| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1pigknightJun 17, 2008 23:14:44 | I had watched the ol' skool 'toons since I was a lil' child, now I talk to the lil' punks that are 1 year younger to me and they don't know what a Captain Planet is, or why I just said that DBZ makes Tom and the ice cream company (Jerry) look like pacifics. Most kids nowadays don't know about great cartoons such as Ed, Edd, and Eddy, or Dexter's Lab (it had a D&D parady episode, I just reliezed that). The only 'toons they have that doesn't have random senseless violence is Camp Lazlo, Chowder, ect. (I didn't think writers for children programs could be "chemically enhanced"). I will admit there is some anime that I like, most of it being the kind that makes you think and isn't just random senseless violence (I have video games for that ) (i.e. Death Note, Code Geass, Bleach [to some tiny extent, at least there's a plot]). The one thing that really irks my chain is Naruto, it's not a ninja 'toon, it's a duskblade/beguiler/battle mage 'toon. Also Dragon Ball Z is the exact same thing over and over again, the villians are just carbon copies (literally once) of each other.On a side note "greatswords" longer than 6 ft annoy the hell outa me. [/rant] So what are your opinions about nime in general (I know it's not a genre, its a style, but a lot of it is very similiar. Talk, talk, talk, fight, fight, fight, talk, next episode with no plot advance). |
| #2calronmoonflowerJun 17, 2008 23:27:49 | ![]() Old school... Speed Racer Macrocross Battle of the Planets Gobots Gigantor |
| #3darkangel1979Jun 18, 2008 0:22:41 | Any adult who still watches Western animation is on very shaky ground when it comes to criticizing anime fans, let me tell ya. Except if the cartoon is Gargoyles. :P |
| #4kerikJun 18, 2008 0:47:22 | Pigknight, how old are you? I'm eighteen and I've watched tom and jerry, dexter's lab, so on and so forth. I've also watched every anime you've stated there. And seriously, I'm not sad no one (or so you say) knows about tom and jerry. That show sucked to begin with. |
| #5zombie_babiesJun 18, 2008 13:53:34 | Whoa, whoa. If we're gonna' talk about older cartoons, let's at least list some good ones. Shows like Voltron, GI Joe, Exosquad (anime influenced), MASK, TNMT, etc. Not "toony" enough? Then try Smurfs, Gummy Bears, TaleSpin, etc. T&J was an alright show, but hardly an exemplar of superior programming. :D As for anime, I don't have much of an opinion. I was never really drawn to it. Well, except for Cowboy Beebop, that is. It just doesn't interest me. Today offers some fantastic adult cartoons as well. Adult Swim has many programs ranging from the well know Family Guy to some oddballs like Squidbillies and Frisky Dingo. All in all, there's a plethora of entertaining cartoons for the discriminating (or not) adult viewer. |
| #6darkangel1979Jun 18, 2008 21:47:18 | Damn kids and their anime. http://www.shortpacked.com/d/20080618.html |
| #7psyguardJun 18, 2008 23:54:39 | Any adult who still watches Western animation is on very shaky ground when it comes to criticizing anime fans, let me tell ya. Hey now I have a reasonable excuse. I make cartoons for a living. Plus Avatar is Western Animation, even if it dose borrow a lot from Anime. And we got a Smurfs movie in the works I hear. Frankly Animation is the same on both sides of the pond. 90% = half hour Toy Commercials and the other 10% is actually good. The Japanese just seem to have 10 times as much of it as we do. |
| #8MalcadonJun 19, 2008 3:11:43 | I had watched the ol' skool 'toons since I was a lil' child, now I talk to the lil' punks that are 1 year younger to me and they don't know what a Captain Planet is, or why I just said that DBZ makes Tom and the ice cream company (Jerry) look like pacifics. Most kids nowadays don't know about great cartoons such as Ed, Edd, and Eddy, or Dexter's Lab (it had a D&D parady episode, I just reliezed that). The only 'toons they have that doesn't have random senseless violence is Camp Lazlo, Chowder, ect. (I didn't think writers for children programs could be "chemically enhanced"). Ed, Edd, & Eddy, Dexter's Lab, ol' skool? I have new shoes that are older then that! Ol' skool is Bravestarr, Thundercats, Jonny Quest, He-Man, Voltron, and even the Dungons & Dragons cartoon! Captain Planet is a tree-hugging idiot! Camp Lazlo is utterly boring! Chowder is a dandly little fagget! DBZ is just retarded screaming and grandstanding! Bleach is DBZ, but with swords! Naruto should just kill himself! 'THE' Batman is nothing next to the 90s Batman. On the other hand. Avatar kicks ass! Billy & Mandy is dame good ****! Beast Wars and (non-ABC) Reboot was truly EPIC! Its hard to hate Anime as a whole, with all the diversity to it. At the lowest end, you get stupid **** like Pokemon, Dragonball Z, and G Gundam, and at the high end, you get some dame good **** like Serial Experiment Lain, Ghost in Shell: SAC, and Fooly Cooly. It ranges from super kwet to the 'taste of the ultra violence'. From light hearted cartoons to hardedge gritty pulp. From silly school-girl crushes to "rule 34"-type perversions! They got somthing for everyone, and that is the power of anime! |
| #9KobajagrandeJun 19, 2008 3:32:10 | Anyone who says they like old school cartoons and doesn't sing praises to Hanna-Barbera is a poseur. Top Cat and The Flinstones should be part of every kid's education. |
| #10ADHadhJun 19, 2008 6:15:44 | Damn kids and their anime. You've ninja'd me. Fun fact: if I'm not mistaken, big eyes have been introduced to manga by Osamu Tezuka. His inspiration was Mickey Mouse :P |
| #11farmer42_dupJun 19, 2008 6:33:58 | You've ninja'd me. Actually, most modern anime can trace it's roots back to Disney. It gets really heavy into the irony when you start talking about Miyazaki, whose style was directly channeled from Disney in the 1960's and whose back catalog is now published in most non-Japanese markets by, you guessed it, Disney. |
