| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1ZenzeiJan 14, 2008 0:22:34 | This guide will display my take on character optimization and hopefully provides tools and ideas regarding monk optimization for CO community. As a firm believer of "practical optimization", I'll strive for elegance, clear rulings and practicality as well as making the most of the class that is monk. This guide is not meant to be the end of all unarmed combat (since there are other ways to do it besides monk), nor this is a monk dipping guide. You may want to check out the original monk minmax creation guide by mean_liar. Thanks to Dictum Mortuum and his many works for idea how to make good looking handbook. |
| #2ZenzeiJan 14, 2008 0:23:24 | Monk's life in D&D First let's take a look at monk's class features so we can start to think how take advantage of them. d8 HD Medium BAB All good saves 4 skill points/level from good list
Alternative class features: Monk's have quite a few variant class features avaible to them and some of them are actually notable.
Here's a complete list of monk alternative features by Dead_Weasel (edits and corrections by me): Show Aquatic monk (SW): Walk across water at slow fall speed. Lose slow fall. Broken one substitution levels (CoV): Add heal and survival to skill list. 3rd level: Get lay on hands. Lose still mind. 6th level: Get tenacious tracker. Lose bonus feat. 7th level: Get locate creature. Lose wholeness of body. Dark moon disciple substitution levels (CoV, web): Levels have d6 HD. 3rd level: Get darkvision 60ft. Lose still mind. 7th level: Shadow blend: Gain total concealment in less than full daylight. Lose wholeness of body. 12th level: Walk the shadows: Gain ability to dimension door from shadow to shadow. Lose abundant step. Decisive strike (PHB2): Gain decisive strike, a full-round action attack that deals double damage and affects AoOs you make before the start of your next turn. Lose flurry of blows. Draconic fist (DM): Your attacks deal bonus energy damage, usable number of times equal to class level per day. Lose 1st level bonus feat. Durable (UA): Gain damage reduction as barbarian. Lose speed enhancement bonus and bonus to AC (but not wisdom to AC). Halfling Monk Substitution Levels (RotW): Levels have d6 HD. 1st level: Get skirmish ability that goes up to 2d6 dmg/+2 AC. Lose flurry of blows. 2nd level: Weapon finesse instead of normal bonus feat. 7th level: Size matters not: Get +4 bonus to grapple (only if you already have improved grapple) and stunning fist DCs against creatures that are two or more size categories larger. Lose wholeness of body. Hin disciple substitution levels (CoV, web): Levels have d6 HD, halfling only. 1st level: Choose stunning fist or underfoot combat as bonus feat. 2nd level: Choose combat reflexes or improved trip as bonus feat. 6th level: Blur of motion: Gain ability to attack a large or larger foe while using total defense. Requires 5 ranks of tumble. Lose bonus feat. 9th level: The harder they fall: Nearby allies can attack a foe you trip if you are occupying its square. Lose improved evasion (and the ability to gain it from other sources). Holy strike (CC): When hitting an evil creature, your unarmed strike is considered good aligned and does extra 1d6 damage. Evil monks can reverse this, applying it to good creatures instead. Lose ki strike [magic]. Kalashtar monk (RoE): Add autohypnosis and knowledge [psionics] to skill list. 1st level: Psychic insight: Can spend power points to improve grapple and stunning fist attacks. Lose flurry of blows. 2nd level: Can select psionic feat as bonus feat instead of normal monk bonus feat. 7th level: Wholeness of body: Can spend power points to augment wholeness of body healing. Phoenix disciple substitution levels (CoV): Must be lawful good. 1st level: Purifying flame: Add 1d6 fire damage to unarmed attack 1/day per monk level. Lose 1st level bonus feat. 3rd level: Gain fire resistance 5. Lose still mind. 12th level: Gain ability to use fire stride. Lose abundant step. Planar monk (PlH): Add knowledge [planes] to skill list. 5th level: Resistant body: Gain energy resistance. Lose purity of body. 13th level: Axiomatic soul: Gain spell resistance (class level +15) against chaotic outsiders. Lose diamond soul. 16th level: Get ki strike [cold iron]. Lose ki strike [adamantine]. Prayerful meditation (CC): Gain bonus on saves vs spells and effects of chaotic creatures and of creatures who's moral alignment is opposite to your own. Lose still mind. Skarn monk substitution levels (MoI): Add intimidate to skill list. 1st level: Spine strike: Use arm spines instead of normal unarmed attacks. Lose normal unarmed strike feature. 5th level: Defensive insight: Gain +1 insight bonus to AC for each point of essentia invested. Gain one point of essentia. Lose normal class bonus to AC. 10th level: Gain ability to shape a single soulmeld and chakra bind [arms]. Lose ki strike [lawful]. Soulwarp strike(CM): Make living creature nauseated (sickened if it makes the save) for one round, usable number of times per day equal to class level. Lose 1st level bonus feat. Spell reflection (CM): Gain ability to reflect missed spells targeted at you. Lose evasion. Standing jump (DS): Reduce fast movement ability to improve jumping ability. Wall walker (DS): Gain the ability to run up and down walls. Lose slow fall. Variant fighting styles (UA): Exchange the normal monk bonus feats for select styles of learning. |
| #3ZenzeiJan 14, 2008 0:23:58 | What is there for monk to do? Unarmed strike and how to improve it is the first question every aspiring monk needs to address. The two things you want to do here is to increase your attack bonus and base damage. Besides having a high ability score, the best ways to increase your attack bonus are spells (GMW!) and some choice piece of equipment. Feats like weapon focus are not worth the cost without an access to weapon mastery. Unarmed damage can be improved by increasing your effective monk level or size. Whatever your build might be, always make sure to have lvl 20 unarmed base damage because it is fairly easy to get. The best ways of increasing effective level are monk's belt (item, DMG, +5 lvls) and superior unarmed strike (feat, ToB, +4 lvls). Should you take both of these you have nine levels, which is plenty, to play with classes/prcs that don't advance monk abilities. Now that our base damage is 2d10 we can start to apply size increases and the massive damage bonuses that come with them. After effective lvl 20 monk damage progresses as follows (assuming medium character): As you can see, being effectively large increases your average damage by 63%, make it huge for 145%! Effective huge size is the baseline of optimized monks for it's very easy to achieve. Just for kicks compare 6d8 (27 average) to greatsword 2d6 (7 average), that difference calls for some serious power attacking. Here are the tools for monk damage extraordinaire:
Stunning fist is one the monk's 1st level feat choices along with improved grapple but in reality you should always take SF because it's good and your next chance to take it doesn't come before level 12, on the other hand, improved grapple can be taken any time. The fortitude save DC against stunning is 10 + ½ character level + wis modifier and in order to make this work I recommend taking feat ability focus [stunning fist] and buying ki straps (MIC). These two combined increase the DC by four, which is a very significant boost. Complete warrior and some later books have provided feats to augment SF and I want discuss two of them here, you can read my judgment on the others in the feats section. First is pain touch (CW), which nauseates everyone who fails the fort save against stunning attack for the round after the stun condition ends. This practically doubles the time you and your party can take free shots at the disabled enemy. I highly recommend this feat, it's almost mandatory. The other notable feat is pharaoh's fist (SS), which allows your SF to affect all creatures adjacent to the primary target. Nice crowd control option for a monk. It's bit unclear to me if these two feats can be combined for seriously awesome total effect, clarification would be appreciated. NOTE: One often forgotten thing about stunned condition is stunned creatures drop everything they are holding. This is worth remembering when you want to disarm someone or are being outgrappled. Tripping is something monks can be pretty good at. They can get improved trip as a bonus feat at 6th level and should always take it instead of improved disarm. Besides the feat, having a good strength score and being as large size as possible are keys to successful trip attempt. Fortunately we have these things covered since they are already required for being good at unarmed combat. Whenever you manage to trip someone use stunning fist with the follow through attack in order to make sure the enemy stays prone for the duration of your next turn. This way you maximize your attack bonus and can easily flurry bash him to death. Sometimes you will fail your trip attempt and will get tripped instead, for those times skill trick "back on your feet" is golden. Disarming in traditional sense is not for monks even if they can take improved disarm as a bonus feat at level 6. Disarming is an opposed attack roll, which you will most likely lose because of your medium BAB and the fact you're unarmed (-4 penalty) plus the enemy is very likely wielding weapon two-handed (+4 bonus). It's glaringly obvious the odds are heavily stacked against monk. This is not say monk can't disarm someone, they just use disarm++ that is stunning fist. Grappling is another viable option for monk. Improved grapple is available as bonus feat at first level but don't take it. Instead use the regular first level feat slot for improved grapple. Normal monks are decent grapplers but should consider grapple tactics only when they have clear advantage. For example, target is of smaller size or target is a spell caster. Psionic monks, however, make excellent grapplers and should always include this tactic in their repertoire. Powers like expansion and crushing grip give you bear hug from which there's no escape. When you have the enemy nicely staying still commence the beating with unarmed strikes or drag him around for AoOs from other party members, this is amusing tactic I saw in recent thread and monks excel at it due to high speed. Pounce is one the most sought after ablities among melee classes and monk is no exception. The ability to execute flurry of blows after charge is just good, especially when it also mitigates hitting difficulties. Add in skill trick "twisted charge" for extra maneuverability. Here's how to get this great ability:
If you do get pounce somehow, it's time look at feats battle jump (UE) and leap of the heavens (PHB2). Battle jump let's you execute a charge action, that deals 2x damage by the way, if you can drop on the enemy from at least 5ft above. Leap of the heavens allows standing jumps without penalty. The plan is to jump into air, 10ft and 15ft required for medium and large creatures respectively, and then drop on the enemy executing charge with pounce. Battle jump also allows trip and grapple attempts with a nice bonus to the check.10ft high jump is DC 40 and 15ft high jump is DC 60, luckily monks are very good at jumping 23 [ranks] + 24 [speed] +10 [item] + 2 [synergy] + 7 [strength] = 66. This is kind of weird strategy but very powerful. Even if you don't go the battle jump route pounce is good, very good. Spring attack, about this one I have mixed feelings. The feat itself is good but it's requirements put serious strain on your total feats (monks are feat hungry) and to make things worse dodge & mobility themselves are worthless pile of crap. It is possible to get the whole chain through cobra strike variant (UA) but then getting improved trip is almost impossible and even stunning fist has to wait until level 12. In short, if you want have to versatility in combat before late game, don't take spring attack. If you do take spring attack chain, being a halfling is highly recommended because of the substitution levels available to them (skirmish ahoy!) and follow up with feats like elusive target and bounding assault for maximum effect. Vow of poverty is fairly popular in monk builds. This feat from Book of Exalted Deeds seems extremely powerful at first viewing and lures many monks who are unaware of its limitations to their doom. Vop provides a bunch of bonuses (AC, stats, resistances, saves, etc..) in exchance for all of character's wealth, both current and future. Vop, however, doesn't give any ability to fly, which is a HUGE disadvantage in higher level play. Monk capable of spell casting, such as sacred fist, can overcome the flight issue easily but even they can't help the fact that in high levels (15+) normal characters are so rich they can buy everything vop offers in items and more. Thus, the vop character will experience an inflation. Vop isn't all bad, though. At low- to mid-level play, when characters are relatively poor, vow of poverty offers solid bonuses that combine well with monk's class features. This may even cause some players to view your vop powered monk overpowered. Recap:
Examples of vow of poverty monk can be found in builds section. |
| #4ZenzeiJan 14, 2008 0:24:35 | Skills & tricks The monk’s class skills are balance (dex), climb (str), concentration (con), craft (int), diplomacy (cha), escape artist (dex), hide (dex), jump (str), knowledge [arcana] (int), knowledge [religion] (int), listen (wis), move silently (dex), perform (cha), profession (wis), sense motive (wis), spot (wis), swim (str), and tumble (dex). Always keep listen/spot maxed! They are by far the most used skills and monk's senses are second only to druid. High tumble has plenty of use, most notably it keeps you safe from AoOs. Hide/move silently are obviously good places to put ranks in if you want to be stealthy. I'd also put five ranks in balance and climb each. Jump sees plenty of use and some ranks here wouldn't hurt either, the more, the merrier because monks have potential for mega jumps. Complete scoundrel introduced skill tricks, a few of which are useful for monk.
