Last minute gift shopping, opinions wanted

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

pbn

Dec 22, 2009 18:24:04
So - my wife wanted a wii fit.  Trouble is, it fell through, and I won't be able to get one.  As a backup plan, she mentioned liking the "chocolate diamonds" she's seen on the Kay commercials(sorry, but off-color diamonds used to be junk back "in the day", but whatever).  Problem with that is she was thinking more of a bracelet, and they seem to deal only with rings and pendants.  As rings get tricky I was thinking of the pendant.  Next problem, the one I prefer (because of the make) is white gold (she prefers yellow, of course).  So, anyway... I have it narrowed down to three options - I figured to run it by you all (as I'm sick - physically - and running out of time)

option 1:
171820107_MV_LG.jpg

option 2:
172118806_MV_LG.jpg

or option 3:
skip the chocolate diamonds, go in to work tormorrow (despite being sick) and stop in at Tiffany's for lunch.

What would you do?
#2

drnick

Dec 22, 2009 18:25:36
First one is better. But I would skip the chocolate diamonds myself (it's a taste thing I guess).
#3

owls_and_more_owls

Dec 22, 2009 18:29:31
The second one looks too much like the company logo. I'd go with the first one.
#4

pbn

Dec 22, 2009 18:55:11
The second one looks too much like the company logo. I'd go with the first one.


My thought exactly (I really wish they had the first one in yellow gold)
#5

jameskennedy2265

Dec 22, 2009 18:57:55
How about get the first one, and stop in at Tiffanys during lunch just to see what they have.

If Tiffanys has something better then just return the chocolate heart shape thing.

Good luck on last minute Christmas shopping!
#6

zombie_babies

Dec 23, 2009 9:54:42
First one.  I really can't comment on jewelry all that much. Well, I can.  I just shouldn't. 
#7

boraxe

Dec 23, 2009 11:26:58
(sorry, but off-color diamonds used to be junk back "in the day", but whatever). 


Well go far enough back and all diamonds were pretty much junk. In the middle ages people used to liked coloured stones a lot more, rubies in particular. They thought diamonds were pretty boring.

Now this may seem a little déclassé at first, but have you a pawnbrokers you can get to easily? For the price of a new piece you can often pick up something equal or better in terms of material value with the added benefit of being vintage or antique and the generally superior design and workmanship that entails.

Good luck, mate.
#8

kiyuya

Dec 23, 2009 13:14:37
I would've gone with the first one. The second just looks... I don't know, it's got nice colours but there's so many ideas in there I just don't see what the artist was trying to get at. It's confusing and overwhelming. Whereas the first is down to earth, to the point, and simply beautiful!

Tell us what you did, and feel free to post pics if you went another route!
#9

darkspartan

Dec 23, 2009 15:01:21
Okay, from my perspective, number two is the company logo, and as such is right out. Number one would be far more appropriate for Valentine's Day, if it didn't look like the heart in question hadn't been left out for a few days on someone's kitchen counter and allowed to rot.

Those brown diamonds are industrial-grade stones that have been cut as gemstones. Not sure what your wife is thinking, aside from they're the "new thing" and therefore has "neat" value. I would drop into Tiffany's and see about something that looks a little nicer, with stones that might just be worth what you're paying for them. A nice tennis bracelet in yellow gold with emerald and/or ruby accents is far more likely to be worn over time than a heavy pendant that looks like it's been through a pool of blood and allowed to dry.

Not to mention, it's likely to be somewhat less expensive than that pendant. Once the fad value drops off, real jewelers are unlikely to appraise for even a third of their purchase price. It doesn't look like you're going to be able to do jewelry exactly the way she wants it, but at least you can get the right format, and find something that she'll wear, and be happy with.

I know I wouldn't be caught dead wearing either of those.

-Sarena

Edit: $1800 for that thing? Eeps! You can do loads better for much less.

I would love this, for example. If I really wanted to be expensive, maybe this one.

Good luck. I hope you find something worthwhile.

-Sarena
#10

pbn

Dec 23, 2009 16:38:47
Now this may seem a little déclassé at first, but have you a pawnbrokers you can get to easily? For the price of a new piece you can often pick up something equal or better in terms of material value with the added benefit of being vintage or antique and the generally superior design and workmanship that entails.

Good luck, mate.


Not declasse (sorry too lazy to find the accents) at all - in fact, have done so (with success) in prior years.  The biggest issue is really my own state of health.  I didn't make it in today, so the "second-hand" jeweler would be the only option to "blue box" it. (don't ask - she adores the blue box, regardles of what's inside)
#11

pbn

Dec 23, 2009 16:43:05
I would love this, for example. If I really wanted to be expensive, maybe this one.
-Sarena



Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you!!!!!
We have a winner.  She may have asked for the chocolate diamonds - but that first piece is PERFECT (given her tastes). (I should have browsed around more)

(oh, and the problem with the tennis bracelet idea, is the one she "really liked" had a HIGH 5 figure price tag - I don't make enough to justify spending THAT much on a piece of jewelry)

Hugs and kisses to you.  I hope you have the most wonderful holiday possible.
#12

darkspartan

Dec 23, 2009 17:25:36
I would love this, for example. If I really wanted to be expensive, maybe this one.
-Sarena



Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you!!!!!
We have a winner.  She may have asked for the chocolate diamonds - but that first piece is PERFECT (given her tastes). (I should have browsed around more)

(oh, and the problem with the tennis bracelet idea, is the one she "really liked" had a HIGH 5 figure price tag - I don't make enough to justify spending THAT much on a piece of jewelry)

Hugs and kisses to you.  I hope you have the most wonderful holiday possible.