| #12BloodsoulJun 19, 2008 15:16:19 | This is one of those times I'm glad YouTube exists. Otherwise I'd have a hard time finding 80's Transformers, Daria, and The Family Dog. |
| #13pigknightJun 19, 2008 15:26:16 | *Smacks head into laptop for forgeting to type down the better cartoons* Farmer, you made me hate Disney. Also, I can't legally drink. Just saying. |
| #14RamienJun 19, 2008 16:07:58 | Are you talking about the original Tom and Jerry from the 40s, 50s, and 60s, or the newer stuff that's not nearly as good? |
| #15insaneengineerJun 19, 2008 17:03:46 | there has been some excellent animation from both us and japan. DBZ was ok except the battles were way too drawn out. dragon ball abd dragon ball gt were both superior to bdz. a short list of some of my favorite toons: teen titans, love the anime spoof style justice league unlimited, ya gotta love super girl telling captain atom to take the stick out 90's batman and superman 80's xmen the shin chan star wars spoof episode |
| #16ArtifactJun 19, 2008 17:24:13 | The first and only anime cartoon I ever watched as a wee lad would be Battle of the Planets (which is a "westernized" Gatchaman, as I understand it). Also watched some Space Ghost/Herculoids re-runs as well (but not much). The live-action Land of the Lost was a staple of my Saturday mornings ;). I enjoyed Thundercats, Masters of the Universe, and Transformers later in life, during my high school years, but are these considered anime? My guess is not so much. Anime has become more and more popular over the years. I'm 38 now (an old man ;)), but based on my childhood viewing habits, I can't help but think that I might enjoy anime cartoons. I know I loved the Battle of the Planet series, so I've always been curious. I've never had much exposure however and don't know where to start my viewing. Any suggestions? I don't have cable, but I do enjoy buying and collecting DVDs. |
| #17holy_beholderJun 19, 2008 22:07:18 | I have two words to why I think the vast majority of really old cartoons are sensless violence. Bugs Bunny. |
| #18vaalingrade_ashland_02Jun 19, 2008 22:35:00 | I'm sitting her, watching Comic Party and waiting for the senseless violence to start... |
| #19pigknightJun 20, 2008 0:41:26 | Are you talking about the original Tom and Jerry from the 40s, 50s, and 60s, or the newer stuff that's not nearly as good? This. The new stuff is horrible, I think I heard one of 'em talk. |
| #20farmer42_dupJun 20, 2008 1:22:59 | Actualy, they do occasionally talk in the old ones. Only once or twice, though. |
| #21pigknightJun 20, 2008 1:55:02 | But they don't say words, I heard words. Specifically "no" but it's still a word. |
| #22farmer42_dupJun 20, 2008 1:57:12 | Actually, they did use specific words. Like I said, it only happened once or twice, but they did speak. EDIT: Typically, it was Tex providing a voice. He did the same thing for Wile E. Coyote. |
| #23ADHadhJun 20, 2008 7:46:26 | I have two words to why I think the vast majority of really old cartoons are sensless violence. Bugs Bunny. Especially when he nips the Nips. Actually I think that what really changed in cartoons are a) technology and b) pop-culture references. Anything else is just coming back and forth throughout the years. |
| #24RamienJun 20, 2008 8:06:22 | Especially when he nips the Nips. Bugs Bunny was full of pop-culture references for its time, though. The pop culture has just changed enough between now and then that a lot of them go over the heads of people watching them today. |
| #25zombie_babiesJun 20, 2008 8:19:04 | I've never had much exposure however and don't know where to start my viewing. Any suggestions? I don't have cable, but I do enjoy buying and collecting DVDs. To kind of ease yourself in, try Exosquad. It was a cartoon that was influenced by anime. Really cool. They even killed characters off. It's older, of course, but it was fantastic. I'm not sure if you can get it on DVD, though. If you can, it'll be worth it. I also reccomend Cowboy Beebop. I know you can find that on DVD. Good stuff. |
| #26RamienJun 20, 2008 8:27:54 | Anime has become more and more popular over the years. I'm 38 now (an old man ;)), but based on my childhood viewing habits, I can't help but think that I might enjoy anime cartoons. I know I loved the Battle of the Planet series, so I've always been curious. I've never had much exposure however and don't know where to start my viewing. Any suggestions? I don't have cable, but I do enjoy buying and collecting DVDs. I'd recommend looking for Robotech/Macross(the original japanese series that was creatively edited and redubbed to give us the first couple seasons of Robotech), Voltron(they also just released its original japanese series in the US as well), or possibly the earlier Gundam series. |
| #27_jayne_cobb_Jun 20, 2008 10:55:12 | I had watched the ol' skool 'toons since I was a lil' child, now I talk to the lil' punks that are 1 year younger to me and they don't know what a Captain Planet is, or why I just said that DBZ makes Tom and the ice cream company (Jerry) look like pacifics. Most kids nowadays don't know about great cartoons such as Ed, Edd, and Eddy, or Dexter's Lab (it had a D&D parady episode, I just reliezed that). The only 'toons they have that doesn't have random senseless violence is Camp Lazlo, Chowder, ect. (I didn't think writers for children programs could be "chemically enhanced"). Wait, people are getting nostalgic for the 90's now? This is ridiculous. ![]() |
