| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1Nirvana24Nov 01, 2009 17:45:15 | I'm a bit out of the loop, so could use some info! During the big cross over to 4th edition, was there anything drastic that happened to tieflings? The blurb about them in the player's handbook doesn't sound much like the demonic bloodline stuff I'm use to. Are tieflings in FR still the same as always? Or did they all get retconned and morph into what looks like satan's instrument? I always thought they had subtle features, not this obnoxious "hey guys I have horns and stuff" appearance. |
| #2The_SilverswordNov 01, 2009 17:56:27 | They way they look is all fluff and if you wanted to change it where you just got horns, or what ever like in Planescape, I see no problem with that, I dont think theres anything set in stone that says FR Tieflings are exactly the same as Core Tieflings. |
| #3Nirvana24Nov 01, 2009 18:02:41 | In the Races of Faerun book, it says they are the descendant of a half-fiend and humanoid. Does this still hold then? (As opposed to the core which mentions something about mages who dabbled in inferno magic or something along those lines..) |
| #4LordManshoonNov 01, 2009 18:04:42 |
I think both are considered acceptable in the Realms, though the latter doesn't overtake the former just because it's Core, similar to the lifespans issue. |
| #5Nirvana24Nov 01, 2009 18:05:44 | What lifespan issue? (I'm really out of the loop :P)
Edit: And hey, while I'm here on the new forums, are all the old threads deleted then? I had some good conversations with some dude regarding FR lore that I can't seem to find.. |
| #6LordManshoonNov 01, 2009 18:09:26 |
The Core lifespans for some races, such as Elves and Half-Elves, are significantly different than what's been established in the Realms. The official stance is that the Core lifespans simply don't apply, because they're so radically different and **** with NPCs that have survived the century time jump.
Edit: And hey, while I'm here on the new forums, are all the old threads deleted then? I had some good conversations with some dude regarding FR lore that I can't seem to find.. What old threads are you specifically looking for? I believe a number of them no longer show any posts at all, a result of the Great Change of these boards. |
| #7The_SilverswordNov 01, 2009 18:10:08 |
Alot of Core lifespans dont match up with established FR lore, Like for instance Core Elves live to be like 200 where as its well documented that elves in the Realms live to be like 1,000 years old. Realmslore trumps Core. Yeah what Lord Manshoon said |
| #8Nirvana24Nov 01, 2009 18:24:53 | Well that's interesting. Thanks for the info.
The thread in particular I was looking for was from a couple years ago actually. It involved the discussion of the cosmology of the realms, deities, their avatars, instances of deities from one verse to the next, etc. |
| #918DELTANov 02, 2009 8:48:33 | Was it Gray Richardson? Thats sounds right up his alley of expertise. Tieflings would come from the old Narfell domains. Narfell was an Ancient Empire that summoned alot of Fiends, before getting destroyed. Or just have the Spellplague change people into Tieflings if you want. |
| #10sfdragonNov 02, 2009 15:07:49 | descendandts of warlocks and fiend mating humanoids.... thats how I view 'em as |
| #11Nirvana24Nov 02, 2009 18:26:21 |
It was indeed Gray Richardson. We had a multi paged thread going on Cosmology. That dawg knows his stuff. Old Narfell domains... bleh this is getting confusing. I think I'll stick to the simple formula as outligned in Races of Faerun. |
| #12keithpNov 02, 2009 20:03:38 | I've just come to Forgotten Realms with 4th edition, so my Tieflings have had horns and tails. These have even figured into the story in small ways. |
| #13Shemeska_the_MarauderNov 02, 2009 23:23:54 | Yeah, the 4e material has run pretty roughshod over anything different from 4e core, even stuff that was well established previously. Tieflings with gigantic cow horns and a monolithic origin are in for 4e, and the vast variety of nature and appearance that was at the core of what tieflings were all about in 2e and 3e is out. It's a shame. |
| #14sfdragonNov 02, 2009 23:31:58 | not entirely ...... its still cannon |
| #15Demetri_KnighthawkNov 03, 2009 2:04:23 |
Almost, I think, or perhaps my own DM flair, I often forget. :P But tiefling + humanoid=tiefling because of dominant demonic gene traits make more tieflings. |
| #16pamelaNov 03, 2009 3:41:56 | I think the appearances are all a matter of player and DM choice. The Revenant article certainly invited leeway in presentation and I doubt it was meant to be reserved for that one particular race. |
| #17suin_bahhar_02Nov 03, 2009 4:20:31 | Tieflings on Abeir, the transdimensianal parallel world of Toril, are likely to be the origin of the more stable horned and tailed breed.You can even plug in the (admittedly awesome) Beal Turach background over there. |
| #18gomeztooNov 03, 2009 5:44:47 | Samantha, my FR tiefling, has very subtle features - tiny horns and an elegant tail (with a little arrowpoint at the end). There is also the suggestion of wings when one first sees her. Then again, Sam was originally an alu-fiend in old Narfell, who became a succubus in service of Grazz't when she fled the conflagaration, and was finally 'cast down' into tiefling form. Still, I chose to use a more subtle approach than the ram-horn redskinned monstrosities that Core tieflings seem to be. Gomez |
| #1918DELTANov 03, 2009 11:02:20 | I wish WotC would have done more with them. But I guess I get to have fun with them. |
| #20sfdragonNov 03, 2009 12:23:44 | there is one good thing about the appearance of the coretiefling. make ues of the cloak of the bat, and go raiding at night.....