You're very welcome. I just decided to have a quick browse around starting from your original post.

We don't expect you to get everything we want in a piece, at least not those of us with more depth than Keaneau Reeves' acting range. We want something you thought about, considered, and found based on what you know about us and the way we are.

Consulting another woman (or other outside group) isn't exactly cheating, as long as you made the final choice

-Sarena

PS- Hugs I'll take gleefully, but give the kisses to your wife for me. She needs them far worse than I do.

-Sarena
#13

zombie_babies

Dec 24, 2009 9:25:39
I would love this, for example

-Sarena



Heh.  I bought that one for the fiancee a couple of years ago.  She loves it.  Emeralds are her thing.  I made sure she has a full set (necklace, ring, earrings and bracelet).  This year I'm finishing her sapphire set.  Next?  Diamonds.  She hates rubys so I'm in luck.    I already got her her wedding bands (2 carats total - 2 5/8 with the engagement ring) but I still need to get a necklace, earrings and bracelet.  I may do pearls, too.  I like buying jewelry and, apparently, I've got fantastic taste.  If ya'all only knew what I did about the stuff, you'd see things a bit differently, I imagine.  We'll just say I'm at a certain advantage on these grounds.

I can't believe you picked that bracelet.  I mean, I know it's common, but I've never seen anyone with one.  Of all the stuff on that site, for that to come up is amusing. 
#14

boraxe

Dec 24, 2009 9:33:13
I bought my wife a replica of Arwen's Evenstar necklace one Xmas. She's not a huge geek but she loved the Evenstar in the LotR films and, even though it wasn't a huge amount of cash (less than $200) she really treasures it.
#15

zombie_babies

Dec 24, 2009 9:56:22
My fiancee loves frogs.  So I make it a point to include a frog somehow in the gift giving.  Last year, it was just a hidden froggy in her stocking.  This year, it's a silly frog puppet wearing the bracelet I got her.  I bet she'll dig that.  ;)

One year I was able to get an artist friend of the family to make a painting for her.  It's three tree frogs.  He paints on slate (and other stuff) and he's amazing.  Anyhoo, he's got one coming out of a crack he painted in the slate and some others on a branch an' stuff.  I think it's one of her favorite gifts I ever got her.  And, it's got a story to go along with it.  The artist is an odd guy (no way!) and keeps lotsa animals an' stuff around his place.  Well, he'd never painted frogs before (exclusive!) and had a couple of tree frogs about to serve as models.  One day, he went to go check on 'em and they were dead.  A tarantula he'd been watching for someone killed 'em.  Heh.  Whoa ... that's kinda sad.  Oh well, it's always neat to have something like that associated with a gift, IMO. 
#16

pbn

Dec 24, 2009 10:27:58
My wife's favorite is dragons.  I put together a rough design of a piece I'd like to have made at some point, but so far the 2 smiths I've found haven't been able to come through.  Basically, as I prefer silver and she gold, I was looking for a pendant - 2 dragons, 1 silver (or white gold mix, for better setting), 1 gold, facing each other (side view), shaped into a heart (with tails intertwined).  A black sapphire eye for the silver, an emerald eye for the gold.  One day.
#17

zombie_babies

Dec 24, 2009 10:36:29
Man, that would be pretty awesome.  If you ever get it done, ya gotta post up some pics. 
#18

darkspartan

Dec 24, 2009 14:47:00
My wife's favorite is dragons.  I put together a rough design of a piece I'd like to have made at some point, but so far the 2 smiths I've found haven't been able to come through.  Basically, as I prefer silver and she gold, I was looking for a pendant - 2 dragons, 1 silver (or white gold mix, for better setting), 1 gold, facing each other (side view), shaped into a heart (with tails intertwined).  A black sapphire eye for the silver, an emerald eye for the gold.  One day.



A somewhat more expensive, but sturdier setting would be all platinum, with one side gold-plated. I would love to see it done, though. I sounds absolutely beautiful.

-Sarena
#19

darkspartan

Dec 24, 2009 14:52:54

I can't believe you picked that bracelet.  I mean, I know it's common, but I've never seen anyone with one.  Of all the stuff on that site, for that to come up is amusing. 



I was looking for bracelets that came close to the description PBN gave, and thought it was pretty.

I'd wear it everywhere, myself, and it was less than a third of what the Chocolate heart was.

After all, no fair rejecing the current options without putting forward one I think would work better.

-Sarena
#20

Mad_Jack

Dec 25, 2009 1:12:01

I'm sorry, but I gotta say it... that second piece in the o.p., the corporate logo?

That's just bling for middle-class suburbanites... Seriously. Ugh.