Feats Take care when selecting your feats as they make huge difference in monk's performance. Plan ahead, preferably all the way through. I won't list the "ascetic x" line of monk multiclassing feats since they are all about adding a bit of monk to other classes and not the other way around. Core
Completes
PHB2 & ToB
Random books
|
| #5ZenzeiJan 14, 2008 0:25:05 | Equipment & spells/powers |
| #6ZenzeiJan 14, 2008 0:25:48 | Prestige classes & builds Atavist (RoE) Enlightened fist (CA) Disciple of the eye (RotD) Disciple of the word (ToM) Dragon descentant (DM) Drunken master (CW) Fist of the forest (CC) Fist of zuoken (XPH) Initiate of draconic mysteries (Drac) Kensai (CW) Monk of the long death (PGtF) Sacred fist (CD) Shadow sun ninja (ToB) Shou disciple (UE) Tattooed monk (CW) Telflammar shadowlord (UE) Warmind (XPH) Zerth cenobite (CP) |
| #7CantripNJan 14, 2008 2:39:17 | Disciple of the Word is a decent 1/4/7 level dip for a monk. |
| #8phoenixinfernoJan 14, 2008 2:40:37 | Don't forget to talk about the Fighting Styles (or whatever they're called) in Oriental Adventures and Tome of Magic. |
| #9jaronkJan 14, 2008 3:44:45 | Can't forget to talk about Fist of the Forest. JaronK |
| #10phaxiJan 14, 2008 6:07:05 | As for prcs there's also the Initiate of Draconic Mysteries, Enlightened Fist and Fist of Zouken. |
| #11haronJan 14, 2008 6:35:37 | Enlightened fist = suckage Enlightened fist + Wraithstrike = pwnage Also even if you don't loose Wraithstrike, but fractional BaB it might not be so bad... ok, it still sux. |
| #12jameswilliamogleJan 14, 2008 7:18:10 | There should be a section for Pouncing; I find it invaluable on any flurry-based monk. In a similar vein, Teflammer Shadowlord. There should be a section on boosting the DCs of Stunning Fist, and some mention of the Deathblow feat (or whatever: coup-de-grace as a standard action). Likewise, a section on grappling would be useful. One thing that seems to be missing from similar handbooks is common buff spells. Monks need one in particular: Greater Mighty Wollop. I look forward to this fleshing out! |
| #13tshernJan 14, 2008 8:54:24 | What does CV stand for? Champions of Valor? In addition to the shadowpouncing Monk, checking out the Jaunter might be worthwhile in a build like that. Edit: Initiate of Draconic Mysteries (sp?) is worth nothing too. |
| #14orenmirJan 14, 2008 10:03:25 | Likewise, a section on grappling would be useful. Seconded. A Monk makes an OK grappler. A Monk 1 or 2 / Psychic Warrior X with Tashalatora makes an excellent grappler. Even though this build is mostly PsyWar, Tashalatora turns the flavor into a Monk that manifests (IMO). |
| #15snizorJan 14, 2008 13:53:03 | The Scorpion Kama (MIC, the Item Sets section) should be in the equipment section when you get it posted. It's a +1 Kama that deals your Unarmed Strike damage. |
| #16CantripNJan 14, 2008 13:59:12 | Here's a build I made not long ago that's as "Monky" as I go: Utterance of the Setting Sun: Lawful Good Human Monk 2/Swordsage 3/Shadow Sun Ninja 8/Disciple of the Word 7 Progression: Unarmed Swordsage 1/Monk 2/Unarmed Swordsage +2/Shadow Sun Ninja 2/Disciple of the Word 4/Sun +3/Word +2/Sun +1/Word +1/Sun +2 BAB: +14 Saves: Fort +15/Ref +17/Will +17 Feats: Human - Dodge 1st - Shadow Blade Swordsage 1 - Weapon Focus (Setting Sun) Monk 1 - Stunning Fist, Imp. Unarmed Strike Monk 2 - Combat Reflexes 3rd - Combat Expertise 6th - Mobility 9th - Spring Attack (Word Given Form - ToM 218) 12th - Sun School 15th - Adaptive Style 18th - Robilar's Gambit Other Feats Wanted (grab them with Flaws if you can): Elusive Target Snap Kick Without Monk's Belt: Unarmed Damage as Monk 20 (2d10) AC Bonus as Monk 17 (+3) Flurry of Blows as Monk 17 Unarmored Speed Bonus as Monk 17 (+50') Stunning Fist 17/day Maneuvers (6 Ready): 1st - Burning Blade, Stone Bones, Mighty Throw, Counter Charge, Wolf Fang Strike, Sudden Leap. 2nd - Cloak of Deception, Shadow Jaunt 3rd - Feigned Opening 5th - Shadow Stride 7th - Hydra Slaying Strike Stances: 1st - Island of Blades, Flame's Blessing 5th - Shifting Defense |
| #17jameswilliamogleJan 14, 2008 14:16:58 | Here's mine. It doesn't have any size alterations, yet. Pouncing Raging Monk of Doom LN Human Druidic Avenger 1 (1), Monk (Cobra Strike Variant) 7 (2-5, 11-13), Shou Disciple 5 (6-10), Shiba Protector 1 (14), Blade Dancer 6 (15-20) optional feat progressions: 1 Two Weapon Fighting, Snow Tiger Berserker 2 Dodge, Imp Unarmed Strike 3 Mobility, Weapon Focus Unarmed Strike 6 Iron Will 7 Combat Expertise 9 Power Attack, Leap Attack 12 Spring Attack, Alertness 15 Neraph Charge or Battle Jump 17 Blindfight 18 Imp. Trip abilities 1 Fast Movement +10', Rage 1/day, Druid Spells 1st lev, Wild Emp -4 2 Flurry 3 Evasion, Fast Movement +10' 4 Still Mind 5 Ki Strike (Magic), Slow Fall 20' 8 Martial Strike (Light) 10 Martial Strike (Any) 11 Purity of Body 12 Fast Move +10' 13 Wholeness of Body 14 No Thought 15 Acrobatics, Leap of the Clouds, Double base movement (+30', or a flat 60'x2=120') 16 Enchanted Blade I 18 Ride the Wind, fast movement (+10', or a flat 60'x2.33=140) 19 Acrobatics (+20), acrobatic attack 20 Enchanted Blade II I'm assuming in this build that Monk / Prc's that progress together advance 100% with respect to unarmed and flurry progression on the Monk table (this is suggested it in UE p33). I'm also assuming that the flurry ability and greater flurry progress. End result: A monk that can charge up to double his move (either 90' or 120', depending on how you rule the bladedancer ability) and full flurry with any weapon, adding his Wis to attack and damage. If you can jump from 5' above (using tumble check of 50, this is doable if 2 objects are w/in 10' of each other, i.e. your target and the wall or an ally) you can double damage, and from 10' across, double power attack damage. Plus, a ton of crazy abilities, including lev 1 Druid spells, insane jump and tumble, and rage 1/day. bab +16, unarmed strike bab +10, 12th level monk unarmed abilities... BUT since you can flurry w/ melee weapons, I think you can count your full BAB of +16, for 16/16/16/11/6/1 when using a weapon. Jump, tumble, and balance: 43, pre-ability adjustments (now your 5' step can be a 10' step, for free, and you don't provoke due to movement, move at full speed, move through enemies). Please let me know if something here isn't kosher; I've been trying to get a charging monk build for a while that doesn't lose too much monk damage, and doesn't have to take a barbarian level that is useless later. I know Shiba Protector is cheesy, but here you lose 2 feats for the ability, so it's pretty balanced in this build, I think; regardless, it's easy to remove in favor of another level of blade dancer. |
| #18cyrocloudJan 14, 2008 14:18:03 | Looks good just two things why is perfect self red, It didn't seem very good or bad to me (the free martial weap pro is nice if a bit late). Also Diamond Soul kinda sucks because most healing and buffs are affected by SR and it is a standard action to lower or activate. This can be quite a problem if your hurt or unbuffed and the have to waste a turn to turn off your SR. Besides that it looks pretty good. |
| #19paradox-of-lifeJan 14, 2008 15:03:58 | Looks good just two things why is perfect self red, It didn't seem very good or bad to me (the free martial weap pro is nice if a bit late). Also Diamond Soul kinda sucks because most healing and buffs are affected by SR and it is a standard action to lower or activate. This can be quite a problem if your hurt or unbuffed and the have to waste a turn to turn off your SR. Besides that it looks pretty good. Perfect self should be red because of the level you attain it it (i.e. lvl 20 monk). Straight monk is just bad. By the time you get to this feature, it wont be worth it because the opportunity cost is too high. Diamond Soul is good due to the fact that it resists save-or-(lose,suck,die,barrel roll) spells. Sure, you can't heal until after a standard action, but healing should be done out of combat and as a monk, you should excel at not getting hit. |
| #20cyrocloudJan 14, 2008 15:09:20 | Yeah your right about the perfect self, but isn't diamond soul the reason why very few monk builds (I can't think of any besides VoP ones) on CO never go past 12. |
| #21jameswilliamogleJan 14, 2008 15:16:06 | You should mention Leap Attack under the pouncing section, too. |
| #22syrazemylaJan 14, 2008 15:16:18 | Incarnum can really help out a monk. The sphinx claws soulmeld, when bound to the hands chakra, grants pounce. And the totem avatar soulmeld bound to the shoulders chakra increases the size of a monk's unarmed strikes. If the monk is psionic or a cleric, he doesn't even need the Open X Chakra feats, due to the Open X Chakra spells and powers. |
| #23cyrocloudJan 14, 2008 15:24:31 | Argent Fist and warshaper(for changeling monks) probably deserve to be listed in the prestige class area a decent build that combines them both would be changeling monk 4/ paladin 4/ warshaper 2/ argent fist 10. |
| #24ZenzeiJan 14, 2008 15:25:37 | Thanks for all the suggestions so far, I'll address as many as I can, I'll also add the builds posted to the builds section. Everyone else feel free to post more builds. The two requirements are: build is legal and it has at least 10 levels in monk base class and/or in monk prcs. @Cyrocloud: Perfect self isn't bad but it's rather useless at those levels (that's why it is red). Every enemy either punches through DR/magic or ignores it entirely with some other kind of attack. Outsider status allows for some polymorph trickery but I don't advocate that particular line of spells. SR has its drawbacks but I feel the protection it provides is worth the cost, therefore blue text. Your point about it is valid, though, I'll mention it in the text. |
| #25syrazemylaJan 14, 2008 15:32:54 | Also, skarn makes a good monk race because of spinemeld warrior. Warmind is an excellent prestige class for a psionic monk, but you'll either have to be a kalashtar or have the Education feat to get in in a timely manner. And we need a ruling about whether a class that advances flurry would advance decisive strike. |
| #26CantripNJan 14, 2008 15:33:47 | There's the Reactive Resistance (?) feat in Drow of the Underdark that lets you lower SR as an Immediate Action. If I ever get a decent SR, I'd be sure to take it. We also need a ruling on whether you can use Decisive Strike as Flurry for requirements, like for Sun School (which would need some tweaking to work with it perfectly, anyway). |
| #27carnivoreJan 14, 2008 15:44:15 | nice guide.... good to see monks Updated here is some stuff from a Psionic Perspective Monks and Psionics: Although there is a Natural affinity for each other.....the way they are combined can greatly effect the overall performance of the character. In general one starts with at least 1 level of Monk to start(many times more levels), and then adds Psionic Classes or PrCs to it. Which Classes or PrCs is very important. For the sake of discussion we will always assume 10 levels of Psionic classes(as many Psionic PrCs are that long and we can also compare them to 10 levels of Base Classes). Monks also have a tendency to MAD(Multiple Attribute Dependancy)..but for the most part are Wisdom Based,so.... Since Monk is Wisdom Based it is normal to look first at :NOTE assume main attribute = 16: Wisdom Based Psionic Classes: Psychic Warrior 10..................... 27 PP / 10 powers known (PW list) 4th lvl Ardent 10................................. 88 PP / 11 powers Known/ 5 mantles (6th lvl with Practiced Manifester) Divine Mind 10........................... 14 PP / 4 powers known...2 mantles 2nd lvl Fist of Zuoken(Psionic Fist) 10...... 71 PP / 10 powers known (PW list) 5th lvl Warmind 10 .............................. 70 PP / 6 powers known (PW list) 5th lvl Zerth Cenobite 10 ..................... 27 PP / 5 powers known (PW List) 4th lvl Intelligence Based Classes: Psion 10 .................................. 88 PP / 21 Powers Known 5th lvl Erudite 10 ................................ 88 PP / 6 unique(23 Powers Known) 5th lvl Lurk 10 .................................... 27 PP / 10 powers known (Lurk List) 4th lvl Charisma Based Classes: Wilder 10 ................................. 88 PP / 6 powers Known 5th lvl Prestige Classes that advance Previous Classes: Cerebremancer Elocator Slayer Thrallherd Psychic Weapon Master Cognition Thief Constructor Feats of Note: feats from Core/XPH: [indent] IMPROVED NATURAL ATTACK [GENERAL] Prerequisite: Natural weapon, base attack bonus +4. Benefit: Choose one of the creature’s natural attack forms. The damage for this natural weapon increases by one step, as if the creature’s size had increased by one category: 1d2, 1d3, 1d4, 1d6, 1d8, 2d6, 3d6, 4d6, 6d6, 8d6, 12d6. A weapon or attack that deals 1d10 points of damage increases as follows: 1d10, 2d8, 3d8, 4d8, 6d8, 8d8, 12d8. Special: A creature can gain this feat multiple times. Each time it applies to a different natural attack. [/indent] Feats from Secrets of Sarlona: [indent] Ascetic Psion...............req:Narrow Mind....allows you to freely multiclass with Psion and Monk, also use Int to AC instead of Wis, and lets you re-Focus as a Standard action, as well as progresses unarmed Damage Tashalatora..............req:Monastic Training(psionic class)(ECS)....progresses AC, Unarmed Damage, Flurry of Blows [/indent] feats from Champions of Valor: [indent] Carmondine Monk.........req:Int 13, member of special organization(which allows you to freely multiclass with Cleric and Monk) gives: Int to AC and the DC for Stunning fist and Quivering Palm are based on Int instead of Wis, also +2 monk lvls for one of the following(each day you pick one): [indent]1)Unarmed Damage 2)Speed 3)AC[/indent] Silver Fang................Base fort save +4, member or ally of special organization Natural Weapon or Unarmed Strike considered Silver vs DR Sun Soul Monk............ Monk 6, member of special order patron= Selune= +1 point cold damage with unarmed strike and considered Silver vs DR, also +3 monk lvl for Speed bonus [/indent] Feats from Tome of Battle [indent] Superior Unarmed Strike.........+5 monk lvls for Unarmed Damage [/indent] Feats from Eberron Campaign setting book: [indent] Double Steel Strike...Req: Exotic Weapon Prof(2 bladed Sword), Weapon Focus(2 Bladed Sword), Flurry Allows you to treat 2 Bladed Sword as Special Monk Weapon and can Flurry with it Whirling Steel Strike...Req: Martial Weapon Prof(Long Sword), Weapon Focus(Long Sword), Flurry Allows you to treat Long Sword as Special Monk Weapon and can Flurry with it Serpent Strike...Req: Simple Weapon Prof(Long Spear), Weapon Focus(Long Spear), Flurry Allows you to treat Long Spear as Special Monk Weapon and can Flurry with it Flensing Strike ....... Req: Exotic Weapon(Kama), Weapon Focus(Kama) as a Full round action,..1 attack..if hits do normal damage and enemy must save(Fort DC 10+1/2 Character lvl+Wis mod(+2 if using Kama)) or -4 penalty to Attacks, Saves, Checks for 1 min Powerful Charge ....... Medium or Larger, BAB+1 when charging....do extra damage....+1d8 Med,+2d6 Large, +3d6 Huge, +4d6 Gargantuan, +6d6 Colossal Greater Powerful Charge ......Powerful Charge, BAB+4 considered +1 size larger [/indent] Feats from Dracominicon [indent]Endure Blows ..... Req: Con 19, Dragon Type, Toughness gives DR 2/- stacks with existing Rapid Strike .......req: Dex 9, pair of Natural weapons, Type=Aberation,Dragon,Magical Beats,Plant,BAB+10 gain 1 extra attack with natural weapon @ -5 Imp Rapid Strike .......req: Dex 9, pair of Natural weapons, Type=Aberation,Dragon,Magical Beats,Plant,BAB+15,Rapidstrike gain 1 extra attack with natural weapon @ -10 Sense Weakness ......req:Int 13, Combat Expertise, Weapon focus(type of weapon) Ignore 5 points of DR or Hardness [/indent] Feats from Complete Warrior: [indent] Flying Kick ........ req: Str 13, Jump 4 ranks, Imp Unarmed Strike, Power Attack +1d12 damage on charge(with unarmed strike) Improved Toughness ...... req: +2 Base Fort save +1 hp/ HD Combat Brute(tactical feat) Elusive Target(tactical feat) Giant Bane(tactical feat) Raptor School(tactical feat) Shock Trooper(tactical feat) Sun School(tactical feat) ....req: Flurry, BAB+4 1)Hit foe with first 2 unarmed attacks in Flurry..and move foe 5'(you can also move 5') 2)stun foe 2 rounds in row....they are Confused 1d4 rounds also 3)Make attack after instantaneous move(Dimension Door,Teleport,etc)[/indent] Other feats: [indent] KNOCK-DOWN [GENERAL] Prerequisites: Base attack bonus +2, Improved Trip, Str 15. Benefit: Whenever you deal 10 or more points of damage to your opponent in melee, you make a trip attack as a free action against the same target. HOLD THE LINE [GENERAL] Prerequisites: Combat Reflexes, base attack bonus +2. Benefit: You may make an attack of opportunity against a charging opponent who enters an area you threaten. Your attack of opportunity happens immediately before the charge attack is resolved. Normal: You only get an attack of opportunity against a character that exits a square you threaten. FLEET OF FOOT [GENERAL] Prerequisites: Dex 15, Run. Benefit: When running or charging, you can make a single direction change of 90 degrees or less. You can’t use this feat while wearing medium or heavy armor, or when carrying a medium or heavy load. If you are charging, you must move in a straight line for 10 feet after the turn to maintain the charge. Normal: Without this feat, you can run or charge only in a straight line.[/indent] Feats from Races of Stone: [indent]Earth Sense .........req: Con 13,Wis 13 while you touch the ground....you can sense # creatures in 20' rad also touching ground Earth Fist(racial) .......... Req: Dwarf, Gnome, Goliath, Earth sense, Imp Unarmed Strike while you touch ground...Unarmed Strike = Cold Iron vs DR Feats from Mini Handbook: [indent] Double Hit Deft Opportunist [/indent] [/indent] Build Combos: Core+XPH: Monk 11/ Warmind 9 [indent] BAB +17 9th lvl Manifester 4th lvl powers(5 powers known) 58 Power points benifits: Greater Flurry...can be combined with 2 weapon fighting to get even more and with Sweeping strike, to further boost effectiveness[/indent] Monk 11/ Psion 1/ Slayer 8 [indent] BAB +16 8th lvl Manifester 4th lvl Powers(17 powers known) 58 Power points benifits: Greater Flurry drawbacks: requires more feats [/indent] |
| #28CantripNJan 14, 2008 15:50:11 | ![]() Use SBLOCKS, man! |
| #29orenmirJan 14, 2008 16:09:10 | KNOCK-DOWN [GENERAL] What book is this from? |
| #30nanshorkJan 14, 2008 16:22:03 | Hmm, are you counting Argent Fist as a monk PrC? If so, I've got a build to contribute. |
| #31syrazemylaJan 14, 2008 16:22:03 | I think it was originally in Deities and Demigods. But it's been moved to the "Divine" section of the SRD. |
| #32enamel_32Jan 14, 2008 17:23:24 | For the kalashtar monk, the atavist (races of eberron) might be work looking at. |
| #33friendlyfrogJan 14, 2008 18:02:45 | Hmm, if Decisive strike can progressed as if it were Flurry of blows, it could very well be worth it for Monk/War minds with Tashalatora and Snap kick. that'd be three attacks at full BAB -2 all applying against two adjacent opponents, each hit dealing double damage. Though it's Robilar's gambit that makes this fun, as all your attacks of opportunity are against two opponents and deal double damage. |
| #34snizorJan 14, 2008 20:58:59 | Ectoplasmic Fist (ECS 264) also gives an effective size increase for US damage for Kalashtar monks. |
| #35Ed-ZeroJan 15, 2008 0:50:36 | Just wanted to mention that I think you left out the variations and alternate class features from Unearthed Arcana (www.d20srd.org). Also, for anyone that cares, the expanded unarmed damage table looks a little something like this: 4d8>6d8>8d8>12d8>16d8>24d8>32d8>48d8>64d8>96d8>128d8>192d8>256d8>384d8>512d8 |
| #36phoenixinfernoJan 15, 2008 2:22:54 | I must protest the labeling of Combat Defense as "bad". It lets you switch your Dodge-buddy, which, when paired with Elusive Target (a "good" feat), lets you employ Elusive Target's abilities multiple times in a round. |
| #37bukowskiJan 15, 2008 8:58:16 | You may want to mention goliath as a viable race for grappler monk builds. Powerful build never hurts when grappling. Also, you may want to at least mention the aligned attack and ghost attack feats for psionic monks. Feats that only have BAB prereqs and let you overcome alignment DR or give your attacks the ghost touch ability, respectively, are not terrible choices for a monk. Ghost Attack, in particular, doesn't even require psionic focus expenditure. |
| #38jameswilliamogleJan 15, 2008 9:34:56 | You may want to mention goliath as a viable race for grappler monk builds. Powerful build never hurts when grappling. Along the same vein, Jotenbrud does the same thing for humans. Also, still no mention of Leap Attack, which is invaluable for pouncing shocktrooper styled monks. Catfolk is a viable monk race due to Catfolk Pounce, which is another method of gaining Pounce for unarmed strikes. The +4 Dex bonus also makes ToB enabled Monks slightly more powerful with the Shadowblade feat. There should be a mention of drop points and the Ascetic chain of feats. Overall, it seems to be shaping up nicely: nice formatting, pretty colors. Good jorb! |
| #39chrisfontenot13Jan 15, 2008 12:03:34 | I know you folks probably have your reasons for discounting the Arcane Monk concept, but I felt like I had to put in my 2 cents (so much so that this is only my second post and my first in about a year so if I muss up some rules of etiquette or if this is a little messy please forgive me). As far as I can see, there are a few ways to make it at least somewhat effective, relying on the Enlightened Fist class. 1) Shift the main att from Wis to Int via Carmendine Monk -or- 1) Shift the main att from Wis to Cha via Ascetic Mage Yeah, you lose BAB, but Arcane Strike boosts your power level nicely and makes up for it. If you go the Sorceror road and use RAW (unless errata states otherwise) you can stack Arcane Strike with Ascetic Mage's benefit spend 2 spell slots for +total spell levels to hit & ( + first sp lv in d4's & + second sp lv direct to damage). As long as you can still make it to +11/+6/+1 you get 3 attacks + Flurry; add on Snap kick for one more. Also, you can add "Mighty Wallop" to crank up the effective size level... Jeez, what a crap name for a spell, eh? Add on VoP and any slots you'd normally spend on spells with expensive materials become downright nasty. This would probably work best with an Illumian, such as Uurnaen, Vauluurr, or Vaulaesh. After the obligatory monk & (wiz or sorceror) levels, there's always the few levels of Swordsage or Warblade to jump into the Jade Phoenix Mage or starting with a Raging Monk to work into Rage Mage, normally not so great but this makes it at least funny, if not effective; whichever you want but Abjurant Champion (possible because monks have Handaxe proficiency) I think to be the best of the options to crank up the BAB and Caster Level simultaneously. I mean, that is about all I can think of... except, of course, for "Giant Size," a 7th Level Wu Jen Spell, which can boost your size up to Huge (15 CL) -> Gargantuan (17 CL) -> Colossal (19+ CL), not too bad with Practiced Spellcaster. (Also hilarious in a Spellsword's hands). This looks best with a build of Illumian Vauluurr - Wu Jen 3 / Monk 2 / Enlightened fist 10 Abjurant Champion 5 (rounding out CL @ 20 with Practiced Spellcaster). Throw on Imp. Natural Attack, Superior Unarmed Strike, a scroll of Mighty Wallop with a monks belt: and ditch two 8th level spells to crank up the d4's and you're looking at a 5-gallon bucket full of dice and a pallet full of pluses to hit and damage. So, I lose a few points of BAB, and I all have to show for it is: 1) a +32 strength mod, 2) Arcane Strike, 3) a 30 ft natural reach for AoO goodness, (and Decisive Strike for double damage) 4) and Colossal++ Unarmed Damage I'm sure I'm mucking up these calculations, but it should come out to something like 32d8 (Unarmed) + 8d6 (Vauluur) + 8d4 (Arcane Strike) |
| #40ZenzeiJan 15, 2008 17:55:18 | Thanks for replies everyone, keep 'em coming. I'm bit busy with school at the moment but I will try to get this guide done by the end of the this week.Hmm, are you counting Argent Fist as a monk PrC? If so, I've got a build to contribute. As long as it's clearly a monk build and not unarmed paladin, go ahead. I'll add it to the builds section when I get there. The question "Can decisive strike be progressed with prcs that progress flurry?" has been brought up. Unless some very convincing rules quotes are presented, my answer is no. The issue is pretty similar to the abjurant champion & mage armor thing but even errata didn't change it. Ectoplasmic Fist (ECS 264) also gives an effective size increase for US damage for Kalashtar monks. I'll check this out. Just wanted to mention that I think you left out the variations and alternate class features from Unearthed Arcana (www.d20srd.org). They are mentioned at the very bottom of the sblock. I'll add link to SRD, easy enough to check the details from there. I must protest the labeling of Combat Defense as "bad". It lets you switch your Dodge-buddy, which, when paired with Elusive Target (a "good" feat), lets you employ Elusive Target's abilities multiple times in a round. Elusive target is good but it isn't so good it justifies taking three more feats (always take at least three combat form feats or don't take them at all) to enhance its effects. On its own, combat defense is just a bad feat, period. You may want to mention goliath as a viable race for grappler monk builds. Powerful build never hurts when grappling. I think you're right, goliath deserves to be mentioned. Aligned attack is bad because it comes with strings attached. First, it is very slow to use because you need to regain psionic focus over and over again, which eats precious actions during combat. Second, you practically need the feat psionic meditation too for the move action refocusing. Third, the only aligned damage reduction with real importance is DR/good and the holy strike variant class feature is superior way of getting good aligned attack. Ghost attack isn't bad, I'll add it to the feats section. Along the same vein, Jotenbrud does the same thing for humans. Will be added. Also, still no mention of Leap Attack, which is invaluable for pouncing shocktrooper styled monks. I have plans of adding a section about charging, leap attack will be there along with the other usual suspects. Catfolk is a viable monk race due to Catfolk Pounce, which is another method of gaining Pounce for unarmed strikes. The +4 Dex bonus also makes ToB enabled Monks slightly more powerful with the Shadowblade feat. Good find. There should be a mention of drop points This is on my to do list. Ascetic chain of feats Every single one of these encourages only dipping into monk, something that is very low on priority from the viewpoint of this guide. When everything else is done, I may eventually add a section about dipping. Overall, it seems to be shaping up nicely: nice formatting, pretty colors. Good jorb! Thanks ![]() Defends arcane monks valiantly. If you could provide a detailed & well formatted example build and some discussion about tactics etc, I will happily discuss more about this topic. For starters here are my main issues with arcane monks: -Low attack bonus -Dependency on questionable spells like, wraithstrike, greater mighty wallop, polymorph... -Builds tend to be awful mess of random abilities that don't have good synergy with each other. This leads to inelegance, which is not good in my book. -Swiftblade builds perform better |
| #41haplo81Jan 16, 2008 19:04:55 | Quick question: When taking Shou Disciple along with Monk, your first level of the PrC gives you a minimum of 6 effective Shou Disciple levels, but the unarmed damage progression only goes up to 2d6. How do you handle further progression from Monk levels? |
