| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1j_hoskins144Jan 04, 2011 22:16:24 | So a friend and I decided we were gonna make a unusual team for the newest DnD game we joined. I came up with the idea of a Goliath and Halfing teaming up and before battles, the goliath would pick up the halfling and litterally throw him at the enemy, or door, or anything else that might stand in our way. Our motto was "if it cant be done by throwing the halfling, then why do it at all" So we ran witht he idea without thinking about how it would be accomplished, so we rolled up a halfling monk and I drew up a Goliath Runepriest (knowing that a thrown halfling might need a little extra healing) I have briefly discussed (with the DM) how the rules would work and just how far i could throw my diminuative partner, but we cant seem to find any rules governing the action. Currently the halfling has done his part and been working on way to mittigate the damage from the throws and what not. My goliath has a Athletics bonus of 20 and a strength score of 21. We are both 12th level. The ideas we have come up with so far include 1) Athletics check for a non-attack throw, Athletics roll divided by 10= number of squares thrown. however i would like to find a way to be able to throw him more than just 4 squares with a crit. 2)Then a ranged basic attack as a heavy thrown improvised weapon for the attack, but we cant figure out the range. I did notice the Gorilla and Giatnkin gloves had ranged throwing properties, but wanted to figure out a non-magical way to do it also I was hoping the wonderful community out there could provide some extra insight into this matter, and mabye ways of improving it, mabye even to the point that i could throw other enemies as well |
| #2slobo777aJan 05, 2011 6:39:45 | A have two suggestions, which I will post separately The first is to extend RAW by creating a house-rule for throwing creatures, based on the use of Athletics skill to perform a Jump action: THROW WILLING OR HELPLESS CREATUREMake an Athletics check to throw a willing or helpless creature in your square or any adjacent square. The check is a move action. Grabbing an adjacent willing or helpless creature is considered a free action.
Balance wise this works out fine IMO - for the cost of a Move action and a couple of skill rolls, the Goliath has made the Halfling more mobile, but not by as much as he would gain by having an additional Move, and at a risk of it all going wrong (prone, damaged halfling, or not clearing the diatance). . . . in addition note that if the Halfling has a higher initiative, he can both Move next to the Goliath, use a Minor for some or other utility, then use his Standard to Ready an attack on the nearest enemy once he lands. That would be all be fine by RAW. Distance Thrown Horizontally: Make an Athletics check and divide your check result by 10 (round down). This is the number of squares you can throw the creature. |
| #3slobo777aJan 05, 2011 7:37:53 | For throwing resisiting enemies, we can base throwing effects on extending the RAW for moving a grabbed target: Throw a grabbed target To throw a grabbed target, you must succeed on a Strength attack. You must be grabbing the opponent, and there may not be any other immobilise conditions affecting it. The target may not be larger than you. Strength Attack: Make a Strength attack vs. Fortitude. Do not add any weapon modifiers. Effect: The grab ends. Hit: 1d4+Str modifier damage. Slide the target to any unoccupied square within 1 square of you. The target makes a saving throw and is prone if they fail. Special: Increase slide range to 2 squares if target is one or more size categories smaller than you. |
| #4slobo777aJan 05, 2011 8:07:03 | Now for some homebrew: Some Heroic Feats that might help you build you the perfect duo, that probably require balancing so that . . . a) They are worth taking, but b) They are not over-powered. Slam Throw Heroic Tier Prerequisite: Goliath Benefit: Gain +2 (heroic)/+4 (paragon)/+6 (epic) bonus to hit and damage with Strength attacks to throw a grabbed opponent. Increase slide distance by 1. Collaberative Throw Heroic Tier Prerequisite: Goliath Benefit: When throwing a willing ally, increase horizontal distance by 2 squares, or vertical distance by 1 square. Your ally does not take damage on landing and does not need to make an Acrobatics check to remain standing. Practiced Body Throw Heroic Tier Prerequisite: Goliath, Trained in Athleitcs Benefit: When throwing a willing ally or helpless opponent, you may choose not to roll d20, and instead use the value 20. Thrown Charge Heroic Tier Prerequisite: Trained in Acrobatics Benefit: On your turn after being thrown by an ally, you may treat the throw as meeting the movement requirements for a charge attack. If your first action is a melee attack, add +2 damage on a hit. Note that this last one allows the halfling to be thrown a square short, and charge the remaining single square (kind of continuing the momentum of the throw). . . . I think that's the basics covered . . . here's one more for fun: Midair Attack Heroic Tier Prerequisite: Trained in Acrobatics, Thrown Charge feat. Benefit: You may make a basic melee attack whilst flying as an Immediate Reaction. The trigger condition is any enemy changing from being out of melee range to within range during your movement. The target of the attack must be the triggering enemy. Special: Note limitations on when you can use Immediate actions, which essentially relegates this feat to a benefit when being thrown or otherwise moved on allies' turns. |
