely to any such suggestion. As would I, as it is not exactly up to scratch. |
| #80nopityforacowardMay 31, 2008 19:12:38 | Course. But do you?;) I Edited my post, re-of course it. |