| #42milisavJan 16, 2008 20:44:07 | Intuitive strike (BoED): Wis modifier to attack instead of str, way better than weapon finesse. This is an exalted feat, which may cause complications during gameplay. Intuitive Strike is reprinted in Complete Adventurer as non-exalted feat. |
| #43snizorJan 16, 2008 21:33:31 | Intuitive Strike is reprinted in Complete Adventurer as non-exalted feat. You Sure? I'm not seeing it in the CAdv Table of Contents. |
| #44milisavJan 16, 2008 21:54:49 | You Sure? I'm not seeing it in the CAdv Table of Contents. You're right it's not in CAdv. I could've sworn I saw non-exalted version somewhere. |
| #45true_shinkenJan 16, 2008 22:17:13 | Very good work! Keep it up! |
| #46snizorJan 18, 2008 14:43:51 | Here are a few Psionic Monk builds. The Quiet Mind Name: The Quiet Mind Race: Kalashtar Build: Monk 6/ Fist of Zuokon 10/ Warmind 4 Feats: 1. Improved Grapple , (Stunning Fist) 2. (Monastic Training: Fist of Zuokon) 3. Wild Talent 6. Superior Unarmed Strike, (Improved Trip) 9. Tashlatora 11. (Ghost Attack) 12. Improved Natural Attack: Unarmed Strike 15. Pain Touch 16. (Expanded Knowledge: Metamorphisis) 18. Snap Kick Powers Known (By FoZ Lvl): 1. Expansion 2. Grip of Iron 3. Psionic Lion’s Charge 4. Strength of My Enemy 5. Dimension Slide 6. Vampire Blade 7. Freedom of Movement, Psionic 8. Tail of the Dragon (SoS) 9. Energy Adaptation 10. free , Metamorphisis Warmind Powers (By Warmind Lvl): 1. Bite of the Wolf 2. Force Screen 4. Hustle Items: 1 Ectoplasmic Shard (ECS) Multiple Power Link Shards (MoE) |
| #47jameswilliamogleJan 18, 2008 15:09:08 | Here's another non-traditional Monk build: Its a Joke! Binder 15 / Knight of the Sacred Seal (Chupoclops) 5 1 TWF, Power Attack 3 Improved Bull Rush 6 Improved Natural Attack (Unarmed Strike) 9 Shocktrooper 12 Leap Attack 15 iTWF 18 gTWF BAB +16, uses Ronove early on, adds Chupoclops later, Zagan after that, and Karsus at 20th. Unarmed Damage is equal to the Monk's, but you get Pounce, an Ethereal Jaunt ability, Improved Grapple, Constrict, and a slew of other abilities. Karsus is to be able to dispel anyone you are grappling from freedom of movement. (ok, just posting this as a joke on the thread, really, but it could monk-it-up pretty well.) |
| #48SenevriJan 18, 2008 16:27:48 | How's something simple like this: Vanilla + ToB monk Wood Elf monk 20: str 16 dex 17 con 12 int 10 wis 14 cha 8. All additions to dex. Monk Bonus feats: Improved Grapple, Combat Reflexes, Improved Trip Feats: 1 TWF 3 Weapon Finesse 6 Improved Natural Attack 9 Martial Study:Shadow Hand (Shadow Garrote) 12 Martial Stance:Shadow Hand (Dance of the Spider) 15 Shadow Blade 18 Snap Kick. Eq: Tome 153K, +6 dex and wis items(72k), amulet +5 (50k), ring +5 bracers +8 BAB 15, +31/+31/+31/+26/+21 up to +27/+27/+27/+27/+27/+22/+17. Damage 4d8(avg 18 )+19 on hit. Per round output ~150->220. AC 43=10+5wis+11dex+4monk+8bracers+5ring. |
| #49SenevriJan 18, 2008 16:28:33 | Intuitive Strike is reprinted in Complete Adventurer as non-exalted feat. Hey, this may be nice for my Superman build! *edit* Not finding it... page? |
| #50carnivoreJan 18, 2008 17:33:38 | a better Monk would be like this: Monk 16/ Crusader 4 Gives BAB +16... thus extra itterative attacks... and Lots of Manuvers with Initiator lvl of 12th(6th lvl Manuvers max) :D |
| #51SenevriJan 18, 2008 17:52:15 | I prefer Warblade or Swordsage meself. Better synergy. A Monk2/Swordsage/Shadow Sun Ninja could be nasty, or even a plain monk/Shadow Sun Ninja. Delivering 5-11 negative levels per round is very much ow. I'd like a CON heavy build there, though. |
| #52carnivoreJan 18, 2008 17:57:17 | I prefer Warblade or Swordsage meself. Better synergy. true... i also prefer Warblade.... Swordsage is nice... but you need to get BAB +16 somehow Human Monk 12/ Swordsage 4/ Warblade 4 ... also Kicks Butt...use Shadow Hand and Diamond Mind :D |
| #53SenevriJan 18, 2008 18:39:12 | true... i also prefer Warblade.... Swordsage is nice... but you need to get BAB +16 somehow You expect to hit something with an attack that has -15 to hit? |
| #54alienfrombeyondJan 18, 2008 19:47:54 | You expect to hit something with an attack that has -15 to hit? Think of it as another chance to roll a 20 ;). Or if you've got a huge attack bonus, it may have a decent chance of hitting anyways. |
| #55tweedledopeJan 18, 2008 22:09:58 | I would have to say that the Drow feat from Races of Eberron that lets you count your Unarmed Strikes as ghost touch is very...very...handy. |
| #56carnivoreJan 19, 2008 12:00:21 | You expect to hit something with an attack that has -15 to hit? as AlienFromBeyond said... but also consider this.... @20th lvl: BAB= +16 so a full attack with Greater Flurry with Haste using say Annis Hag form(from Skin of Proteus)(25 Str wearing +6 Belt of Str) is this(which can easily boosted Higher.... but is ready for EPIC play): +16 BAB +10 Str +1 Haste ........... +27 attack Full Attack: +27/+27/+27/+27/+22/+17/+12 add average d20 roll= +10 = +37/+37/+37/+37/+32/+27/+22 TARRASQUE only has AC 35 Balor also AC 35 Very Old Red Dragon(CR 21) has AC 36 you could put a beating on them :D |
| #57cyrocloudJan 19, 2008 12:50:22 | I see that and my mind goes Pouncing Charge with leap attack and shock trooper. You can even easily eak out another hit on average with Magic Fang, Greater. |
| #58carnivoreJan 21, 2008 5:17:48 | very true... imagine if your local Party member Incantatrix was to Persist Wraithstrike and Greater Magic Weapon on your hands then you could get: Pouncing Charge with leap attack and shock trooper with +42/+42/+42/+42/+37/+32/+27 Touch Attacks :D |
| #59jameswilliamogleJan 21, 2008 7:47:08 | very true... imagine if your local Party member Incantatrix was to Persist Wraithstrike and Greater Magic Weapon on your hands How does one Persist Wraithstrike on a party member? I'm sure there's a method, I just am not aware. With a bunch of enlarging effects going, that could be pretty sick damage, too. In general, I don't find Shocktrooper to be all that necessary when Wraithstrike is added in. One can just Power/Leap Attack for full at that point, and have a very good chance of never missing. |
| #60carnivoreJan 21, 2008 8:04:23 | Incantatrix has a Class ability(3rd lvl) that allows then to apply a metamagic Effect to an existing spell effect(they must make a Spellcraft check) :D |
| #61jameswilliamogleJan 21, 2008 8:06:40 | Incantatrix has a Class ability(3rd lvl) that allows then to apply a metamagic Effect to an existing spell effect(they must make a Spellcraft check) Oh, I know, but how do you get it on a party member? |
| #62carnivoreJan 21, 2008 8:13:20 | the Incantatrix can apply the effect to you after you have cast the spell from a scroll or Potion,etc... :D |
| #63jameswilliamogleJan 21, 2008 8:26:19 | Ah. I see. So, it takes a bit of timing, I guess, and a pretty hefty Spellcraft check, but is doable. |
| #64vitellioFeb 16, 2008 9:01:28 | I have a question, and it seems that this is the right place to ask. RAW, the monk does not have simple weapons proficency, thus they are not proficent with unarmed strikes. I know this is not a Rule as Intended, but by RAW should i take Simple Weapon Proficency(unarmed strike) in order to skip the -4 to hit penalty for using a weapon I'm not proficent with, or is there a faq/errata that addressed this problem that i have not seen?(I've just looked through the ufficial FAQ and the 3.5 phb errata, but they are silent on this.) |
| #65carnivoreFeb 16, 2008 12:16:22 | RAW, the monk does not have simple weapons proficency, thus they are not proficent with unarmed strikes. I know this is not a Rule as Intended, but by RAW should i take Simple Weapon Proficency(unarmed strike) in order to skip the -4 to hit penalty for using a weapon I'm not proficent with, or is there a faq/errata that addressed this problem that i have not seen?(I've just looked through the ufficial FAQ and the 3.5 phb errata, but they are silent on this.) actually to answer this... look at the Class Feature of the Monk Class ... notice: Unarmed Strike: At 1st level, a monk gains Improved Unarmed Strike as a bonus feat. A monk’s attacks may be with either fist interchangeably or even from elbows, knees, and feet. This means that a monk may even make unarmed strikes with her hands full. There is no such thing as an off-hand attack for a monk striking unarmed. A monk may thus apply her full Strength bonus on damage rolls for all her unarmed strikes. :D |
| #66vitellioFeb 17, 2008 8:39:17 | IMPROVED UNARMED STRIKE [GENERAL] Yes, and the feat does not say anywhere that it gives you the proficency^_^ you don't provoke AOO, you can deal lethal damage, but you do not gain the proficency with unarmed strikes^_^ This was my conudrum. |
| #67true_shinkenFeb 17, 2008 8:53:36 | Yes, and the feat does not say anywhere that it gives you the proficency^_^ you don't provoke AOO, you can deal lethal damage, but you do not gain the proficency with unarmed strikes^_^ That's the most ridiculous argument I've ever seen in this boards. And I've seen stupid arguments... |
| #68_inertia_Feb 17, 2008 10:06:04 | It has been ruled that a monk's unarmed strikes qualify as natural weapons: for instance, they can take Improved Natural Attack (unarmed strike). IIRC, creatures are considered automatically proficient with all natural attacks. |
| #69amazing_triangleFeb 17, 2008 17:31:13 | It has been ruled that a monk's unarmed strikes qualify as natural weapons: for instance, they can take Improved Natural Attack (unarmed strike). IIRC, creatures are considered automatically proficient with all natural attacks. Where is this ruling...I am going to bring the argument to my DM and I need the information that says that I can choose that feat for the monk because he is not a monster. |
| #70carnivoreFeb 17, 2008 17:51:59 | Where is this ruling...I am going to bring the argument to my DM and I need the information that says that I can choose that feat for the monk because he is not a monster. look in the PHB ... under Monk... Unarmed Strike: At 1st level, a monk gains Improved Unarmed Strike as a bonus feat. A monk’s attacks may be with either fist interchangeably or even from elbows, knees, and feet. This means that a monk may even make unarmed strikes with her hands full. There is no such thing as an off-hand attack for a monk striking unarmed. A monk may thus apply her full Strength bonus on damage rolls for all her unarmed strikes. also look here:Official D&D Game Rule FAQ Can a monk take Improved Natural Attack (Monster Manual, page 304) to improve his unarmed strike? :D |
| #71amazing_triangleFeb 18, 2008 13:15:44 | Thank you very much! :D |
| #72trackstarFeb 18, 2008 14:56:48 | Anyone have any good ideas or builds for a VoP, psionic monk? Or links to one? |
| #73alastarFeb 18, 2008 15:00:18 | monk 4/psychic warrior 1/warmind 10/ monk +4/Psychic warrior +1 Feats: lvl1: Sacred vow, stunning fist (b) lvl2: deflect arrows(b) lvl3: vow of poverty lvl5: superior unarmed strike (dm allowed to be a figher feat, can be arranged) lvl6: ascetic psion (warmind) lvl9: Improved natural attack lvl12: snap kick lvl15: flying kick lvl17: improved trip lvl18: Improved critical (fist) Lvl20: ability focus (stunning fist) BAB 17 get expansion and psionic lion's charge |
| #74vitellioFeb 19, 2008 7:36:47 | That's the most ridiculous argument I've ever seen in this boards. And I've seen stupid arguments... Yes, I know. It was thrown against me, and i wanted some solid rules to refute it^_^ |
| #75snizorFeb 22, 2008 15:46:10 | An interesting thing I just discovered: The feat Ordered Chaos (FC1, requires base Will save +4) would allow a Monk to theoretically qualify for any PRCs that specifically required a chaotic alignment. COuld open up a few unusual PRC options |
| #76the_shamanFeb 22, 2008 19:46:13 | Anyone have any good ideas or builds for a VoP, psionic monk? Or links to one? I'd say it wouldn't be hard to do one, although I haven't given it much thought. However, the ability to buff yourself and use utility powers makes psionic monks much more suited for VoP than normal ones . Heck, with Tashalatora - the feat from that Eberron book - it's hard not to make a good psionic monk. If you want to keep it simple, monk 2/PW 18 (ideally a mantled PW or with a soulbound weapon - see the expanded psionic classes web article) or Ardent 18 with Tashalatora should work perfectly; I'd prefer the former for the feats, but the latter may win in terms of pure power. Also monk/psionic fist combos with elocator, slayer or sanctified mind improving the PF progression can work as well (the latter are mostly valuable if you don't have access to Tashalatora, however). Monk 6/PF4/Warmind 10 with Tashalatora on the warmind can also work fine. Monk/psion (with kung-fu genius or carmendine monk) builds can also work if you want to emphasize your manifesting; I'd suggest you use an egoist for the extra buff power. |
| #77eldarielFeb 22, 2008 20:04:02 | Have you considered writing a section for Incarnum Monks? Especially VoPped Monks really want Incarnum (or some form of Magic, or very high Initiator Level) to get flight, but normals can get lots of mileage out of all the offensive-enhancing Soulmelds. And it only costs you feats to strive for the abilities; you don't need to invest levels if you're happy with a low essentia-version of whatever you're after. |
| #78tshernFeb 22, 2008 20:07:22 | Have you considered writing a section for Incarnum Monks? Especially VoPped Monks really want Incarnum (or some form of Magic, or very high Initiator Level) to get flight, but normals can get lots of mileage out of all the offensive-enhancing Soulmelds. And it only costs you feats to strive for the abilities; you don't need to invest levels if you're happy with a low essentia-version of whatever you're after. You must be talking about Landshark boots here. Well, it indeed rocks. |
| #79rabidpiratemanFeb 29, 2008 15:13:03 | I'm just putting this out there, but I think Fire Hobgoblins make alright monks- they get bonuses to Dex and Con, which are important, and Int, which means you can dump it without any ramifications. They only get a penalty to Cha, which no one cares about. On top of that, you get resistance to fire. All of this is just for 1 LA. |