they all just flee screaming demon |
| #21pamelaNov 03, 2009 13:27:34 |
Couldn't really blame 'em, could you? :P |
| #22sfdragonNov 03, 2009 15:19:18 | no.. but it makes easy work for banditry...... |
| #23neuroglyphNov 03, 2009 20:55:03 | In my FR game, I blamed their new "satan's nieces and nephews" appearance on the Spell-plague. As they were beings with some high end magic using DNA, I figured the S-P lit them up like a light bulb. I was even debating blaming the S-P for Dragonborn - I wasn't too sure how I liked the whole Abeir crossover stuff, and was considering declaring the Dragonborn to be 3.5 Sorcerers of Draconic bloodlines who go mutated by the 'plague. The Spell-plague is such a nice blanket to hide all your inconsistencies under huh? |
| #24LordManshoonNov 03, 2009 21:35:50 | I kept the old style and included the new style in my own Realms. The new, super-infernal spellbound ones are primarily found in Returned Abeir and elsewhere where rifts appeared during the Spellplague. These guys are nicknamed "Darkblood Tieflings" and consider themselves to be the true Tieflings. They hate their half-human counterparts with a passion, for the most part. The half-fiend, half-human ones are called "Grayblood Tieflings". Their human heritage is more apparent than their fiendish traits, and they're generally a more agreeable lot in common society. |
| #25sfdragonNov 03, 2009 22:17:08 | LM has it right, and dont argue with him, he might blast you into some other part of the realms |
| #2618DELTANov 03, 2009 22:56:15 | Lackey... |
| #27LordManshoonNov 03, 2009 22:57:29 |
Just because he likes my idea doesn't make him a sycophant. Care to tell us what you've done with Tieflings in your game? |
| #2818DELTANov 03, 2009 23:07:09 | Left them as is... |
| #29pamelaNov 04, 2009 11:41:21 | I've only seen one tiefling so far in our games, and he's been happy to use the 4e presentation. If I were a DM I wouldn't care either way but I think your take is a very good one to keep in mind, Manshoon. |
| #30neuroglyphNov 04, 2009 13:49:33 |
Ok... i'm jumping on the LM's Lackey Bandwagon - i like that treatment of Tieflings - even the names Darkblood / Grayblood sound cool... *bows before LM* I'm totally using them next time I game hehe |
| #31LordManshoonNov 04, 2009 16:10:09 |
It appears the people like what they see. My thanks for the compliments. |
| #32Nirvana24Nov 11, 2009 2:20:13 |
I don't fully understand your Darkblood Tieflings, due to not fully understanding the Spellplague and Returned Abeir, but I think this is a good idea to distinguish between the two. |
| #33The_SilverswordNov 11, 2009 2:41:20 |
I would try to explain the whole Spellplauge thing, but it would just sound crazy. |
| #34Nirvana24Nov 13, 2009 15:04:49 | I remember reading about what WOULD happen (before 4th edition actually came out). I haven't gone ahead and found out the finer details though, which I'll do when some free time comes about. I do remember the controversy though. |
| #35JudgeDookieNov 13, 2009 21:47:48 | Finer details? ![]() |
| #36RilsNov 17, 2009 11:26:13 | PS - Tiefling's heritage is devilish, not demonic... big diff. Our group hasn't felt the need to define an origin for 4e FR tieflings. They're just one of the races in the world, no biggie. We do tend to describe them more on the goat-horned human side rather than the huge-rams-horns red-skinned side, though. 4e tieflings seem to be fairly cosmetically bulky; ours aren't so much. Psychologically, they have hopes and dreams and fears the same as anyone. They tend to be solitary, mysterious wanderers, as there's no Tiefling Nation. Some are good, many are a little shady: the usual for NPCs. |
| #37StiggerNov 17, 2009 15:17:01 | As far as I'm aware, a tiefling was simply defined as someone who had less than 1/2 fiendish blood, as in a lower planar race, with no distinction between demonic, infernal, or whatever origin. Unless something changed in 3e that I'm not aware of... |