| #5SabelkattenJan 05, 2011 18:33:20 | Meh. Improvised ranged weapon (heavy thrown)! Let the halfling hold an action to make a melee attack when he hits. I'd probably add a push 1 or similar effect to it, thought. ;) |
| #6slobo777aJan 06, 2011 3:25:19 | Meh. Improvised ranged weapon (heavy thrown)! This simple suggestion would cost the tactical setup, plus 2 standard actions to get the effects of one melee attack plus a push 1. Seems balanced to me, once you include the free movement of the melee character. One thing missing from the suggestion - unlike a thrown weapon, the final position of the Halfling needs to be resolved (on a hit or miss), and is of some importance for team tactics . . . this cannot be left to DM ad-hoc rulings (which would be fine for a one off improvisation) since the tactic is going to be used a lot, it needs to be figured out . . . any suggestions how it would be resolved? I would immediately suggest the ability to use a (smaller) ally as an improvised heavy thrown weapon is in fact a new homebrewed feat that the Goliath should take. The feat can define where the ally ends up. The OP probably needs more than a minimal how to do it, hence my original feat suggestions which give the concept a little more longevity . . . so could anyone suggest some feats that would take this approach develop so that it is still fun to play in the 20th encounter onwards? |
| #7SabelkattenJan 06, 2011 4:19:54 | Well, Ok... Basic idea, just following the rules. Start out with the halfling making a held action, and then the Goliath picks him up (minor) and throws him (standard). Attack roll is STR vs/ AC, damage is 1d4+STR, range 5/10, if he hits the halfling can make an attack. The halfling always ends up prone in a square next to the target (unless he has some ability that allows him to land on his feet after a fall). On a hit the attacker choses the square, on a miss the defender choses. Now I agree that if it's a trained tactic it should be better. Make it a feat that gives an attack bonus to the throw, possibly an attack bonus to the halfling's attack, and adds some effect to the damage (like push 1 and possibly prone). |
| #8thespaceinvaderJan 06, 2011 5:57:00 | My interpretation, crossposted from Q&A: Halfling Hurl is a ranged attack usable as an RBA, heavy thrown, targetable at empty squares only. On a hit, the halfling lands standing. On a crit, he lands and gains CA against any and all adjacent enemies. On a miss, he lands prone. Minor to pick him up, Standard to lob him, and you have to do both in the same turn (but you can move in between if you wish, at half speed). Short range, probably between 3/6 and 5/10. The Halfling moves in as straight a line as possible, 1 square off the ground. Halfling can ready an attack for when he lands if he wants, or go into delay next to the Goliath to come out after the goliath's turn. Counts as forced movement for the halfling, so he doesn't (usually) provoke OAs. If mobs have OAs that can target forced movement, he falls prone in the first square where he can be affected by the power if hit. Enable it with feats for both characters, Halfling Hurler for the Goliath (prereq: at least medium size, STR 17: you gain the Halfling Hurl power, and can use it to Hurl willing Small creatures who have the Halfling Hurlee feat) and Halfling Hurlee for the ammunition (You can be Hurled by allies with the Halfling Hurler feat). Some of the other feats suggested above could jive with this. But I also like the idea of adding Halfling Mastery to give expanded crit :D |
| #9stargazer_dragonJan 07, 2011 19:54:18 | Added gear: spiked helmet, Does 1d6 Damage when your thrown at a target and hit Jaged spiked helmet: does 1D8 damage on a hit when thrown |
| #10OraibiJan 18, 2011 0:30:44 | I'm just disappointed that nobody's proposed a rule called "Fastball Special." |
| #11rampantJan 18, 2011 1:25:24 | I'd treat it as an assisted jumping charge using better of the two characters's athletics checks. |
| #12thespaceinvaderJan 18, 2011 3:10:34 | I'm just disappointed that nobody's proposed a rule called "Fastball Special." That's pretty much what we're all talking about, we're just not calling it that. Mainly because, apparently, none of us thought of it. D'oh. |