| #80SamrinFeb 29, 2008 15:17:12 | Why do you consider Earth's Embrace to be so bad? Seems like a good way to deal out a ton of damage against a pinned opponent. |
| #81deathtrapMar 15, 2008 20:33:08 | Cloud Anchorite (Fr) can be a good Monk PrC in some situations. |
| #82the_shamanMar 16, 2008 1:22:33 | Why do you consider Earth's Embrace to be so bad? Seems like a good way to deal out a ton of damage against a pinned opponent. You said it, pinned opponent. That means you iirc need to win 2 grapple checks, and he can escape either through quite a few means - including just dim-dooring away or escape artist check. |
| #83the_shamanApr 03, 2008 7:23:33 | Bump. Has anyone looked at the Monk of the Enabled Hand from the Dragon Compendium? I liked the idea of having your unarmed attacks count as a large weapon for disarming, and some of the other abilities aren't half bad themselves. |
| #84eldarielApr 03, 2008 7:40:53 | The class is solid with a few handy abilities, but it requires picking up pretty weak feats. Also, Empty Hand makes you static 'Large', so if you're medium Enlarged, it's no good to you and if you have more size-changing abilities, it gets even worse (you could houserule it to just make your hands count as one category larger; that'd make more sense and would be better overall). Reverse Hand is a handy Karmic Strike-addition though, giving you an extra AoO each time you're hit, Mind over Hand makes for a few easy hits per day (always good) and Dragon's Tail Slap actually increases your size by one so it works with other size-increasing stuff. The 'Monk of the Enabled Hand per day'-limitation is annoying as it's a 5-class prestige and thus you're maxed out at 6 uses per day, but Reverse Hand alone would be worth a couple of levels. Too bad it doesn't give any Trip- or Grapple-boosts; I've always found those to be the prime abilities a Monk SHOULD be good at. |
| #85the_shamanApr 03, 2008 9:50:48 | I though Kong Soo implies that your fists count as a large weapon of your size category - you know, halberd, greatsword, that kind of thing. I guess you're right, but I think my idea makes for a nice houserule. Monks were already gimped for disarms, and they were supposed to be good at it... As for grappling or tripping, I tend to consider those the province of full-BABers like Shou disciple, Pious Templar, or Warmind - who also have extra feats or powers to help them get an extra edge... hey, speaking of full BAB, has anyone used Singh Rager for a monks yet? Apart from benefiting from good charisma for the Ki Shout/GKS part, it can be quite handy. Pounce + rage is never bad :D |
| #86augurerApr 05, 2008 22:16:13 | I'm working on building a Monk/Psion and I had a few questions: 1) Do I need Monastic Training to get Tashalatora if I have Ascetic Psion? That just seems redundant. Ascetic Psion doesn't seem worth it for this build on top of Monastic Training. 2) What type of bonus is the Monk's "AC Bonus" special ability? An unnamed bonus? An "AC" bonus? Or "armor" bonus? It doesn't seem like it is the last, which means powers like Inertial Armor should stack with it, correct? 3) With the AC Bonus ability, do negative modifiers on Wisdom apply, or are they simply ignored? |
| #87eldarielApr 06, 2008 6:02:25 | 1) Talashtora specifically requires Monastic Training. The benefit here is that you get all Monk-features as a part of an other class. It's easily worth it. 2) If a type isn't defined, it's untyped. That is the case here. 3) Technically you could make a case for them applying, but really, the ability is called 'bonus' and basically all other bonuses say that negative bonuses don't apply (since y'know, the wording is 'bonus'). So technically, RAW, negative Wis modifier would apply to AC, but rationally not. |
| #88ppaladin123Apr 09, 2008 9:18:23 | EDIT: skarn monks get the ability to bind only one SOULBORN soul meld. Very crappy. |
| #89sinfire_titanApr 09, 2008 9:39:38 | Skarn monks get a substitution level at 10, which gives them 1 soul meld and the ability to bind to the arms chakra. Pick the totemist soul meld sphinx claws and bind it to your arms chakra. Bingo...you have pounce without any annoying "was a barbarian, now a monk" role playing. Also good if your DM hates psionics though in that case he might hate incarnum too. Incarnum has more in common with the love child of a Warblade and an Artificer than with anything from the XPH/CPsi. Also, Incarnum Monk tricks? Skarn Monk 2/Totemist 8/Spinemeld Warrior 10 BaB +18/+13/+8/+3 Feats: Relevant ones with anything but Stunning Fist (trust me, we are going for something here). Improved Multiattack is obviously the winner. Also, SuS. So with your Spines, you have the full TWFing tree for a total of 7 attacks. You can use your legs for Unarmed Strikes, which nets the Monk's Flurry for an extra 2. Then Girallon Arms for another 4. Add in Sphinx Claws for the Pounce ability. Then do the math for you attacks. Max Essentia in the Spines and in your Girallon Arms. Who need the Substitution Levels? Though Fighter 2 can squeeze in an extra point of BaB and even net two bonus feats you may want over the Monk ones. And Heavy Armor. |
| #90ppaladin123Apr 09, 2008 9:49:39 | Incarnum has more in common with the love child of a Warblade and an Artificer than with anything from the XPH/CPsi. Oh yeah I just meant a DM who bans psionics may very well ban any alternate magic/power system. I was going to suggest monk 11/ spine meld warrior 9 for 12 attacks during a flurry of blows pounce but I think you have me beat. :D |
| #91sinfire_titanApr 09, 2008 9:58:57 | Oh yeah I just meant a DM who bans psionics may very well ban any alternate magic/power system. My friend is building the Swordsage/Fighter/Totemist version as a backup character for his Glaivelock. I honestly say that I am scared of this character's potential. |
| #92jetstrike3000Apr 09, 2008 11:37:18 | Races Show Beguiler: Actually a race from the Forgotten Realms - Shining South supplement, this offers a RIDICULOUS TON of awesome abilities, including +6 Dex, +2 Int, small size, a climb speed, a +8 to Hide (on top of the +4 size bonus!), two claws/bite/rake/tail attack, true seeing AT WILL, darkvision, and lowlight vision. They also look like Pikachu. Air Goblin: From Unearthed Arcana, these guys are goblins the way they should have been. Aside from a few air-related traits, the big deal is a +4 Dex instead of +2. The rest is sort of standard goblin. Jermlaine: MMII, I think (or III?). These guys are TINY fey with +6 Wis and +6 Dex. The downside is that you're tiny (finessable reach weapons like Spiked Chains or the Rope Dart from Dragon Mag are a must for melee), ugly as sin, and STOOPID (-4 Int, I think). Venerable Dragonwrought Kobold: These guys kick butt, as everyone knows, with a +3 to mental stats, +2 Dex, and only minor penalties. If you're using the improved web-version of the kobold, they only get better (I especially like the size and claws bits of the upgrade, which you can find here). All three options I just listed are - guess what? - LA +0 races. Shazam. Hengoyaki -badger (OA) (burrow speed 10 ft in animal form and possibly hybrid form) Unbodied (XPH) (incorporeal subtype) (Asherati) (Sand) (Burrow speed in sand, ash, and other loose soils) |
| #93the_shamanApr 09, 2008 11:57:47 | Why do you suggest Karmic Strike over Robilar's Gambit? I'd say the second is way better - you get an AoO when they try to hit you, regardless if they succeed. |
| #94nanshorkApr 09, 2008 12:50:12 | stuff Beguilers have cohort LA, not normal LA. They're not playable as a PC. Also, I don't see the point in adding a race that needs to use a spiked chain or some such to a monk handbook. And I don't see the point in an Unbodied monk at all, incorporeality isn't helpful to a melee character, plus the LA is a big problem. As to your "if I get hit I hit them" section, they're all already in the guide except for double hit. Furthermore, out of the other feats you listed, the only one I see as any good is the extra reach. Minor natural attacks and some natural armor just aren't good enough to be worth a feat. Surreal's list of stuff has more than enough on increasing monk damage. As for the rest, it doesn't really belong in the guide to monks, it's all general goodness. |
| #95jetstrike3000Apr 09, 2008 13:00:41 | Beguilers have cohort LA, not normal LA. They're not playable as a PC. What is a cohort LA and where did you find this tidbit of information so I can update my records. |
| #96zarzakApr 09, 2008 13:31:58 | Two fun monk builds: Build 1: Argent Fist Build I love the Argent Fist prc - I'm not sure if you want to put this build in your handbook though. Paladin 4/Monk 2/Argent Fist 10/Warshaper 3/Swordsage 1 Feats: 1) Knight Training (required) 3) Serenity (Dragon 306) 4 monk) Improved Unarmed Strike 4 monk) Stunning Fist 5 monk) Combat Reflexes 6) Improved Natural Attack 9) Superior Unarmed Strike 12) Intuitive Attack 15) Martial Study - Crusader's Strike 18) Martial Stance - Thicket of Blades The goal of this build was two-fold: Make monk go from MAD to SAD, and get a lot of defensive options in place. The build is definitely SAD: Wisdom is applied to divine grace, lay on hands, smite evil, turn undead, extra AC, will save, and your attack. CON is also important still. If you decide to do power attacking instead of martial study/thicket of blades, or instead of stunning fist/combat reflexes (via sub features), then strength becomes very important. Defensively you get to wear fullplate and get the monk's AC bonuses. Warshaper provides some offensive options, as does swordsage and the argent fist's class features. Think of it as a monk tank. ^^ -------------- This second build was more for fun. The goal was to become a forever young, forever immortal creature. It turns out this can only really be done through monk. Human Vigilant Monk 5 (with the 5th level planar monk substitution)/Tattooed Monk 5 (Crane Tattoo, Ocean Tattoo, and whatever Tattoo, maybe Phoenix?)/Cloud Anchorite 10. Feats are mostly free, I chose: 1) Endurance 1 human) Mountaineer 1 monk) Improved Grapple 1 monk) Improved Unarmed Strike 3) Intuitive Strike 6) Improved Natural Attack 9) Two-Weapon Fighting 12) Improved Two-Weapon Fighting 13 Cloud anchorite) Cold Endurance 15) Greater Two-Weapon Fighting 17 cloud anchorite) Improved Cold Endurance 18) Versatile Unarmed Strike or Stunning Fist Beyond the first level feats (which are pre-reqs) everything else is free, so you can make whatever kind of monk character you want. For example, you could easily work towards optimizing stunning fist ... or whatever! This character is fairly weak offensively, but was optimized more towards defense + RP value. He has Evasion, Improved Uncanny Dodge, the full monk unarmed damage progression, +50' speed, +50' climb, +4 to AC, and wis to AC. He never ages starting at level 10, and becomes immortal at level 20. He is immune to nonmagical diseases and poisons, and never needs to eat, sleep, or drink. Sort of the stereotypical martial arts master on the mountaintop kinda guy. You could easily do VoP with him - it fits the theme pretty well. |
| #97nanshorkApr 09, 2008 17:15:31 | What is a cohort LA and where did you find this tidbit of information so I can update my records. Cohort LA is the LA a creature would have if used as a cohort. You get cohorts from the Leadership feat. And it says it right in the stat block. "LA: 0 (cohort)" |
| #98The_Crimson_DawnApr 10, 2008 23:28:35 | I did not see it yet but in Faiths of Ebberon there is a construct graft that I think is called heavy arms or something like that. It grants you a slam attack and allows any race it is grafted to the ability to use a battlefist. In addition if you have multiple grafts it gives you the ability to pierce DR/Andamantine and DR/andamantine. If you need ghost touch use a ghost shroud from the magic item compendium (I think that is what it is called), if you want to pierce magic and silver use the guantlets of weaponry arcane (once again I think that is the name), and if you want andamantine use the ring of andamantine of which all are from the same book. After all that you can pierce magic, silver, and incorpereal along with other dr that you want such as versatile unarmed strike for piercing and slashing. The only dr that is a problem for me is epic (if you do not buff your battlefist), alignments outside of the one or two your classes give you, and cold iron (maybe make your battlefist out of cold iron but then it costs more). |
| #99ppaladin123Apr 26, 2008 1:45:31 | Here is a build using incarnum: Skarn Monk 11/spinemeld warrior 9 Str: 18, Dex 12, Con 14, Wis 16, Int 8, Cha 8 Important Feats: shape soul melds: enigma crown, sphinx claws. Open least chakras: crown and hands, improved natural attack ACF: Holy Ki Strike, Skarn racial substitution levels (pick mauling gauntlets at 10th level) Bind the Enigma Helm to the Crown Chakra to make all your melee attacks have the force descriptor (and thus overcome DR and act as if ghost touch weapons). Bind the Sphinx Claws to the Hands Chakra for Pounce. Mauling Gauntlets bound to the arms chakra make your spines keen and lawful and give you a nice bonus to strength checks like trip. |
| #100sinfire_titanApr 26, 2008 2:28:58 | Here is a build using incarnum: Improving upon this: Monk 2/Barbarian 2 (Lion-Totem)/Ranger 2/Spinemeld Warrior 7/War Mind 8 Feats: 1st: Educated Flaw: Hidden Talent (or just Wild Talent) Flaw: Any Monk 1: Stunning Fist Monk 2: Combat Reflexes 3rd: Sapphire Fist (for the Essentia) 6th: Any Ranger: TWFing Sometime during War Mind: Tashalatora. Idea: Flurry of Blows+Pounce+Psychic Warrior Powers+Soulmelds=Dead enemy. |
| #101turalisjMay 05, 2008 21:39:00 | Anyone have a Monk/FoZ build? |