| #28norcalnerdJun 20, 2008 11:40:51 | I grew up in the 90's and I remember all the cartoons from Captain Planet, Dexters Lab, Robotech (just downloaded the series again to watch it, amazing!) As I grew up though it felt like I wanted something more from cartoons that western animation wasn't giving me anymore, but that's when I discovered Anime (Japanese Animation) and have been a fan ever since. The closest western animation that I can think of that ranks high on my list would have to be Avatar the Last Airbender. For those of you who only think of DBZ or Naruto when it comes to anime might be looking at the wrong demographic. Those two are categorized as Shonen which is meant for a more younger teenage audience. I'd suggest Seinen for us older folk, and dare I say it? Shoujo, if you want something with a more feminine touch (aimed towards women). A big thing that factors into Anime that people sometimes miss though is that it's from 'Japan' and their customs and mannerisms are very different from ours in the States. Peace ![]() |
| #29psyguardJun 20, 2008 13:31:18 | I get really sad watching Bugs Bunny these days. I remember these shows when I was a kid and I see an episode I remember and I smile as I see the punch line coming up and ...... nothing. Because they had to edit the punchlines out to make it more "safe for children" When Bugs makes a turkey out of Dinamite and feeds it to the Tazmainian Devil, it's only funny if you actually see Taz Eat the Turkey, have it explode in his stomach and watch him swell up like a balloon then beltch smoke. but no. Bugs walks off screen with a sizzeling Dina-Turkey then /CUT/ smoke is coming out of Taz's mouth. It's just sad that kids aren't allowed to enjoy these things anymore. ![]() |
| #30zombie_babiesJun 20, 2008 14:47:18 | It's just sad that kids aren't allowed to enjoy these things anymore. Not really. I spent 4 years in juvey for dynamite turkeyin' my 3rd grade teacher. What? She had it comin' ... |
| #31ArtifactJun 20, 2008 18:14:12 | Just wanted to say thanks for the recommendations, Zombie Babies and Ramien. I had forgotten all about Robotech over the years, but now that I think about it, that would be one I'd prolly enjoy. Never heard of Voltron but wikipedia tells me ;) its a giant mecha, so I'd prolly enjoy it as well Cowboy Bebop looks as if it could be an unexpected surprise; I've certainly heard good things about it. These three look like a good place to start. Now that DVD sets are available, I can finally watch shows I never got to watch years ago, but would have enjoyed. Thanks again! |
| #32pigknightJun 21, 2008 11:44:01 | Wait, people are getting nostalgic for the 90's now? This is ridiculous. The 90s were before 2000, when Bush got elected. |
| #33doomsoughtJun 21, 2008 22:22:01 | If you want anime with a story, get a Bit Torrent client, and rev up Google. Oh, and Flash_Plasma forgot outlaw star. I think that wraps up the best of the best. I've got all of Robotech on DVD+VHS. Now if you want something that is not just bad, but evil: try out Neon Genesis Evangelon, they say he had a stroke near the end, but I say he had to be sadistic madman. It starts out above average, but the ending is... like removing your brain threw a sweat gland in your foot with a rusty spoon. |
| #34zyrusticaeJun 22, 2008 10:40:24 | Anime is definitely not just for kids. The Japanese take their animation very seriously. They make shows for every range of the age bracket. This guy does a good job of blogging the more outstanding ones. If you're interested in what's good but never reaches the states (or at least, doesn't until several years afterwards), check 'em out. (You can usually find fansubs fairly easily for these.) |
| #35trayaJun 23, 2008 4:03:08 | I really think that people have a incredibly wrong outlook on what anime is. I myself think anime is alot better than western animation. Why? Because Anime actually has a meaning , actually has depth , it has a point. Sure captain Planet wants you to recycle and stop polluting but a lot of anime touch on morals. philosophy , religion , social interpretation. Not to mention that even though there are some westernized shows that have a point , they no where near the number of dumb downed violence shows. You say anime has nonscence violence (which I presume are shows like Love Hina) there are a WHOLE lot more western shows focused on nonscecne violence than there are anime , and even Love Hina touchs on social interpretation and relationships where things like bugs bunny and tom and Jerry do nothing BUT violence. Its very hypocritcal that people say that. Not to mention as I said earlier there is alot more depth in anime. Dragon Ball Z had more depth than most western animations , and thats saying alot. Not to mention that that is one of the main problems with people trying to understand anime. The first thing they look to is DBZ which most anime fans are only into for nostalgia reasons. But back to the depth , theres alot of character and world immersion that western animations lack ( minus the good ones like Beast Wars :D ) . I can get attached to characters in anime and connect with them , theres actually a meaning for them instead of just being random people doing random things. I would also like to say that narutards ruined Naruto. As much as people say its bad , its actually really good when you come looking for the right thing. Do not come into Naruto looking for assassins and stealthy ninja pursuits Tenchu style , you need to take into thought of a world where a ninja is more of a warrior and a common military at that. Naruto has a incredible amount of depth to it , one of the things I like. Almost every character has a story to them and something setting them apart from another , even if it turns into a huge DBZ style fight atleast there is a point to the fighting and where the anime is going. Atleast it has character development and depth. And at the same time it captivates a unique style while keeping it very action oriented. I like anime because they are more like books than western animation could ever be. The same reason I play video games. I am a person for story , I like to learn things and see others viewpoints of philosophies and morals. If you want to think of anime , dont start with DBZ. Right now pick up Neon Genesis Evangelion , its what started me into anime. There is nothing that is more thought provoking , philisophical , spiritual , and down right psychological than this anime. Its a beautiful peice of art. If you want to view something with any type of meaning then thats where you need to start. Then you might be able to see the depth that anime brings and how much more involving it is than mindless slugfest superhero western animation. |
