what where is the barbarian (2nd Ed.)

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

zombiegleemax

Sep 21, 2006 7:34:52
I started playing roleplaygames with ad and d 2nd Ed. but lost contact to my original DM. Nevertheless for me 2nd Ed. was the king of it all so i managed to buy some used books (core rules).
But where is the barbarian? And there are only mages!
Where pls can i find barbarians and sorcerers? Did i miss something?

Thank you for your help!
#2

agathokles

Sep 21, 2006 13:02:08
But where is the barbarian? And there are only mages!
Where pls can i find barbarians and sorcerers? Did i miss something?

Uhm, Barbarians existed in AD&D1e (Unearthed Arcana, IIRC). They were removed in AD&D2e, along with Monks, Cavaliers and Assassins. The idea was that a "Barbarian" could be portrayed with a Fighter or Ranger with the appropriate weapon and non-weapon proficiencies.
However, there are at least a Barbarian kit (and a Berserker kit) in the Complete Fighter's Handbook, and a "Complete Barbarian's Handbook", which probably reintroduces the class itself.

As for Sorcerers, if you mean 3e Sorcerers, they never existed in any OD&D or AD&D edition, though the class could be mimicked by using the Player's Option: Spells and Magic book, which introduces free magicks (that is, in 3e speech, "spontaneous spellcasting").

Note, however, that there were many wizard kits and classes in AD&D 2e -- see the growing list here:
http://boards1.wizards.com/showthread.php?t=682417
#3

gerothian

Sep 21, 2006 20:33:37
the barbarian was revised and put into a players handbook reference book on barbarians, its called pbhr the complete barbarians handbook and the monk was revied and put into one of the 3 forgotten realms books called faiths and avatars, demihuman deities or powers and patheons. as for the cavalier and assassin, i've brought them across into 2nd edition myself. the cavalier was split into 4 different cavalier classes - the original cavalier class from the 1st edition unearthed arcana book, the elven cavalier from dragon magazine issue #114 or 116, the drow elven cavalier and aquatic elven cavalier
#4

zombiegleemax

Sep 22, 2006 5:43:58
Thank you very much you really helped me.
hmm... time to create houserules.:D
#5

greylord

Sep 24, 2006 20:46:23
The sorceror class can be found in the rules for the CRPG Baldurs Gate 2.
#6

agathokles

Sep 25, 2006 2:52:17
The sorceror class can be found in the rules for the CRPG Baldurs Gate 2.

Interesting. It seems that BG2 was a mix of AD&D2e and a few elements of 3e (monks, sorcerers, barbarian and half-orcs as "standard" classes and races).
#7

ateth_istarlin_dup

Sep 25, 2006 4:34:03
Any Idea wher I can find CRPG Baldurs Gate 2?
It sounds perfect for my hybrid game.
#8

agathokles

Sep 25, 2006 9:58:15
Any Idea wher I can find CRPG Baldurs Gate 2?
It sounds perfect for my hybrid game.

Try the Planet Baldur's Gate website (http://www.planetbaldursgate.com/bg2/), theres's a summary of the rules.

G.
#9

zombiegleemax

Sep 25, 2006 12:55:31
the barbarian was revised and put into a players handbook reference book on barbarians, its called pbhr the complete barbarians handbook and the monk was revied and put into one of the 3 forgotten realms books called faiths and avatars, demihuman deities or powers and patheons. as for the cavalier and assassin, i've brought them across into 2nd edition myself. the cavalier was split into 4 different cavalier classes - the original cavalier class from the 1st edition unearthed arcana book, the elven cavalier from dragon magazine issue #114 or 116, the drow elven cavalier and aquatic elven cavalier

The Assassin was a Thief kit in the Complete Theives book. I have no idea how well they did it, though.

Wasn't the cavelier addressed in F&A, too? Or am I mistaken
#10

agathokles

Sep 26, 2006 1:24:53
Wasn't the cavelier addressed in F&A, too? Or am I mistaken

It was in the CFH. The CFH and CTH kits are usually less powerful than the original classes, though the cavalier is an exception, and it still is very powerful (actually, IMO too powerful).

G.
#11

zombiegleemax

Sep 26, 2006 22:10:37
It was in the CFH. The CFH and CTH kits are usually less powerful than the original classes, though the cavalier is an exception, and it still is very powerful (actually, IMO too powerful).