| #102the_shamanMay 05, 2008 22:08:57 | Does using another PrC to update your FoZ progression count? I was thinking that Monk 6/FoZ4/X 10 with Tashalatora for the 2nd PrC would be the simplest option. You can do it with a PrC that uses the FoZ progression - Elocator, Slayer, even sanctified mind - or with a PrC with a progression of its own, using the FoZ for low-ML buffs, like the Warmind. I think both have their merits; in either case the FoZ provides a good base. A FoZ/warmind is not a bad combo at all imo, providing you with a PrC that has the warmind prerequisite Knowledge Psi as a class skill and gives you a few more low-level powers that complement the warmind's limited repertoire. On the other hand, an elocator or slayer allows you to get the two PrCs' impressive abilities while continuing an ok power progression - faster than PW levels would give you, at least at first. Also, on the monk/barb/ranger/spinemeld warrior, I don't have MoI right now, but weren't spinemelds supposed to be lawful? |
| #103thanaelMay 08, 2008 10:53:31 | Anyone have a Monk/FoZ build? Check out Jaerom's awesome Zuoken. |
| #104nicholas_the_paladinJul 27, 2008 19:09:03 | Pounce is one the most sought after ablities among melee classes and monk is no exception. The ability to execute flurry of blows after charge is just good, especially when it also mitigates hitting difficulties. Add in skill trick "twisted charge" for extra maneuverability. Here's how to get this great ability: another source is the feats from Magic of Incarnum. Take the feat 'shape soulmeld' to get 'sphinx claws' and then the feat 'open chakra' to bind it to your arm-chakra. You'll be able to pounce at will. These feats are open to any character with at least CON 13 Combine this with 'Law Devotion from CC and you'll be able to 1)charge, 2)pounce and 3)walk away in one round. It really saves a lot of HP's |
| #105divisionbyzer0Sep 26, 2008 7:20:52 | To help with the alignment problems with barbarians and monks multi-classing there is a chaotic variant from dragon #335: you lose flurry for "flailing strike" which follows the same hit progression but gives a RANDOM number of additional attacks starting at 1d4-1, ending at 1d6. It looks like this ability uses the the highest attack bonus for all the attacks though, unlike the flurry lose purity of body, wholeness of body, diamond body, abundant step, tongue of sun and moon, perfect self gain some stuff with charging, blur like ability, anarchic self, freedom of thought |
| #106SenevriSep 26, 2008 17:19:54 | What is the current status of Ordered Chaos feat concerning alignment shenanigans? |
| #107mmx_zero_00_Sep 28, 2008 14:00:09 | I'm curious about how the dragon descendant PrC, from dragon magic, is never mentioned. Also consider this build, Warblade1/monk4/Druken master1/bloodstormblade4 yeah its only lvl 10, but basically you can now full attack by throw chairs(or any object that would need 2 hands to throw) and PA as a two handed weapon while using your unarmed strike dmg. |
| #108sinfire_titanSep 29, 2008 19:10:46 | What is the current status of Ordered Chaos feat concerning alignment shenanigans? Ordered Chaos only works for magic items and the Abyssal Herator feat Primordal Scion. Nothing else. |
| #109ninjarabbitSep 29, 2008 21:14:15 | bard1/paladin17/monk2 Key feats: able learner (to max out UMD and perform), devoted performer, initatie of milil, ascetic knight Smiting as a 20th level paladin, bardic music abilities as a 18th level bard, unarmed strike damage as a 19th level monk You could take the overwhelming attack monk variant from UA/SRD for the power attack and improved bullrush feats, setting you up for divine might and shock trooper. |
| #110morfeasrevOct 06, 2008 5:19:16 | I just saw a race from MM3 that MUST be includes to this monks guide. HARSSAF (MM3 p82) some of the abilities are: STR +4 DEX +6 CON +6 CHA +2 +3 natural armor damage reduction 5/bludgeoning 6d6 Racial HD with 9(2+int) skill points attack bonus +6, saves +2,+5,+5 Alertness and Lightning reflexes as bonus feats 3 feats because of LA Flaming aura (Su): Like Fiery Ki Defense but at will free action!!!!! Sand Pulse(su): 1/day 3d6 30feet aoe may blind as well Sand Form(su): you become a pile of moble sand at will Spell Resistance 17 + class lvl wow thats better than the monks one blindsense 30ft, immune to blindness and fire fast healing 3 Vulnerability to cold (the only bad thing) Favored Class: Monk LA+4 |
| #111bronzebeardOct 06, 2008 6:41:39 | bard1/paladin17/monk2 The devoted performer lets you combine paladin + bard, same goes with initiate of milil. ascetic knight do the same for monk + paladin. But you need a third feat to get monk + bard otherwise, wonky things will happen. |
| #112ninjarabbitOct 06, 2008 15:47:27 | But you need a third feat to get monk + bard otherwise, wonky things will happen. Not really, the build only loses 1 monk level for unarmed damage and 2 bard levels for bardic music. I suppose you could try to work in the ascetic mage feat if you wanted to take 4 bard levels or so. |
| #113bronzebeardOct 26, 2008 4:52:15 | I dunno. Somethink is a miss here. Maybe I'm mistaken. =/ |
| #114KerrusNov 07, 2008 20:30:49 | Nice guides, all in all. I've started my first monk build this past monday, and... it's an experience. Don't know the GM much yet, so I'm going for a fairly basic build- though I didn't think I was going to make a monk going into it, and didn't have any chance to research (ergo, some... bad feat choices, particularly mobility/dodge) As it is, I'm planning taking Monk to sixth level, then PrC into Shintao. Once I finish that, I'm not sure what I plan to do. Maybe some more levels in monk- until I get Diamond Soul, then multiclass into something else. I'm still not sure which books the GM has access to, and the only books I have access to I don't actually own (borrowing from a friend who lets me peruse their pages, :p) so I'll need to see what my options are. Fortunately, I'm only at level 1, and I did get some pretty good rolls during Character Creation. Hoping to pick up Intuitive Strike when I hit level 2- though that'll take a bit of convincing the GM and being exceptionally good IC. So eh. |
| #115winternachtDec 18, 2008 5:08:32 | Three questions here: 1. How does the monks unarmed damage progression combine with e.g. claws? 2. Someone said you could combine flurry of blows and two-weapon fighting, is that true? 3. How is flurry of blows connected to BAB? |
| #116SenevriDec 18, 2008 9:03:29 | Three questions here: It doesn't. At all. A lenient DM might allow you to do slashing damage, if you have claws, I guess... 2. Someone said you could combine flurry of blows and two-weapon fighting, is that true? Yup. 3. How is flurry of blows connected to BAB? Directly from the SRD: - she may make one extra attack in a round at her highest base attack bonus, but this attack takes a -2 penalty, as does each other attack made that round. - When a monk reaches 5th level, the penalty lessens to -1, and at 9th level it disappears. - A monk must use a full attack action to strike with a flurry of blows. Monk also has a different ability called "Greater Flurry". Greater Flurry When a monk reaches 11th level, <...> she gets a second extra attack at her full base attack bonus. I doubt not that many classes actually net this, as most just progress flurry... For an example, a Shadow Sun Ninja misses out on Flurry of Blows. An unarmed Swordsage doesn't get any flurries, either. Superior Unarmed Strike doesn't do anything, nor does Monk's Belt. Tattooed Monk doesn't progress this. Etc. Actually, let me count the ways: Classes which DO NOT progress Flurry of Blows: Tattoed Monk Sacred Fist Fist of Zuoken Enlightened Fist... Dragon Descendant Fist of the Forest Drunken Master Shadow Sun Ninja Kensai Initiate of Draconic Mysteries Zerth Cenobyte Classes which DO progress Flurry of Blows: Uncanny Trickster Monk Disciple of the Eye (for flurry only, technically..) Disciple of the Word (does not gain flurry, but progresses) BAB functions normally. Hey, has Monk 11/Suel Arcanamach 4/Swiftblade 5 been suggested? A bit expensive (dodge, mobility, combat casting, iron will), but is practically constantly hasted with 50% concealment and 20% targeted spell miss chance. Oh, and 4th level Suloise casting. *edit* Wait, trouble. Need MWP x4. Need to be an Elf, then. Hmm. Monk 11 /Swordsage 1/Suel Arcanamach 2/Jade Phoenix Mage 6... That being said, a Variant Dread Commando would already net 50% concealment, but no spellcasting, though. |
| #117SenevriDec 18, 2008 9:45:37 | add average d20 roll= +10 = +37/+37/+37/+37/+32/+27/+22 Reply to OldPost, but... your example three attacks do NUTHIN! :D ... although you'll likely get one hit there, as you need 13 on the first and 18 on the second. The last one only hits on a 20. One point less of BAB changes nothing, IMO. |
| #118midgard_in_ruinDec 18, 2008 11:35:40 | Exemplars of evil: monk alternate features: feign death: Kinda self explanatory. Replaces evasion invisible fist: invisibility for a round every three rounds. Absolute gold In the elder evils, between two feats, monks can deal 2 vile damage with every unarmed strike as well. Thought I'd just mention them. |
| #119unundindurDec 19, 2008 1:15:27 | Classes in order: Swordsage1/Monk4/Swordsage3/Fighter4/Shou Disciple3/Master of the Nine5 Feats in order (including feats from classes): Dodge, Stunning blow, Weapon Finesse, Combat Reflexes, Adaptive Style, Superior Unarmed Strike, Improved Natural Attack, Weapon Focus, Weapon Specialisation, Weapon Mastery, Improved Initiative, Blind Fight, Snap Kick Sources: Players Handbook, Players Handbook 2, Tome of Battle, Monster Manual, Unapproachable East Notes: *This build uses the swordsage unarmed variant. *This build keeps all base classes within 1 level of each (for the most part), thus there is no xp penalty. *Ends with BaB 16, Initiator level 14 and a very powerful set of normal attacks. *It allows people to effectively dump strength and focus on wisdom and dexterity, which in my experience is very popular. |
| #120SenevriDec 19, 2008 2:40:26 | I like it. I especially like the clean way you represented it. Question, though: What does Shou Disciple do for this build, and how would you do without it? I take Monk 4 is for Ki Strike prereq. on some class? |
| #121unundindurDec 19, 2008 4:08:22 | Monk 4 is rather simple: Monk is cool as long as there are no drawbacks ![]() That 4th level grants you BaB, saves and continued progression in everything. Ki Stike is also cool, but not at all the reason. The Shou Disciple is special in that it grants full BaB and monk progression. That by itself is key. In addition it grants bonus feats, which this build sorely needs (I barely managed to put in everything essential). Without Shou Disciple, this build doesn't work, since you would not reach the same unarmed damage and have BaB 16 at the same time ![]() |
| #122unundindurDec 19, 2008 6:24:14 | As for a perfectly valid arcane monk, its not harder than modifying the classic gish: Race: Elf (sun or moon, depending on your taste) Levels in order: Monk1/Conjurer5/Eldritch knight3/Abjurant Champion5/Eldritch Knight6 Feats in order: Otherworldly, Improved Grapple, Carmendine Monk, Weapon Finesse, Spontaneous Divination, 5 feats left to play with and tune this in whatever direction. Notes: *BaB 16, CL 18 *As far as I can see, this should be perfectly valid, and this character will be an AC monster from the depth of the deepest places. *biggest problem is probably that he will be rather weak (as weak as a near full caster can be...) until he gets weapon finesse. *For all its worth, take Immediate Magic for complete win. |
| #123ChristopherGrovesDec 19, 2008 7:37:52 | That can be handled by a feycraft monk weapon. There's also an enchantment that grants finesse too right? |
| #124SenevriDec 19, 2008 8:21:28 | Lessee, you have the UA damage of Monk 11, or Monk 15 if Swordsage stacks. In any case, with a Monk's Belt, you'll have the best or second best fist. All in all, a decent optimization of the Fist. As you said, Shou is basically for: - Unarmed progression AND - Two bonus feats. At three levels, that's hard to match. Lessee... ... Well, Ascetic Rogue feat, + feat Rogue... but it's behind 1 BAB and 1 feat. :/ Psywar gets the feats, but again loses BAB and fist power. Still, it might be a decent alternative otherwise. A cleric with right domains might snatch the feats, but for some reason there isn't an Ascetic Cleric feat or somesuch around :/ Ugh. I must agree here, it seems. |
| #125carnivoreDec 19, 2008 11:22:39 | Shou Disciple 5 allows you to Flurry with ANY Martial weapon.... thus there are many options that are opened up: Use a Martial Reach Weapon Use a Trip Weapon with Reach... get multiple Trip attacks as Melee Touch Attacks and they cant Trip back... and you didnt spend a 2 feats(Combat Expertise, Imp Trip) Use Disarm Weapon with Reach Use Magical Weapon Enhancements that you dont have on your hands :D |
| #126SenevriDec 19, 2008 11:47:28 | I just dislike setting specific stuff. |
| #127carnivoreDec 19, 2008 11:55:58 | most setting specific things do allow for Adaptation... provided you have a lienient DM :D |
| #128carnivoreDec 19, 2008 12:03:54 | Reply to OldPost, but... your example three attacks do NUTHIN! :D if the character is using Touch Attacks(Tripping, Grapple, etc...) they are all effective... a character might even have a Single Touch attack... thus could use the first attacks as Normal... and the Last Attack as a Touch Attack(exa: Unavoidable Strike) against the example creatures .... they do give the OPPORTUNITY to Hit(however slight).... but more than that... they give a Lot More in EPIC play also having an extra itterative attack also helps fighting Multiple opponents :D |
| #129SenevriDec 19, 2008 12:53:00 | Uh, yeah... Touch attacks. ... Okay, you got a point there. (there's also the tidbit that BAB is designed to scale so's you can use it for Power Attack, so if you don't you sometimes got a bit of extra.) and yet, it's at most, two hits at -15 to hit. Let's agree to disagree on that. *edit* Although, your examples weren't really close to max at all. I counted some items and got +32 to hit easily, so with a bit of BAB optimization that's +33, for an almost pure monk. A Gish Monk could probably go to something high enough to make the last attacks sort of relevant. So dunno... doesn't really matter except for epic play. |