| #36KobajagrandeJun 23, 2008 10:16:27 | Ah, one of the reasons why I generally avoid anime. I find it simply too presumptuous, quasi-intellectual and too hyped. |
| #37aotrscommanderJun 23, 2008 10:43:49 | Me, I've always considered myself a cartoon fan as opposed to an anime fan. I'll watch almost any cartoon - or anime - once, just to see what's it's like. I grew up in the eighties, so I remember Transformers when it was first on. And Centurions, which has to rank as may second favourite. And Jayce and the Wheeled Warriors (my vehicle bias is showing here, isn't it?) I've seen enough good, bad, indifferent and just plain awful cartoons and anime I judge 'em on their own merits. Cartoon wise, I think we're seeing a dip in the quality of western animation in the last few years; the end of DC's 90s run ending with Justise League Unlimited being the most recent, along with American Drago and Kim Possible - both of which I was astounded to find I liked, with them being Disney. I will also sadly miss W.i.t.c.h. Nothing new decent and serious in tone (save perhaps Legion of Superheroes and the upcoming Wolverine and the X Men) since JLU - and of course the end of Avatar. I think the highlight was the mid-late 90s with Marvel and DC's universes and the general quality of intellect going into cartoon cartoons (Dexter's Lab, Powerpuff girls, Johnny Bravo, even Megas XLR). The 80s started it (He-Man, Transformers, the Real Ghostbusters 1) but it wasn't until later the plots actually became really, really good. Anime-wise I'm happy, since I like both Pokemon and Naruto (as they have brightly coloured thing blowing the crap out of each other with even more brightly coloured things.) Avatar is of course, a bright spot, being one of the best shows I've seen - period. It has most of the neem of Naruto without the long drawn-out flash backs which is the least good thing about that show. If they actually were allowed to have blood in it ( a la Naruto) it'd be just about perfect. Avatar is so good I refuse to watch it on the telly and instead torture myself waiting for the full season boxed sets every year. Best of the current crop, cartoon-wise in my not in the least humble opinion? Ben 10 isn't too bad, nor is Legion of Superheroes (I think Teen Titans was better, though). Transformers: Animated I think is superb once you make the adjustment to the background and animation style. The fact they made Starscream more like his comic counterpart (I.e. badass) and slathered it with G1 references really helped. I'm definately looking foward to Wolverine and the X-Men, which looks like it'll combine the animation style of X-Men Evolution (which was okay, though the series itself was a bit meh) with something closer to the 90's tone. And it stars Wolverine voices by Steve Blum. The trailer looked awesome. 1Seriously, sometimes that show gave me the creeps. That was pretty cool. |
| #38pigknightJun 23, 2008 12:16:45 | After watching some cartoons and anime I've come to a conclusion: Holy crap its all the same really. Most of it is random violence, and the only thing that seperates cartoons from anime is that more cartoons have stand-alone episodes. Side Note: Naruto would be better if it didn't sell as a ninja anime. |
| #39rollingthunderJun 23, 2008 12:56:02 | Anime is to animation what rap is to music. /absolutely awful.... |
| #40holy_beholderJun 23, 2008 13:12:56 | Some Anime is crap. Naruto really isn't all that impressive, and Dragon Ball Z is just atrocious. But it is an incredibly wide genre, and there is some really good stuff in it. Miyazaki has produced a lot of incredibly good movies, in anime style. Same thing with cartoons, Avatar is way deeper than something like Tom and Jerry. Also rap isn't music. It has neither harmony or melody, only rhythm and to be music something needs two or three of those 3 things. |
| #41rollingthunderJun 23, 2008 14:44:25 | Some Anime is crap. Naruto really isn't all that impressive, and Dragon Ball Z is just atrocious. But it is an incredibly wide genre, and there is some really good stuff in it. Miyazaki has produced a lot of incredibly good movies, in anime style. Same thing with cartoons, Avatar is way deeper than something like Tom and Jerry. Try telling millions of people across the planet that. |
| #42trayaJun 24, 2008 1:58:40 | Anime is to animation what rap is to music. I like your justifications on the subject , even if its hollow without anything to support it. |
| #43pigknightJun 24, 2008 2:04:24 | Furthermore, both cartoons and anime have a lot of crap (Camp Lazlo, My Gym Partner's a Monkey, Naruto [only 'cause it is sold incorrectly], some of the Gundams [they stopped trying]). |
| #44thecobraJun 24, 2008 2:08:25 | Lumping all anime together makes about as much sense as lumping all American live-action movies together. |