| #38JudgeDookieNov 17, 2009 21:43:16 | Eh. We had this discussion a bit back concerning Magadon. If Paul Kemp--responsible for "canon"--doesn't know what the hell a Tiefling is, does it really matter? |
| #39StiggerNov 18, 2009 7:33:11 | Author versus sourcebook, the sourcebook is gonna win every single time in my book. |
| #40LordManshoonNov 18, 2009 9:08:49 |
For which WOTC cares not a bit. ![]() |
| #41StiggerNov 18, 2009 10:59:29 | Which is why I'm not giving them much money these days, outside of SWSE. ![]() |
| #42angelus_obscuraNov 18, 2009 11:32:43 | I've always been partial to the human-turned-_____ path with races such as tieflings, shadar-kai, and other "corrupted from original" races (sometimes genasi). As for Magadon, he CALLED himself a tiefling, but he was in actuality a half-fiend. I think Kemp used the cutting of Mag's horns as a device that decreased his devilish power (much like Hellboy). |
| #4318DELTANov 18, 2009 11:48:24 | FYI Mark Sehestedt has a series coming out called "Chosen of Nendawen" The consumer, the despoiler, has come to Narfell. Hi followers have taken Highwatch and slain all who held it-save one. Book 1 The Fall of Highwatch Book 2 The Hand of the Hunter November 2010 Book 3 Cry of the Ghost Wolf. November 2011 Vengance will be yours, the Master of the Hunt Promises. If you survive. It looks like book one is out already... Looks interesting. ![]() |
| #44LordManshoonNov 18, 2009 17:59:48 | I was waiting for someone else to notice. Surprised me, since Mark writes good stuff indeed. |
| #45JudgeDookieNov 18, 2009 22:29:26 | Author versus sourcebook, the sourcebook is gonna win every single time in my book. I'll agree. Though, there is always the "canon is canon" contradiction.
No. I talked to Paul about it and he was quite honest in the fact that he wasn't aware of everything that was specified in the sourcebooks. One of the reasons I respect him more among many of the authors--he doesn't try to fabricate excuses or create hypothetical debates for his mistakes. |
| #46gomeztooNov 19, 2009 3:36:13 | FYI Mark Sehestedt has a series coming out called "Chosen of Nendawen"The consumer, the despoiler, has come to Narfell. Hi followers have taken Highwatch and slain all who held it-save one. There was a LFR adventure out that dealt with the aftermath of that book. It was fair adventure, slightly marred by the fact hat you could not really follow up on it, since the actual significant events take place in the novels. Gomez |
| #47Shemeska_the_MarauderNov 23, 2009 18:51:49 | PS - Tiefling's heritage is devilish, not demonic... big diff. Only in 4e. Previously they had a rather rich history as being descended from any (or even multiple) fiendish bloodlines (baatezu, tanar'ri, yugoloth, rakshasa, etc) |
| #48Shemeska_the_MarauderDec 01, 2009 21:08:23 | Hey Shemeska. Is Rip still around? It as been a while for me on these forums. He's still around here and there. I've been around a lot less though. Between the forums all but inducing eye-bleeding and WotC managing to entirely turn me off of FR in 4e, I've been spending time elsewhere. Mostly just lurking around here. |
| #49kvoDec 03, 2009 13:34:06 | I LOVE TIEFLINGS!!!! although if i were one i would resist cold instead of fire. i allow my players that option since there r 2, count em 2, distinct icy levels of the nine hells. yay! |
| #50The_SilverswordDec 03, 2009 22:08:56 | I LOVE TIEFLINGS!!!! although if i were one i would resist cold instead of fire. i allow my players that option since there r 2, count em 2, distinct icy levels of the nine hells. yay! Yeah that makes sense, theres Ice Devils so there should be Ice Tieflings. |
| #51gomeztooDec 06, 2009 2:00:11 | Maybe it will be in the races: thieflings book |