| #130carnivoreDec 19, 2008 13:09:03 | i was just trying to give examples of high CR regular opponents ... that would be expected to be encountered by a High Level Monk character at some time they were also something that i could get the Numbers on quickly from the SRD :D |
| #131drivenDec 19, 2008 22:04:35 | Any opinions on the Shintao Monk in Oriental Adventures? |
| #132carnivoreDec 20, 2008 11:30:32 | Any opinions on the Shintao Monk in Oriental Adventures? it is awesome... mainly for the Bonus Feats that it gives ... i dont have OA anymore so i can only remember that about it ... but i do remember i used it a lot :D |
| #133drivenDec 20, 2008 14:03:39 | I was thinking of doing one of these AoO builds. Along with some grappling. The Earth's Embrace feat in OA is... far more desireable than the CW one. Automatic critical damage can be fun. I was going to make him a Disarmer, but after reading this thread... It just wouldn't be a good idea. My DM is taking off the Code of Conduct thing, so it should be a fairly more fun class really. That and he is saying its just going to progress flurry of blows. Though, I wish I could do the pounce thing somehow. Flying Kick+Pounce+Flurry of blows is amazing. |
| #134phaedrusxyDec 20, 2008 23:42:15 | I was thinking of doing one of these AoO builds. Along with some grappling. The Earth's Embrace feat in OA is... far more desireable than the CW one. Automatic critical damage can be fun. I was going to make him a Disarmer, but after reading this thread... It just wouldn't be a good idea. My DM is taking off the Code of Conduct thing, so it should be a fairly more fun class really. That and he is saying its just going to progress flurry of blows. Four levels of Singh Rager, also from Oriental Adventures, gives Pounce + Rage. Or dip into Psiwarrior and take Psionic Lion's Charge. |
| #135carnivoreDec 21, 2008 15:58:20 | Four levels of Singh Rager, also from Oriental Adventures, gives Pounce + Rage. Or dip into Psiwarrior and take Psionic Lion's Charge. Singh Rager is FAR FAR FAR better than a Dip into PW..... it is Full BAB, Good Fort and Will saves, d12 HD, great class features(Fury, Ki Shout multiple times per day, Pounce,etc...) all for free without spending any PP... or needing any PP :D |
| #136phaedrusxyDec 22, 2008 0:06:02 | Singh Rager is FAR FAR FAR better than a Dip into PW..... it is Full BAB, Good Fort and Will saves, d12 HD, great class features(Fury, Ki Shout multiple times per day, Pounce,etc...) all for free without spending any PP... or needing any PP It gives you a bit of MAD, though, since you need Cha 13 to enter it, IIRC. I have played a couple of Monk/Shou Disciple/Singh Ragers and enjoyed it alot, though. |
| #137vdragoonDec 22, 2008 2:33:43 | From the Official D&D Game Rule FAQ v.3.5 Main D&D FAQ Does a monk with a monk’s belt and the Superior Unarmed Strike feat benefit from both, or does just the highest benefit apply? In this case, the better benefit will prevail. These effects technically do not have a bonus, so they would not use the stacking rules. One effect will end up overshadowing the other. These effects don't stack so if you want lvl 20 fists you gotta go through feats/MC that allow monk unarmed dmg progression. |
| #138drivenDec 22, 2008 6:14:11 | It gives you a bit of MAD, though, since you need Cha 13 to enter it, IIRC. I have played a couple of Monk/Shou Disciple/Singh Ragers and enjoyed it alot, though. I like that idea. Was going to shoot for 11 levels of monk, at the least. And of course at least 4 levels of singh rager. Shou Disciple is great and all.. But the Shintao monk would make a bit more sense in this case. Either way. My flurry of blows/pounce/flying kick thing will be nasty. Well. 12 levels of monk, with 4 levels shou disciple, and the rest in Shintao monk would give me a base attack bonus of 16/11/6/1. Which would make my flurry of blows really nice. I like this idea. |
| #139phaedrusxyDec 22, 2008 9:14:13 | Shou stacks for flurry. |
| #140frerezarDec 22, 2008 10:11:56 | Ok i hope i don't get bashed for this but. What are your toughts on the monk's alternate class feature from Exemplars of Evil to become invisible (not as the spell) for an entyre round every three rounds by sacrificing evasion. IDK it just seems ment to work with rogue. Anyway i just wanted some insight as i like it a lot. |
| #141kuririn67Jan 21, 2009 16:05:27 | Hi, what do you guys think about a Thri Kreen (ExPsi page 14) Monk equipped with the Multiattack Feat. Wouldn't he be able to strike 5 times at a -4 penalty (at first level) |
| #142unundindurJan 22, 2009 0:53:57 | Ok i hope i don't get bashed for this but. What are your toughts on the monk's alternate class feature from Exemplars of Evil to become invisible (not as the spell) for an entyre round every three rounds by sacrificing evasion. IDK it just seems ment to work with rogue. Anyway i just wanted some insight as i like it a lot. I personally love it because if I first play a monk he tend to be the guy who wants invisibility ![]() Also, it is a great change if you also multiclass with rogue, and thus gain evasion twice. From a pure optimization point of view, and in a high-level build its a bad trade, because getting invisibility at high levels is a lot easier than getting evasion (and evasion is a dead solid ability). |
| #143carnivoreJan 22, 2009 4:18:25 | a quick note on ease of acquisition: Ring of Evasion: This ring continually grants the wearer the ability to avoid damage as if she had evasion. Whenever she makes a Reflex saving throw to determine whether she takes half damage, a successful save results in no damage. Moderate transmutation; CL 7th; Forge Ring, jump; Price 25,000 gp. Ring of Invisibility: By activating this simple silver ring, the wearer can benefit from invisibility, as the spell. Faint illusion; CL 3rd; Forge Ring, invisibility; Price 20,000 gp. an interesting side Note: Invisibility from ring requires you to use a standard action that does not provoke attacks of opportunity, and duration of Invisibility = 3 Minutes(30 rounds) because CL = 3 :D |
| #144unundindurJan 22, 2009 9:45:41 | an interesting side Note: Invisibility from ring requires you to use a standard action that does not provoke attacks of opportunity, and duration of Invisibility = 3 Minutes(30 rounds) because CL = 3 Yea, the main point of the invisibility is the immediate action-activation. Its not as great as abrupt jaunt, but its pretty nice. |
| #145carnivoreJan 22, 2009 11:26:56 | Yea, the main point of the invisibility is the immediate action-activation. Its not as great as abrupt jaunt, but its pretty nice. true... thats why its better to be a Pixie... and have constant Greater Invisibility :P ;) |
| #146vdragoonJan 22, 2009 17:19:17 | I just multiclass with ninja 2 and got ghost step (invisible), which acts like greater invis as ruled in the 3.5 FAQ. Expend a use of ki to activate it as a swift action that does not provoke an aoo. I have ascetic stalker feat for progression in unarmed strike dmg, ki strike and ki pool. Not optimized but I like it, plus I get sudden strike. |
| #147jameswilliamogleJan 22, 2009 18:32:53 | true... thats why its better to be a Pixie... and have constant Greater Invisibility :P You and your pixies... |
| #148Omni-WyvernilFeb 01, 2009 1:05:01 | I don't see a lot of stuff here for Sacred Fists. Any suggestions on feats/builds that might suit one? Of course, the easy answer is 'persistent divine metamagic', but some might find that a tad cheesy. Law Devotion looked like an interesting option to boost AC or attack bonus. |
| #149unundindurFeb 01, 2009 2:18:38 | I don't see a lot of stuff here for Sacred Fists. Any suggestions on feats/builds that might suit one? Of course, the easy answer is 'persistent divine metamagic', but some might find that a tad cheesy. I belive people generally find them super-weak. I haven't checked, but I think it would be better going with a modified gish: Monk2/Conjurer5/Eldritch Knight2/Abjurant Champion5/Eldritch Knight6 (or something similar) If you take superion unarmed strike, improved natural attack and carmendine monk you pretty well on your way to awesome, with monk flavour. EDIT: Ops, for some reason I thought you were talking about the arcane one. My bad. |
| #150the_shamanFeb 01, 2009 2:43:07 | I just dislike setting specific stuff. It's not really specific. There's no order, deity or something it's tied with. Ok, the title suggests it has come Shou (which are something like the Asian immigrants in "mainland" FR), but that's no more necessary than your TKD trainer being Korean. |
| #151madtitanfanFeb 02, 2009 22:44:06 | I dont know If anyone has seen this Feat but in Shining South there is a Feat called Lion Tribe Warrior that lets Monk Pounce all day long, only restriction is you have to be Human and From Shar. Seems Fair to me. |
| #152unundindurFeb 03, 2009 6:40:43 | I dont know If anyone has seen this Feat but in Shining South there is a Feat called Lion Tribe Warrior that lets Monk Pounce all day long, only restriction is you have to be Human and From Shar. Wow! I have never even heard of that feat, and its sweet! That feat can be useful in so many builds, by removing the need of any pesky barbarian. Thanks for finding it! ![]() |
| #153the_shamanFeb 03, 2009 12:42:41 | I thought it was a feat for barbarians? I might be wrong though. I know that the Snow Tiger lounge feat from Unapproachable East requires affiliation with a Rashemi berserker lodge, and was the same in many other ways, but I don't remember the SS version. Also, it allowed pounce with a single light weapon, but I'd say monks have no problem there ;) |
| #154carnivoreFeb 03, 2009 13:12:08 | here it is:Lion Tribe Warrior[Regional](Shining South)Reqs: Region: Human (the Shaar),Clan: Lion Tribe (see Human Tribes of the Shaar, page 164 Shining South). :D |
| #155nabuchadnezzarFeb 09, 2009 7:32:01 | Hi carnivore, I read your guide to psionic monks, especially where you advise a monk 11 - warmind 9 build for a SRD only character. How do you deal with the fact that knowledge (psionics) is cross class for monks? Warmind requires 8 ranks in it so it shouldn't be available till monk level 13. What do you think about this other build? Monk 6 - Fist of Zuoken (Psionic Fist) 4 - Warmind 10 You take psionic fist to take the necessary prerequisites for warmind and also happen to increase your monk abilities and access the psychic warrior power list a bit earlier. |
| #156carnivoreFeb 10, 2009 16:03:02 | Hi carnivore, I read your guide to psionic monks, especially where you advise a monk 11 - warmind 9 build for a SRD only character. havent forgotten .... will answer later gotta go right now :D |
| #157orrynMar 02, 2009 22:00:16 | Is there any substitution for losing the wisdom AC bonus? I have a MC monk / moon-warded ranger from Dragon 340. At second level I want to pick up Armor of the Senses - Add your Wisdom modifier to your AC. This bonus applies to your Touch AC and you keep this bonus even if you are Flat-Footed. The bonus is lost when you are Immobilized, Helpless, wearing Medium (or heavier) armor, or when carrying a Medium (or heavier) load. I give up the combat style for that level. DM says I cannot combine the AC bonuses. So is there anything out there I can get by giving up the monk's AC bonus? Or better yet, anybody got a ruling on adding the two? I know about the ninja / monk not being able to add together, but this seems like a different kind of ability. It just uses the same stat to add to AC. thanks |
| #158sofawallMar 02, 2009 22:10:05 | Different sources, different names, untyped bonuses... Yup, they should clearly stack. |
| #159awaken_D_M_golemJun 30, 2009 18:12:42 | bump |
| #160humankyleJul 16, 2009 11:10:48 | A dragon descendent monk build with some lockdown thrown in? Show Changeling. Monk 3/Crusader 1/Fighter 1/dragon descendent 10/warshaper 4/Crusader 1 BA 15 Saves 17/7/14 Stats Str 15 Dex 14 Con 10 Int 8 Wis 13 Cha 12 Feats/abilities: 1: Draconic Heritage, Stunning fist, Decisive Strike 2: Combat reflexes 3: Mage Slayer 5 Power attack 6: Close-Quarters Fighting (DM Dependent I’ve played with DM’s who won’t use the grappling rules and ones who will change the monsters feats to improved grapple just because) 9: Improved Natural attack 12: Snap kick 15: Deft oppurtonist 18: Stand Still Without monks belt or any feat or ability modifications Unarmed damage 2d6 Speed +40 Decisive strike as 3rd level monk AC bonus +2 Stunning Fist 7/day With monks belt, Improved natural attack, and 1 warshaper size increase Unarmed damage = 4d8 (did I do that right) Dragon descendent gives better Rolibars gambit +5 to ac +5 to saves and dr 10/cold iron And some stuff Warshaper gives, reach, size increase for fist, fast healing, higher stats, immunities |
| #161danduJul 16, 2009 13:01:05 | So, I've been hearing about partially charged wands... |
| #162themistoklesJul 16, 2009 16:43:37 | So have I ... |
| #163ORC_WyvernJul 17, 2009 14:24:21 | Hi. I had to remove some content from this thread because it violates the Code of Conduct Please keep your posts polite, respectful, and on-topic, and refrain from making personal attacks. |
| #164magmer1Jul 20, 2009 11:49:58 | This is a monk that says screw MAD SAD monk Water Orc Base stats>>racial standard array Strength 14>>18 Dexterity 13>>13 Constitution 12 >> 14 Intelligence 15>>13 Wisdom 8>>6 Charisma 10>>8 Fighter2/18 passive way monk DR variant Feats Level 1 dodge (F) Power attack Level 2 combat reflexes Level 3 Combat expertise, karmic strike, decisive strike Level 4 improved trip, magical deflection Level 6 Improved feint, knock down Level 9 Improved sunder Level 12 Shock trooper Level 15 Deft oppurtunist Level 18 Robilars Gambit>>retrain Karmic strike to expert tactician, |