| #45hanzo187Jun 24, 2008 14:17:50 | Hmm, I have to say, I find myself in the territory that likes (scratch that, LOVES) both 'toons and anime. Hell, I grew up watching both in the early 90's, when Sci-Fi would have that Saturday Anime thing and show Project A-Ko (my very first anime), Vampire Hunter D, Casshern: Robot Hunter, Akira, among others. I also enjoyed watching the old TMNT (I like the new as well 'cause it's more faithful to the comic), X-Men, Spider-Man, Batman (the 90's one), Pro-Stars (I'll admit it, I liked that show), and all kinds of others. Being a kid who grew up in the 90's, I remember plenty of the good animated shows (and believe me, I was also one of the dudes burning Pikachus in the street). Let's also not forget Liquid Television (back when MTV was actually good), which spawned Aeon Flux. Today, that's not much different, though I do tend to watch more anime than cartoons these days. I prefer the less "kiddy" stuff like One Piece, Afro Samurai, Rurouni Kenshin, Excel Saga, Cowboy Bebop, Samurai Champloo, Death Note (one of my favorites), Naruto (prefer the manga), Bleach (prefer the manga), Ghost in the Shell, and let's not forget the movies (Ninja Scroll, VHD: Bloodlust, Spirited Away, CB: Knockin' on Heaven's Door, etc.). I'm still a sucker for 90's cartoons, esp. X-Men (I wish to God that would be on DVD), but nevertheless, you can never say "you see one anime, you've seen them all". After all, as you have said, pigknight, you don't hate ALL anime, just some, and I'm with you to an extent. There are certain anime I just can't stand, like Pokemon (despise it). I am glad you made this thread, pigknight, despite any disagreement. This is a topic I've always wanted to discuss. |
| #46TouchfuzzyJun 24, 2008 14:44:37 | Lumping all anime together makes about as much sense as lumping all American live-action movies together. QFT I'm glad you have opinions I can agree with. ![]() |
| #47thecobraJun 24, 2008 15:26:21 | I love anime such as Evangelion, Wolf's Rain, Now and Then, Here and There, Cowboy Bebop, and Trigun. I consider the best anime completely equal to the best live-action movies. As advertised, Princess Mononoke easily matches Star Wars. Shows like DBZ, on the other hand, do nothing for me. (I remember attempting to watch it and only getting frustrated by the fight that lasted for five episodes. Recap, preview. Recap, preview. Wonderful.) |
| #48zaydracheJun 24, 2008 16:06:11 | I think something most Americans forget is that allot of the anime comes from manga. This causes something that takes several manga issues to resolve mostly because it is something that takes allot of space in the manga to take a ridicules amount of time on the anime. Naruto is a prime example as is DBZ with taking a ridicules amount of time for anything to happen because the action takes 5 minutes to happen when the mange took 50 pages. These shows are really not that bad (I much prefer the new naruto). The manga is usually much better imo. Growing up in the 80s sees lots of great shows. Many of these shows however where marketing campaigns for toys and caused much of the difference between Anime and western productions. Even much of the anime that was brought over at the time was to sell toys (Voltron is a great example). Most of this anime was so edited it barely resembles the original source material. Watch Pokѐmon in Japanese with subtitles to see what I am talking about. Unedited anime is much better and even the kiddy stuff is more interesting. I have already seen most of my favorites but i will throw out SilverHawks, Johny Quest, and Darkwing Duck. There are really too many others to mention but the first real anime I ever saw was Vampire Hunter D. |
| #49EscherEnigmaJun 24, 2008 18:24:49 | If you're curious about anime but want to try something completly different from DBZ and Naruto, try looking up yaoi. Very different. |
| #50pigknightJun 24, 2008 18:28:31 | Hell no. Don't do it. |
| #51holy_beholderJun 24, 2008 19:00:04 | Try telling millions of people across the planet that. Just because lots of people believe something doesn't make it true. Also, don't look up yaoi. Its a bad move. Unless you also play FATAL, in which case you should, just not at work. |
| #52farmer42_dupJun 24, 2008 19:07:21 | ...try looking up yaoi. V "IT'S A TRAAAAAAAAP!!!!" I would also recommend shows like The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzamiya. It's a little trippy, but it also pokes fun at anime in general (the main character wants a world filled with the standard anime tropes, but lives in the real world [sort of]) and still manages to have some really serious points. |
| #53pigknightJun 24, 2008 19:40:50 | The writers of The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzamiya were "chemically enhanced" the enitire time they were writing it. |
| #54psyguardJun 25, 2008 1:50:14 | Naruto, Bleach, DBZ, Rave Master, etc,,,, those are all pretty much typical kid's shows. Episode after episode week after week going on into the hundreds. The writing can be good and bad but they generally follow the same premise of Hero vs. bad guys and a steadily increasing level of power and destruction. They aren't exactly what I would consider the top quality stuff but they are entertaining and they sell merchandise. (if you think the Americans merchandise the crap out of cartoons you ain't seen nothing). Great for the kids but if someone isn't already an Anime fan (or someone with a strong inner child that likes to see things go Boom) they aren't exactly the sort of thing that will win them over. When I have to recommend Anime to someone I use this list. For Fantasy Record of Lodoss war Rune Soldier Claymore The Twelve Kingdoms Berserk Spice and Wolf For Sci-Fi Crest of the Stars + Banner of the Stars Figure 17 Ergo Proxie Other Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Dai-Guard Black Lagoon pretty much anything by Miazaki Perfect Blue Millennium Actress Death Note Those are the ones I consider some of the better works out there. Lodoss War and Rune Soldier in particular I think would be enjoyed by just about anyone who likes D&D. (Lodoss = Epic play style D&D, Rune Soldier = Fun play style D&D). There are a few other things I consider really good but the ones above are the ones that would appeal to the broadest number of people. Things like FLCL and Lain... well, you have to be in a certain frame of mind to fully enjoy them. |
| #55farmer42_dupJun 25, 2008 2:31:23 | That's a good list, Psyguard. I'd also add Outlaw Star to it and probably Bebop as well. The tight focus of the storytelling really kept them going. |
