| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1darkdiashiAug 30, 2009 10:36:56 | Hey This is my take on Gandalf the White. The focus is on fire (and hope) from his ring Narya, and radient from his maia origin. I also tried to give him items and utilities that shocased bits from the literature. Whadaya think?
====== Created Using Wizards of the Coast D&D Character Builder ====== FINAL ABILITY SCORES STARTING ABILITY SCORES
TRAINED SKILLS UNTRAINED SKILLS FEATS POWERS ITEMS |
| #2dark_empireSep 02, 2009 2:54:32 | Nah, he's first level. If you are feeling genereous give him a +1 staff of light, and a few points in the Healing skill. That would match the powers he displayed in the books. Mannerism and behavior: Complusive lying (about abilities), and Glory Hound. Don't even get my started about that overrated Ring of Invisiblity. 4th editon does not try to simulate fantasy books anymore, doing so will only lead to disappointment. If this is an NPC just give him a new name, Merlin, Obi-Wrong, Fizbin, it's all the same Wise Old Man, Mentor and Master of Exposition.
|
| #3QubeSep 02, 2009 4:10:16 | Nah, he's first level. I don't think so. At a first level you can't break a bridge with a single tap of the staffs ... or fight a balor while you're falling. etc... However, I don't think he's class based: I think he's more like a monster stat block ... (PCs have lots of combat abilities, which he lacks) |
| #4pluisjenSep 02, 2009 4:20:53 | Actually you are better off building him in Mutants & Masterminds...
|
| #5AbdulAlhazredSep 02, 2009 13:36:13 | How's that really different from a 4e monster stat block? Epic high fantasy characters never have really translated well into D&D in any edition. 4th at least offers up a fairly free form monster stat block mechanism. I'd consider him to be something like an epic tier controller/leader. He did definitely have some sort of basic "zap" power (used IIRC once in the Chamber of Mazarbul) and some sort of not too well defined "power word" capability which sounded like it would be something like opposed arcana checks, but we really didn't learn enough about it to know how exactly it worked. Not really an easy character to stat because a lot of his action happened off-screen and was only described in general terms. Most of his on-screen action was non-combat or at least not directly involving attacking the enemy. Remember too, Gandalf and the Istari in general weren't about directly confronting evil. They were direct servants of higher powers who were supposed to channel those power's assistance to the free peoples in the form of knowledge and insight. Giving them powerful combat magic wouldn't really have fit their mission very well, and within the value system of Middle Earth would have probably been evil or at least counterproductive. It would be a LOT easier and probably more interesting to stat out some of the other main characters. They had a lot more concretely defined abilities. |
| #6thunderforge8Sep 02, 2009 17:32:41 | A while ago, I built a 4e scenario of the Mines of Moria and statted Gandalf the Grey at Level 9. Why so low? Well, the main reason was that I wanted a balanced party and Frodo certainly wasn't Paragon or Epic. I figured that Gandalf the White would be a decent Paragon Path version of Gandalf and after the Mines and Amon Hen, the others were more experienced and could become Paragon too as they began to accept their destinies in Two Towers. I think a Minas Tirith Gandalf the White would be Level 17 at best if you're going to have a player play him with a party of other Lord of the Rings characters (and that's being awfully generous since that would mean giving Pippin and Eowyn level 17 status). Of course, if you're not intending for any character to play him, then sure, make him an epic tier monsterblock. But I don't think he's level 30 and he's definitely not a Demigod. |
| #7pluisjenSep 03, 2009 3:37:25 |
An 'X' stat in M&M doesn't mean 'really high', it means 'whatever it needs to be at that specific time'
A character with X stats can do everything and anything the plot requires. It's strictly an NPC thing and even then should be used sparingly, but it fits Gandalf perfectly since he's a walking plot exposition with widely varying levels of power. |