Who here would

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

sfdragon

Mar 18, 2010 13:55:20
support Aluando the Wise being returned to life???
#2

Matt_James

Mar 18, 2010 15:37:49
eh... Maybe an apprentice or some such that is rising to the knowledge-level of Aluando
#3

Jorunhast

Mar 18, 2010 20:25:14
Nah... Alaundo is like the FR version of Nostradamus.  Bring him back to life and it diminishes him, and people would likely demand a write up.  Keep him mysterious and inscrutable, much better for flavor.
#4

johnkretzer

Mar 19, 2010 0:57:39
Better to leave him dead.  He did his job...now let him rest.  It does loose alot of it's flavor to bring him back.
#5

Stigger

Mar 19, 2010 5:42:40

Wouldn't the time dead thing kinda preclude it even being remotely possible to do for mortal priests... doubtful even a wish spell would do much good there, given that it would pretty much follow the same rules as a True Resurrection sort of spell...

#6

LordManshoon

Mar 19, 2010 9:02:19

I'm of a similar mind to the others who have posted here. I think Alaundo should stay in his grave, lest a (probably gimmicky) return cost him some of his appeal as a famous NPC whose legacy after death has drawn the attention of so many Realmsfolk. That being said, I wouldn't mind a new NPC being introduced who intends to carry on Alaundo's work, whether or not it's a feasible goal. Perhaps some diviner claims to be aided by Alaundo's spirit, or a young man or woman attracts attention for his/her foresight and rumors arise that he or she is the reincarnation of Alaundo. Keeping things mysterious and uncertain would be the ideal path, to me.

#7

maeglin-amandil

Apr 01, 2010 15:36:20


maybe another person ascending to his level of knowledge (as mentioned earlier)
or perhaps a secret order (or single person) that was taught personally by him.
#8

Zireael

Apr 02, 2010 2:46:57

I'm of a similar mind to the others who have posted here. I think Alaundo should stay in his grave, lest a (probably gimmicky) return cost him some of his appeal as a famous NPC whose legacy after death has drawn the attention of so many Realmsfolk. That being said, I wouldn't mind a new NPC being introduced who intends to carry on Alaundo's work, whether or not it's a feasible goal. Perhaps some diviner claims to be aided by Alaundo's spirit, or a young man or woman attracts attention for his/her foresight and rumors arise that he or she is the reincarnation of Alaundo. Keeping things mysterious and uncertain would be the ideal path, to me.




A reincarnation of Alaundo? Wow, I'm all for it!
#9

18DELTA

Apr 02, 2010 3:18:16
We need to focus on bringing Mystra back...




18DELTA(RESTORE MYSTRA!)
#10

The_Silversword

Apr 02, 2010 3:31:46
Yeah so Cyric can kill her again!
#11

sfdragon

Apr 02, 2010 8:15:50
Tymora's Bossom
#12

sfdragon

Apr 02, 2010 8:17:35
I will have my revenge, and by Holy Hoar... you will all rue the day, and today seams like a good day, start rueing.
#13

18DELTA

Apr 02, 2010 8:46:57
Yeah so Cyric can kill her again!


No he won't, Foxy will get to kill her in time for 5E!
#14

creyzi4zb12

Apr 02, 2010 9:22:50
Gruumsh will soon kill Cyric in the later 4e editions...it's because of this issue...Cyric, the mad-god has performed too many deicides, and is almost trying to hit the Guiness book of WOrld Record for killing the most gods, but Gruumsh will now try to break that record...by killing the defendant himself!
#15

Jorunhast

Apr 02, 2010 10:18:28
Didn't Alaundo worship Savras?  I can't remember.  But if he did, his soul would have probably been in Dweomerheart when it was destroyed - so his soul (like the others there at the time) would have been destroyed too, right?

Seems like a waste and a shame for all of those souls to have been destroyed, probably millions of petitioners of Mystra, Savras, and Azuth all utterly destroyed, from the millenia that they were worshipped, gone forever.  But I think that's what happened when Dweomerheart blew up.
#16

LordManshoon

Apr 02, 2010 11:45:45
Didn't Alaundo worship Savras?  I can't remember.  But if he did, his soul would have probably been in Dweomerheart when it was destroyed - so his soul (like the others there at the time) would have been destroyed too, right?

Seems like a waste and a shame for all of those souls to have been destroyed, probably millions of petitioners of Mystra, Savras, and Azuth all utterly destroyed, from the millenia that they were worshipped, gone forever.  But I think that's what happened when Dweomerheart blew up.

It's funny you should mention this, because months ago Iluvrien and I had a discussion about the fate of the souls who were in Dweomerheart at the time of Mystra's murder. Although I, like you, initially thought the souls would have been wiped out, a response by Rich Baker was found regarding the matter, which stated that the souls on Dweomerheart (at least most of them) actually survived, and that it was likely they would have gone to other planes, such as Kelemvor's or Selune's, with Dweomerheart in ruins. So, despite what may seem like a guaranteed annihilation of souls, the planar explosion actually didn't decimate the dead faithful of Mystra and her allies.

#17

Jorunhast

Apr 02, 2010 22:27:59
Didn't Alaundo worship Savras?  I can't remember.  But if he did, his soul would have probably been in Dweomerheart when it was destroyed - so his soul (like the others there at the time) would have been destroyed too, right?

Seems like a waste and a shame for all of those souls to have been destroyed, probably millions of petitioners of Mystra, Savras, and Azuth all utterly destroyed, from the millenia that they were worshipped, gone forever.  But I think that's what happened when Dweomerheart blew up.

It's funny you should mention this, because months ago Iluvrien and I had a discussion about the fate of the souls who were in Dweomerheart at the time of Mystra's murder. Although I, like you, initially thought the souls would have been wiped out, a response by Rich Baker was found regarding the matter, which stated that the souls on Dweomerheart (at least most of them) actually survived, and that it was likely they would have gone to other planes, such as Kelemvor's or Selune's, with Dweomerheart in ruins. So, despite what may seem like a guaranteed annihilation of souls, the planar explosion actually didn't decimate the dead faithful of Mystra and her allies.



How strange.  I always thought that an outer plane was shaped (to some degree) by the souls that the god(s) brought there to be with them.  This would suggest that souls are nearly indestructible, which is contrary to all the spirit/soul-related spells, items and such that can damage or utterly destroy souls.  Sounds maybe like the designers are being really inconsistent (not that I'm shocked).

#18

The_Silversword

Apr 03, 2010 2:22:43
The way i see it, the souls are bound to the plane, so if the plane is destroyed, the souls are set free.
#19

LordManshoon

Apr 03, 2010 11:37:19
The way i see it, the souls are bound to the plane, so if the plane is destroyed, the souls are set free.

This is more or less the right of it, given Rich's response. At least, it's one strong possibility.

#20

suin_bahhar_02

Apr 03, 2010 13:56:14
I tend to agree with the viewpoint souls are made up of energy, and you cant destroy it, only transmute its form from one state to the next.