| #56xhereticxJun 25, 2008 11:37:58 | Watch animes like Elfin Lied, Trinity Blood, Hellsing, and FLCL and then try to tell me anime is kiddy stuff.;) There is too much variety. Like Naruto and Girls Bravo have about as much in common as Power Rangers and General Hospital. They are just animated versions of normal shows, with the same variety. |
| #57holy_beholderJun 25, 2008 15:58:46 | Yeah, its a huge category. It contains its fair share of crap, but judging all anime off of it would be like judging all live action movies off of the first dungeon dragons movie. Or Zardoz. Or it would be like judging all pen and paper RPGs off of FATAL. I would also add full metal alchemist to that list above. Its a pretty good show, with more of a focus on morality, ethics, human perception, etc. than most people who have ever seen more than three episodes give it credit for. It gets a lot darker later on too, and the fight sequences are usually fairly short. |
| #58xhereticxJun 25, 2008 16:07:21 | Yeah, its a huge category. It contains its fair share of crap, but judging all anime off of it would be like judging all live action movies off of the first dungeon dragons movie. Or Zardoz. Or it would be like judging all pen and paper RPGs off of FATAL. Yes, FMA is one of the best animes ever. It actually uses real scientific theories held in the early 20th century and a lot of Medieval Esoteric elements as well, which was pretty cool. I still can't believe it is a shonen, it should be a seinen. |
| #59pigknightJun 25, 2008 17:44:14 | I didn't think FMA was a kiddie anime, it's on Adult Swim and what not. Also a lot of stuff on it would go write over a kid's head. |
| #60farmer42_dupJun 25, 2008 23:04:45 | I was part of an interview with Al's (from FMA) voice actor at ACen this year.. He was a kid when he did, and he told us the funniest story about when he realized he couldn't do the Al voice anymore. He had been doing a panel at a different con and was asked to do a line from the show, so how started to try, and his voice cracked and he couldn't do it. He then stood up and declared, "I'm A MAN NOW!" one of the other VA's on the panel actually fell over laughing. EDIT: Some other random off-topic randomness from ACen: Fat Man in a Skirt Asks a Question |
| #61roxlimnJun 26, 2008 10:27:37 | Wow. There's a fair degree of uniformity here as to what anime is supposed to be good and what anime is all about. Violence? Anime? Are we even talking about the same thing here? Anime?!?!? That's weird. Sure, I watched my fair share of mindless hero-action shonen anime in my youth, but who hasn't? That's strictly kiddie fare, and male kids nearly always like that sort of heroic coming-of-age story, regardless of medium. These days, I like my shonen, too, but I've watched more of the anime library and truth to tell, only a small fraction of anime actually contains violence. Here's a bunch of shows I don't hear a lot of: Cooking Master Boy - it's probably shonen, but it's about the hero's journey to restart his family's retaurant business and fulfill his destiny as the best chef in all the world. No, he doesn't need to fight anyone in combat to do that. It's mildly entertaining. Not too good, but it passes the time. Grander Musashi - much the same formulaic thing as above, except about fishing. If you like to fish, you might enjoy the treatment of the hobby. Not a lot of combat here, either. Hikaru no Go - watched this recently. It's the story of a Go player's rise to prestige and power. Yes, Go, as in Chinese chess. You'd think watching an anime about a board game would be boring. You couldn't be more wrong. This thing is seriously addictive. 75+ episodes of win. Cardcaptor Sakura - magical girl series. Be warned, the cuteness factor on this is off the charts. If you don't like cutesy animation, steer wide and clear. Young girl lets a bunch of magic cards loose and has to track them all down to prevent world destruction. Very episodic early on, but there are no magical transformation sequences, she needs to use her head or her compassion often to capture cards, and it gets decidedly dark in the second season when the plot threads come together. Princess Tutu - ultra-cute animation hides dark depressing story, but good. Definitely darker than Cardcaptor. Yes, this is a ballet-dancing anime. Prince of Tennis - you guessed it, tennis anime. This ranks consistently high on the list for many anime fans. It's decidedly shonen in presentation, though. No, they don't beat each other up with rackets. Aishiteruze Baby - young high school boy finds himself saddled with a baby girl and faces the trials and tribulations of young parenthood. It's lighter-hearted than it sounds and is generally feel-good. Love Hina - harem anime in the tradition of Tenchi Muyo. College failure Keitaro finds himself the fortuitous manager of an all-girl dorm. Lots of fanservice and generally trite story, but if you're a guy who likes fanservice and a bit of romantic comedy, this is eminently watchable. His and Her Circumstances - a bit more mature in the romantic comedy genre, this is decidedly not for the unsubtle. There's a bit of slapstick going on, but you need to be able to read reactions and event implications to appreciate this. Please Teacher - alien earth monitor gets seen by a young high school boy in her true form. To maintain her cover and continue her mission, she gets involved in his life and they accidentally get married. The problem is that she's older and has a cover job as his teacher. More than a little weird, you have to have good suspension of disbelief to like this one; but assuming you do, it's okay. Great Teacher Onizuka - stupid ********er Onizuka gets it into his head that being a teacher is a cool job. He gets in and proceeds to set straight the most absurdly evil bunch of teenagers you can imagine. It's very exaggerated for dramatic and comedic effect, but if you can sympathize with the situations, it has many moments. Initial D - I would recommend this very highly. The graphic style