G.

Ah-- I am looking now and see that F&A gives a new sub-class for Clerics called the Crusader, which is what I had in mind. But you're right re the Assassin and CTH. It seems weaker than the 1e class. I haven't looked at the CFH, though.
#12

zombiegleemax

Sep 29, 2006 14:23:45
The linked file doesnt exist anymore.

And thank you all for your help and interest.
#13

zombiegleemax

Sep 29, 2006 23:44:40
The Cavalier was a kit for the fighter, IIRC. The Assassin was a kit for the thief. Try the Fighters hand book and the Thief handbook for the kits.
#14

zombiegleemax

Oct 01, 2006 15:49:59
Any Idea wher I can find CRPG Baldurs Gate 2?
It sounds perfect for my hybrid game.

If you're looking for the game, try eBay. :D
#15

agathokles

Oct 02, 2006 2:06:34
The linked file doesnt exist anymore.

Uhm, which linked file?

G.
#16

garonak

Oct 02, 2006 6:33:36
The planet BG link. They've reorganized the site.


Just browse through the site, you'll fin what you're looking for.
#17

agathokles

Oct 02, 2006 10:02:11
The planet BG link. They've reorganized the site.

Just browse through the site, you'll fin what you're looking for.

Odd, the link doesn't point to any specific page, yet it is detected as faulty... anyway, this is the direct link: http://www.planetbaldursgate.com/bg2/character/classes/wizards/sorcerer/
#18

emeriliath

Oct 31, 2006 16:06:34
i've brought them across into 2nd edition myself. the cavalier was split into 4 different cavalier classes - the original cavalier class from the 1st edition unearthed arcana book, the elven cavalier from dragon magazine issue #114 or 116, the drow elven cavalier and aquatic elven cavalier

If you're playing with house rules, don't forget to add a paladin-cavalier or an anti-paladin-cavalier!
#19

extempus

Nov 01, 2006 15:41:05
The Assassin was a Thief kit in the Complete Theives book. I have no idea how well they did it, though.

In The Complete Thief's Handbook, it was decided that the assassin could be of any class, but was included as a thief kit to show how "a thief can be converted into an efficient, discreet killer" (p. 26).

The assassin was reintroduced as a rogue subclass in The Scarlet Brotherhood, as well as the monk as a priest subclass (pp. 72-74). Personally, I have no clue why they dropped them only to bring them back a decade later. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
#20

agathokles

Nov 02, 2006 6:02:09
In The Complete Thief's Handbook, it was decided that the assassin could be of any class, but was included as a thief kit to show how "a thief can be converted into an efficient, discreet killer" (p. 26).

The assassin was reintroduced as a rogue subclass in The Scarlet Brotherhood, as well as the monk as a priest subclass (pp. 72-74). Personally, I have no clue why they dropped them only to bring them back a decade later. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

They dropped them because AD&D 2e was originally an attempt at streamlining things: the idea was to compact classes into the four basic groups (plus psionicists, outside the core), and then use character kits to portray specialized class variants. So the Barbarian and Cavalier would be Fighter kits, and the Assassin a Thief kit -- but of course you could have Barbarian Clerics or Assassin Fighters as well (the Assassin Fighter kit is in a Dragon Magazine article, IIRC).

They were reintroduced probably as a Greyhawk specific thing ("The Scarlet Brotherhood" being a setting-specific book), to represent more faithfully the setting as it was in AD&D 1e.

Then which way was better is mostly matter of preferences -- personally I don't even use the Paladin as a class, since I prefer Paladin-like kits. Same for Assassins (they can belong to any class) and Cavaliers (just a Fighter variant, if at all needed). For Monks, I prefer to have martial artists of any class, so kits are still a better solution (actually, IMO the better oriental variant of AD&D is Dragonfist).
#21

Higmorton

Nov 04, 2006 17:48:46
The assassin and Monk are in 2nd ed as the Assassin of the Scarlet Brotherhood and Monk of the scarlet broherhood. I have a copy of the classes not sure what book it came from though.
#22

zombiegleemax

Nov 04, 2006 18:27:27
Also, in the Complete Priest's Handbook there is a kit named "Fighting monk".