| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1Johnathan_VagabondNov 30, 2009 16:47:25 | I'm building up a world for a PbP game, and would really appreciate some feedback and nit-picking, especially with the Introduction or "This is the homebrew world in a paragraph" part where you try to explain everything in a tantilizing and not-boring manner to the players. |
| #2ah_maclimeszeroNov 30, 2009 16:55:20 | Holy awesome, Batman. That is fantastic. So, if I am reading this right, Wyst is your parallel to the Feywild, while Fyrna is the Shadowfell? The Arcanist/Primist/Divinist equivalences are easy to spot. All in all, a fantastic treatment. I would love to play in your world. Well done. |
| #3Johnathan_VagabondDec 01, 2009 10:59:51 | Well, you might get the chance if you join (or are part of) the Real Adventures group. |
| #4shadowhntr7Dec 01, 2009 11:34:53 | That is both awesome and highly original. Very nice! Am I understanding that the first two worlds are nested inside the third/fourth, or am I misunderstanding? What system will you be running this on, btw? |
| #5Johnathan_VagabondDec 01, 2009 12:11:40 | That is both awesome and highly original. Very nice! Am I understanding that the first two worlds are nested inside the third/fourth, or am I misunderstanding? Each "world" was once the actual Planet itself. Wyst was the planet before the Gods turned it into a shadow of the world. Rise was the planet before the Arcanists invoked the banishement, sending the God-Empires (specifically, their massive palaces) into orbit. Cataclysm was the name of the planet while it reacted to the sudden and uneven loss of mass. Finally Morn, (standing both for Morning and Mourning) is the planet after it finished coping with the redistribution of mass. In some way, the four worlds are like separate Ages as well as separate Worlds. The God-Empires are now moons. The Wyst is now a shadow planet. Cataclysm only exists in Talms. And Morn is what the planet is now. They mark radical changes. See, while an Age would simply be the end of a major time period, these separate 'Worlds' mark the major events in which the world no longer even closely resmebled it's past. Violent rebirths you might call it. I'll be running it on 4E, although I'll likely be playing fast and loose with the rules. |
| #6pbnDec 01, 2009 12:55:05 | Just a quick critique/review - to see if "all the bases are covered" The main translations that are needed via power-source/plane would be as follows: elemental - elementalists - Cataclysm primal - primists - Wyst dvine - divinists - Rise arcane - arcanists - ?? shadow - undead - Fyrna As with most home-grown gods - Channel Divinity powers may need to be worked for each of the 7 If you decide to go with Warlocks - star, fey, possibly even dark may be covered, but infernal may need a tie in. Primal and Arcane classes (as well as martial and psionic) should be alright. (with the note on warlocks above) |
| #7Johnathan_VagabondDec 01, 2009 13:10:34 | Just a quick critique/review - to see if "all the bases are covered" Arcanists draw on the power that ties the Wyst to Morn (whether through study like a Wizard or talent like a Sorcerer). It used to be they drew off of ley lines, but now they don't need to. I don't know what you'd really call it. It's left vague so everyone can interpret it differently. Elementalists will be able to draw on the leftover energies from the cataclysm and from the Talms. Undead are tied to the Fyrna I suppose, but in the opposite manner in which they usually are. Undead can't reach the realm of the dead, rather than inhabit it. I suppose it would be like a world of ghosts in waiting, where as the other corporeal and non-ghost incorporeal undead are trapped on Morn (willingly or no). Yes, Channel Divinities need reworking. I figure that'll take a little work, most likely I'll just pick 7 and give one to each god. I'm not sure what to do with the old Hells, except perhaps connect them via a strong Taln. The Gods want souls, the Wyst wants souls, the abominations on the Fyrna want souls. Maybe the devils and demons will be part of the creatures that hunt souls on the Fyrna. They'd need some flavor refluffing, but it should be easy enough. Or maybe just no infernal pact. It will probably depend largely on the party make up. I make cut demons and devils out entirely if no one runs a hellock. |
| #8darkspartanDec 01, 2009 14:32:18 | Holy awesome, Batman. That is fantastic. So, if I am reading this right, Wyst is your parallel to the Feywild, while Fyrna is the Shadowfell? The Arcanist/Primist/Divinist equivalences are easy to spot. All in all, a fantastic treatment. Wow... Definitely nice work, J_V. I see PBN was very right about your storytelling capability. I'm in too, if you'll have me. -Sarena |
| #9tylara67Dec 01, 2009 14:46:40 |
The wording on this part is confusing. You might think about having the First World and the Feywild-equivalent have slightly different names instead of calling them both Wyst, in order to make it easier for people to tell which of the two you're talking about. |
| #10Johnathan_VagabondDec 01, 2009 15:09:10 | I can understand how that is difficult to keep straight. I tried to separate them by referring to one as Wyst and the other as The Wyst. Would perhaps a capital The (as opposed to "the") clarify? I find I'm rather attached to the idea of them sharing a name. I suppose I could call them both Wyst, just say that it became it's own separate shadow of Morn. Although, thinking about it. The PCs will only know it as the Wyst, they wouldn't know what Wyst (without a The) is. As they unravel the truth, it becomes adds to a level of suggestion and allusion. |
| #11pbnDec 01, 2009 16:35:11 | Now to be a bit more specific (thinking of Storm) - I worry about this part...Elementalists will be able to draw on the leftover energies from the cataclysm and from the Talms. I know she doesn't know all of this yet (or does she?) - but would that not put her at odds with most of the rest of the world? It seems to me should would want those Talms to remain open. |
| #12Johnathan_VagabondDec 02, 2009 10:42:47 | Now to be a bit more specific (thinking of Storm) - I worry about this part...Elementalists will be able to draw on the leftover energies from the cataclysm and from the Talms. It could, to a point. However, I think it will end up being much more practical. Primists, for example, might praise the Wyst and 'seek it's return'. But really, I think they'd like it to get just strong enough that they can be the big fish in a small pond. Divinists might prefer the Gods stay at arm length as long as they can grant them more power. I would worry more that Elementalists could become a convenient political target, rather than the subject of a unified crusade. It's not like the Talms would be able to bring Cataclysm back into the world, they'll just leak powers and monsters into the world. Also, no, she wouldn't have a clue about any of this. No PC and very few NPCs will know about anything that happened before Cataclysm (and especially before Rise). History, for all intents and purposes, begins with Morn. |
| #13darkspartanDec 03, 2009 1:28:41 | How long has it been since Morn settled into it's current form? I'm guessing a number of years out to a century? -Sarena |
| #14Johnathan_VagabondDec 03, 2009 10:11:51 | How long has it been since Morn settled into it's current form? I'm guessing a number of years out to a century? From 3.5-5 centuries since the hard end of the cataclysm. However, there was a time before that when the cataclysm was in it's draw down stages, so others may place it earlier or later. After all, when all you've known is the literal churning of the world, at what point do you say 'everything is normal again'. Example: The cataclysm was in a state of constant earthquakes, some of them up to magnitude 11 (richter scale goes to 10). At what magnitude do you say "Oh, the cataclysm is over"? Magnitude 7? 4? 1? It's a fuzzy thing, just like when a new generation begins and the last one ends, only drawn out over centuries. DM Speaking: The cataclysm ended in recent history, but distant memory. |
| #15pbnDec 05, 2009 23:02:55 | Have there been any empires in that time? if so, how many? Both in the above world, and in the tunnels. How much is known of the various tunnel races and how they came to unite? |