is not typical for anime, and the computer graphics are now a bit dated, but for story, this one is great! Young tofu delivery driver Takumi discovers that his father has been secretly teaching him the ways of drift racing and he gets drawn into the illegal underground racing circuits. Emma - a Victorian Romance - realistic portrayal of interclass romance in the Victorian age in England. Lots of attention to detail. Very nice. Wing Chronicles - Princess Sakura's memories have been purged from her and if she is to survive, her friend Chaoran must travel through the dimensions and seek them out, one by one. There is some fair bit of fighting here, but mainly it's about finding little trinkets of magical power, which is what Sakura's memories have become. Kino's Journey - very philosophical anime about one boy's journey through the world. It's episodic so you can watch any episode you like and still get most of it. Slam Dunk and Dear BoyS - these are both highly recommended anime that I nevertheless couldn't like and never watched much. They're both basketball anime, but I gather that the main draw here is the romantic angle. Lots of girls like Dear BoyS. There's tons and tons and tons of anime out there. Most of it is crap, but a large number is actually very good, probably just because there's a ton of the stuff out there. Shonen anime forms only a fraction of that number, and of that, only a fraction involves extensive and outrageous hand to hand fighting and mecha. As far as I can tell, outside of shonen anime, mecha and fighting aren't even common anime elements - what little is shown comprises less than 20% of that particular show's airtime. Certainly, I saw no hundred foot leaps and mega mecha in Grander Musashi. Seriously, I think that if you consider DBZ to be the pinnacle of anime, you need to do yourself a favor and find a good show to watch - there's tons and tons of them out there. You can go a year watching only anime 8 hours a day 7 days a week before you run out of the best shows to watch. |
| #62pigknightJun 26, 2008 13:53:24 | I never stated DBZ was a good anime, I stated it was one of the worst. I like a couple anime(s?), but (like most new cartoons) I think most of it is crap. |
| #63roxlimnJun 26, 2008 16:09:39 | Most of everything is crap. This is nothing new. |
| #64viktor_von_doomJun 26, 2008 17:30:15 | Card Captor Sakura and Kinos Journey, good times. I really gotta hunt down those DVD's. And I'm surprised no one has said Magical Shopping Arcade Abenoshi, Fooly Cooly, or Tengen Toppen Gurren Lagan. |
| #65xhereticxJun 26, 2008 18:23:24 | Ahh, loved CardCaptor Sakura, watched it when I was a little kid and loved it. Recently watched Tsubasa Chronicles and that brought back memories...![]() Love Hina is an excellent anime too for anyone that hasen't watched it. I generally am a fan of ecchis, magical girl animes, good action shonens, and mature, bloody and philosophical seinens. I hate mechas though, blargh... |
| #66pigknightJun 26, 2008 18:44:49 | I remember watching CardCaptor as a kid, they canceled it fast for some reason (damn you Cartoon Network, damn you). |
| #67xhereticxJun 26, 2008 18:47:09 | I remember watching CardCaptor as a kid, they canceled it fast for some reason (damn you Cartoon Network, damn you). I also remember Sailor Moon as a kid, I used to think it was retarded, but looking back I do so miss it. |
| #68viktor_von_doomJun 26, 2008 18:56:59 | I remember watching CardCaptor as a kid, they canceled it fast for some reason (damn you Cartoon Network, damn you). I'm so happy they did, Card Captors was terrible, they butchered the original show so horribly. |
| #69EscherEnigmaJun 26, 2008 19:30:33 | Hell no. Don't do it. "IT'S A TRAAAAAAAAP!!!!" Hey now, you're spoiling my fun. |
| #70farmer42_dupJun 26, 2008 20:02:11 | Hey, I think there are many different aspects of anime that are great and should be encouraged. I feel comfortable as a heterosexual male recomending Utena and Sailor Moon (fansubbed, please for the love of god, don't go the way of the American version, it cuts and pastes and changes at will), but letting someone be lured towards the dark hole that is yaoi would be like sending someone to 4chan who has never been on the internet. Although, I'm thinking it might be fun if we introduced the Westburough Baptists to 4chan. It would be an epic battle of crazies. And Anon might do something really useful for once... |
| #71viktor_von_doomJun 26, 2008 20:14:46 | Hey theres some good Yaoi out there. |
| #72EscherEnigmaJun 26, 2008 20:38:20 | I just hope that yaoi isn't indicative of how Japanese women think gay men actually act. It's almost as bad as people thinking we're all limp-wristed flamboyant twigs. |
| #73xhereticxJun 26, 2008 21:14:58 | Hey theres some good Yaoi out there. Yuck, although yuri is nice. |
| #74pigknightJun 26, 2008 23:58:42 | Isn't it against the CoC to talk about yaoi, yuri, hentai, ect? |
| #75farmer42_dupJun 27, 2008 0:12:01 | I don't believe so, as long as nothing is really described, although yuri and yaoi aren't inherently pornographic. They're just "idealized" visions of homosexuality aimed at heterosexual audiences. They're both typically featured in shojo, so it's debatable what the "target" audience for yuri is, or the implications of such. And, EE, don't sweat it, I think it's aimed specifically at a teen-age heterosexual girl mindset not unlike the teen-aged heterosexual male view of lesbians. I hope. I'm not sure though, remember, untill our evil overlords at Hasbro (they who allow us to speak here, long might they rule our minds and bodies) took over creative control of the Transformers IP, there was that weird focus on having prepubescent girls and Nemesis Convoy redecos in the various series, so I wouldn't discount the possibility. BTW, in case anyone at Hasbro sees this, thank you doing away with such weird practices, though we could still do with fewer Nemesis Prime redecos. They get old. |