| #165danduJul 20, 2009 12:15:28 | So what does it do? |
| #166turalisjJul 20, 2009 12:30:15 | Get it's ass kicked three ways to sunday, duh :P |
| #167magmer1Jul 20, 2009 13:16:39 | So what does it do? It sets up counter attack exchanges between itself and another creature using decisive strike to get double damage. Its saves should be pretty decent due to being a monk, and it should have an AC of 21, 17 after karmic strike, at level 3 before it buys magic armor and shields and other items. It will try to trip with knock down, it has a high strength and +4 from passive way so it should be pretty decent at it. Deft oppurtunist will off set its low BAB, as will its focus on one strong attack. |
| #168danduJul 20, 2009 13:49:11 | I beleive your AC is +8 from full plate, +1 from monk, +1 from dex. +1 again against one opponent. |
| #169magmer1Jul 21, 2009 0:41:26 | I beleive your AC is +8 from full plate, +1 from monk, +1 from dex. Err, +8 from F.Plate, +2 from large shield, +1 from dex, and +1 against one opponent. No monk bonus to AC, I traded that out for DR, also I'm in full plate and using a large shield. |
| #170turalisjJul 21, 2009 1:04:46 | I'm pretty sure you can't get any of the alternate monk abilities while in full plate. |
| #171dr_rocktopusJul 21, 2009 1:22:59 | There are a couple that can be broken carefully into working with armor. The incarnum substitution level, I believe, supplies a bonus that will work in armor. |
| #172danduJul 21, 2009 6:46:42 | Err, +8 from F.Plate, +2 from large shield, +1 from dex, and +1 against one opponent. No monk bonus to AC, I traded that out for DR, also I'm in full plate and using a large shield. These are the kinds of things you may want to elaborate on when explaining your build. |
| #173magmer1Jul 21, 2009 23:29:37 | I'm pretty sure you can't get any of the alternate monk abilities while in full plate. They don't say anything about armor, so I am assuming that they do infact work in armor. |
| #174danduJul 22, 2009 0:04:32 | They don't say anything about armor, so I am assuming that they do infact work in armor. ![]() |
| #175dr_rocktopusJul 22, 2009 1:31:05 | In this case, it's valid. Most ACFs specify either all their requirements or all their inherited requirements if they are based specifically off of something. :: shrugs :: |
| #176turalisjJul 22, 2009 9:27:04 | They don't say anything about armor, so I am assuming that they do infact work in armor. I don't know about anyone else, but every DM I know would be grabbing their phb and smacking the player upside the head for saying this. I would say that, if the class feature that the alternate is replacing requires you not to wear armor then the alternate class feature can't be used. I'll go book diving to see if I can find a ruling on this.... |
| #177-ktkenshinx-Jul 22, 2009 11:20:47 | The Unarmed Damage progression of a Monk works regardless of your armor. This establishes a precedent that there are indeed certain monk abilities that function even in armor, and unless the text specifies otherwise, it is likely that Decisive Strike is one of them. There is no PHB2 Errata to suggest otherwise, as well. -ktkenshinx- |
| #178turalisjJul 22, 2009 11:25:16 | Monk abilities lost in armor (don't have my book with me atm)- Flurry of Blows, AC Bonus, Speed Bonus. Of these, the build relies on alternate features for AC and Flurry of Blows. The Flurry of Blows seems especialy key, since the alternate feature would be double damage. |
| #179dr_rocktopusJul 22, 2009 11:33:21 | For god'sake, this is ridiculous. Not being able to use a thing in armor is kinda important. It's noted down explicitly in every other case where it applies, why would it be magically assumed here? Unless the ACF directly inherits characteristics as per a "functions like _________ except" clause or something similar, it inherits no behavior. Likewise, new text over-rides inherited text where conflicting. |
| #180-ktkenshinx-Jul 22, 2009 11:37:06 | Monk abilities lost in armor (don't have my book with me atm)- Flurry of Blows, AC Bonus, Speed Bonus. Of these, the build relies on alternate features for AC and Flurry of Blows. The Flurry of Blows seems especialy key, since the alternate feature would be double damage. Barbarians replace Fast Movement with most of their alternate class features: Improved Grab, Pounce, UA bonus feats, etc. Are you implying that the Barbarian would lose these feats and abilities if wearing armor that was too heavy, even though not a single one of the alternate class feature entries explicitly say so at any time? Decisive Strike makes no mention of armor limitations. This ability can be used in armor. |
| #181turalisjJul 22, 2009 11:40:48 | That is your interpretation of the rules. |
| #182-ktkenshinx-Jul 22, 2009 11:46:20 | That is your interpretation of the rules. No, that is how the rules are written. Notice the Barbarian ACF in the PHB2, Berserker's Rage. It inherits a number of the restrictions of the normal Rage ability (spell casting, inability to use concentration-like skills, etc). It has EXPLICITLY inherited these restrictions from the original ability that it replaced. This sets a precedent and leads us to wonder why one ability explicitly mentions restrictions that carry over, and why another ability does not. The only answer that is evident based off of facts, not opinion, is that Decisive Strike did not inherit Flurry restrictions, and thus is operable in armor. Is this a Wizards oversight? Maybe. Is a lot of stuff that goes down on the CO boards representative of Wizards oversight? Definitely. -ktkenshinx- |
| #183turalisjJul 22, 2009 11:49:48 | And thus another is added to the ignore list. |
| #184-ktkenshinx-Jul 22, 2009 11:53:13 | And thus another is added to the ignore list. I am sorry that you have interpreted my posts as belligerent. I am merely attempting to have an educated and informed argument about an ability, not initiate a fight. I would be happy to discuss the alternate interpretation of the rule on the rule's terms alone, and have no desire to engage in any animosity. If you have seen my posts as personal attacks, then I apologize, but I must uphold that these boards be kept free of the usual exchanges that plague the internet, and the mannerisms behind them. -ktkenshinx- |
| #185danduJul 22, 2009 13:01:14 | And thus another is added to the ignore list. Constructive and mature. |
| #186turalisjJul 22, 2009 13:03:37 | It's an alternative to getting banned because neither person wants to back down. |
| #187danduJul 22, 2009 13:05:34 | Or you could have just left instead of launching off a needless and offensive statement... ... but what fun would that have been? |
| #188phaedrusxyJul 22, 2009 13:06:45 | And thus another is added to the ignore list. WTF? You ignore everyone who disagrees with you? Your ignore list must be huge. :P |
| #189danduJul 22, 2009 13:08:55 | Anyhow... If you are a warforged monk/kensai with Sizing on your natural attacks, and transform (and roll out) into a Huge warforged, do you have a nonproficiency penalty to attacks with your body? |
| #190olo_eopiaJul 26, 2009 0:19:58 | Hey, I was looking at VoP Monks today, and I saw something. Maybe I'm going off and forgetting a rule, but..... With VoP you get bonus exalted feats. Touch of Golden Ice makes it so that any time your fist comes in contact with an evil creature (the majority of what players would be fighting) they get hit by golden ice. Low DC, yes, but it's 1d6 DEX damage, and they're going to roll a 1 sooner or later with flurry of blows. Also, since it's then a feat like stunning fist, would you be able to boost its DC like you did stunning fist with that feat from the monster manual? (the name escapes me at the moment) Sorry for taking your time if I'm wrong. |
| #191danduJul 26, 2009 1:08:19 | One of the problems with the Exalted feats is that they require CHA 15 for some reason... good luck getting that on a monk... |
| #192SenevriJul 26, 2009 3:23:55 | Most people I game with would lose exalted feats within a session of gaining them, too. I mean, you have to be so good, Paladins seem morally ambiguous. |
| #193olo_eopiaJul 26, 2009 9:09:41 | One of the problems with the Exalted feats is that they require CHA 15 for some reason... good luck getting that on a monk... Where does it say that? I never read it when going through the book. |
| #194danduJul 26, 2009 13:09:10 | Hm. I may be thinking of Align Ki Strike... |
| #195olo_eopiaJul 26, 2009 13:17:39 | The only requirement I've seen for Touch of Golden Ice is Con 13. Easily achievable for monks. After taking the feat, you have the potential to deal 1d6 Dex damage per strike against anything evil. Pretty cool if you ask me. |
| #196tomrkindrickJan 09, 2011 1:18:29 | So is this guide going to be finished any time soon? |
| #197waazraathJan 09, 2011 7:18:55 | Eh... since it's from 2008, and the last post before yours is from July 2009, my guess would be.... no ![]() You could check this out if you want another guide (not this) |
| #198ascreennamenotinuseJan 28, 2011 12:14:10 | Hi all My first question, after a lengthy and unfulfilling registration process: Can you think of any way to get armor or shield properties on a monk without actually wearing either? I know some effects can be duplicated by spells and such, but is there anything general that would allow any and all effects (not necessarily at the same time) to be added? One thing I've been looking at is using artificer infusions (like Armor Enhancement, ECS p. 109) on a warforged monk. Of course I don't actually want to play a warforged so I need some way to use the skin of the protean (XPH p. 176) to allow me to change into a warforged temporarily. Any other clever ideas? |
| #199ikildkennyFeb 02, 2011 9:29:31 | firstoff, a warforged monk is a baaaaaad idea - since you loose your AC bonus as well as most of your classfeatures ... second Armor: Bracers of Armor (a obvious choice) or crafted Item of constant effect "(Greater) Mage Armor" and Item of constand effect "Shield" both together give you +10 to AC (6 Armor (GMA) and 4 Shield) and putting both on the same item will cost you 36k GP (Constant GMA 30k, constant Shield 4k*1.5 b/c secondary effect on the same item) |
| #200The_Crimson_DawnFeb 02, 2011 16:25:47 | Warforged monks keep their AC bonus and class features as long as they do not pick up an armor feat. The descpription is very careful to avoid this issue and Races of Eberron makes it clear about how much of a benefit this is. |
| #201razak4988Feb 25, 2012 11:57:00 | So I am new to monk, I am currently lv4 Thri-Kreen Monk. I had a question about 'Improved Monk Unarmed Strike': says "Damage die of your unarmed strike improves to 1D10". So what I am wondering is; a lot of my attacks, Encounter, At Will, etc. say Monk Unarmed strike on them. i.e 'Awaken The Slumbering Hurt' Encounter Standard Action then below that says Monk Unarmed Strike: +6 vs. Fortitude 2d8+4 damage. So does the Improved Monk Unarmed strike Feat apply to this as well (and any other encounter/at will) or is it just for Basic Melee Attack only? 'Dragons Tail, At Will Standard Action, Monk unarmed strike: +6 vs. fortitude, 1d6+4 damage....... Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks |
| #202Tempest_StormwindFeb 25, 2012 13:33:29 | So I am new to monk, I am currently lv4 Thri-Kreen Monk. I had a question about 'Improved Monk Unarmed Strike': says "Damage die of your unarmed strike improves to 1D10". So what I am wondering is; a lot of my attacks, Encounter, At Will, etc. say Monk Unarmed strike on them. Before anyone points out that this is the wrong forum for this, note that he's already found that. |
| #203awaken_D_M_golemFeb 27, 2012 17:18:44 | 3kreen that goes into the 2 Headed Template from Sav Species could be interesting. (assumes the ritual is available and some gangster fronts the gold for it) ![]() |
| #204byte21Jul 21, 2013 17:13:49 | I never understand why everyone always misses my favourite of all the monk prestige classes, The "initiate of shattered steel". From the Mercenaries AEG rulebook page 208. Basically makes the monk able to easily shatter any weapon/shield (double strength for damaging weapons, deal maximized damage to weapon after successful disarm, etc...) add their wisdom to their damage bonus, re-roll 1's & 2's when dealing damage, can flank enemies by themselves, and as a capstone ability add their CON bonus to their AC. Has some pretty awesome stuff which makes their multi-stat reliance pretty useful in the later levels. Basically turns the monk into a melee powerhouse. IMO. |
| #205StevenOJul 21, 2013 17:29:25 | I never understand why everyone always misses my favourite of all the monk prestige classes, The "initiate of shattered steel". From the Mercenaries AEG rulebook page 208. ... You answered your own question. It's not in a rulebook that most of us would consider "official" because if you want to start taking homebrew stuff, which includes 3rd-party material, then you have a wealth of additional options. |
| #206DarthBlackApr 14, 2014 14:48:18 | I have a question about Monks...
A monks unarmed damage goes up as they level up and also gain differant attributes as well...
My question is does the "Hardness" lvl of a monks unarmed strike go up as they lvl? I thought there was a chart out there somewhere but i cannot find it.
I know that at lvl 16 a monks unarmed strike is equivilent to andaminite, what is it equivilent to at lower lvls?
A buddy of mine came up with this, but i thought i would ask everyone here their thoughts...
4th level: Counts as a magic weapon (+1 for purpose of damage reduction) Equivalent material (I made this up. Couldn't find anything anywhere) 1st - 3rd: Wood |
| #207Tempest_StormwindApr 14, 2014 15:10:19 |
|
| #208QvicklyMay 23, 2014 6:38:05 | Hi, i would like to ask about monks and duelist. Is it posible to use duelists special qualities with piercing type of dmg of spiked gauntled and also use monks unarmed dmg? Thanks |
| #209Tempest_StormwindMay 23, 2014 9:10:31 |
|