| #76viktor_von_doomJun 27, 2008 6:30:15 | I read a fair amount of Yaio (And yeah I'm a dude), only the biggest time wasters and slock are like what you described. |
| #77the_fanJun 27, 2008 6:43:38 | My favorite is One Piece. (25 years old here) It's one of the few non-Heroic Fantasy anime out there that I think would make a kickass campaign setting. It's a wide open world that really reminds me of the Points of Light setup (only the darkness is the ocean). The heroes form a party that fills different roles and will often work together in combat (they do pair off for the big fights, but normally there's a reason for splitting up). I regularly use it as an example for how healing surges, hit points, and other game mechanics work. Surprised it hasn't been mentioned in this thread yet. |
| #78richard_kJun 27, 2008 7:04:38 | Anime is pretty much all I watch nothing else really interests me, well cept for Avatar and Heroes. I think its become a bit of an obsession, its grown from the usual starter pack (Akira, Ghost in the Shell, Ninja Scroll) to about 450 dvds. To me I dont compare anime to the western style stuff cause it has become sort of a cyclical thing...western animation goes to japan and now japanese animation comes back to the westernised animation. On a side note though probably the best western animation ive seen in recent years is Avatar which is sort of anime-ish but before that and what i think was a very good blend is Gendy Tartatovsky's works...Samurai Jack and so forth. Damn it all this anime talk, might go rewatch Cowboy Bebop, though I'll wait till Predator is finished, to much of a classic to stop it half way. |
| #79roxlimnJun 27, 2008 17:25:14 | The Fan: There's a lot of great (not just good) anime that hasn't been mentioned here. The list is very, very, very long. Of course, there's also mounds and mounds of total crap, and many of the best anime isn't universally appealing, much like not everyone likes Sense and Sensibility, even though it is a very good Hollywood film nevertheless. What irks me is that a lot of Western audiences only get tuned into the mass produced products-selling crap like Pokemon and DBZ and immediately assume that this is the best that anime has to offer, or even that most anime is like this. It isn't, and I think people like you and I have an obligation to share our great experiences with anime to people who think that anime is only about giant robots and fighting men who call out their fighting moves while executing 70 foot jumps. |
| #80tiwaztyrsfistJun 27, 2008 18:08:46 | My favorites are quite varied. By type: Dark: Evangelion and Noir - Speaking of Chemically enhanced, the guy who did Evangelion? He was on Methodone for large portions of the scripting. He'd been in a bad car accident, and gotten hooked on morphine in the hospital. So, yeah, that's part of why that's so crazy... Comedy: Ranma 1/2 (Old school). Also, Irresposible Captain Tylor - So funny, I blacked out at parts from laughing so hard I couldn't breath. Romantic Comedy: Love Hina - Freaking awesome series. Things that got butchered in the American Release: Sailor Moon and Cardcaptor Sakura - The things they did to these... It was like watching someone butcher a kitten... I got the Uncut/unedited subtitled versions. You know, the ones with plot instead of suck. The ones where in cardcaptors, you realize at some point that the girl with the curly hair in Sakura's class has a psychotic level crush on the male teacher, and Sakura's brother is obviously having a relationship with Yukito. You know, that version. Other: Detective Conan (AKA Case Closed) - This thing makes most episodes of CSI look tame. Seriously, first one I saw, they guy had killed this girl, and was carrying her severed head around in his sweater (had the shirt stuffed so he just looked fat). He was using it to fake her kidnapping and confuse the time and cause of her death. Also, Slayers and Record of Lodoss war are musts for any D&D fan. |
| #81roxlimnJun 27, 2008 18:33:48 | I'm getting this really weird vibe from Cardcaptors. It's definitely not the same, which is why I specified Cardcaptor Sakura. I didn't think that Touya was getting it on with Yukito, but there was definitely something there. For that matter, there's definitely an attraction going on between Tomoyo and Sakura, and sometimes that's quite blatant onscreen. I kinda think that the same mindless censorship and misplaced parenting values in censorship killed the Cardcaptors translation and it's probably what's stunting mainstream American animation, keeping it from its full potential. |
| #82pigknightJun 27, 2008 19:18:31 | people who think that anime is only about giant robots and fighting men who call out their fighting moves while executing 70 foot jumps. I'm confused are we talking about anime or Transformers/The Matrix? ![]() |
| #83roxlimnJun 28, 2008 7:06:13 | No. Actually we're talking about Hong Kong cinema and American scifi. |
| #84tiwaztyrsfistJun 28, 2008 11:35:55 | I'm getting this really weird vibe from Cardcaptors. It's definitely not the same, which is why I specified Cardcaptor Sakura. I didn't think that Touya was getting it on with Yukito, but there was definitely something there. For that matter, there's definitely an attraction going on between Tomoyo and Sakura, and sometimes that's quite blatant onscreen. If you read the Manga of CCS, it's really, REALY obvious that Touya and Yukito are having a close, physical relationship. But then, keep in mind, CLAMP started out doing Yaoi Dojin of other popular series. I'm also liking the Resevoir Chronicles Manga, haven't checked out the anime version yet. |
| #85roxlimnJun 28, 2008 11:40:35 | Why? Do they kiss or something? I'm reading the manga now, so it'd be nice to know something like that in advance. |
| #86holy_beholderJun 28, 2008 13:12:27 | I'm confused are we talking about anime or Transformers/The Matrix? Were talking about Crysis. |