How to Interpret the Rules

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

Mistwell

Dec 31, 2014 10:06:07

Sacrosanct came up with this excellent flowchart which tells you how to interpret rules in D&D 5th Edition. He's called it "Waibel's Rule of Interpretation". If you're ever stuck on how to use a rule, quickly consult this chart to find out what to do!

 

Waibels Rule

#2

Leugren

Dec 31, 2014 11:16:07

Mistwell wrote:
#3

Orethalion

Dec 31, 2014 10:47:22

Leugren wrote:
#4

Mistwell

Dec 31, 2014 10:56:15

Leugren wrote:
#5

Leugren

Dec 31, 2014 11:14:15

Mistwell wrote:
#6

Mistwell

Dec 31, 2014 11:15:02

Leugren wrote:
#7

Leugren

Dec 31, 2014 21:46:58

Mistwell wrote:
#8

Orethalion

Dec 31, 2014 11:21:12

Mistwell wrote:
#9

Wuzzard

Dec 31, 2014 14:25:09

This is exactly the flow chart I follow when considering any and all rules, races, classes, monsters, traps, feats, proficiencies, backgrounds, sidebars and fluff text.

#10

SilentSin

Dec 31, 2014 16:39:05

I like how the flowchart says you can "change it to fit your needs", and then end up with something you're not OK with.

(Reply to #10)

Devils-Advocate

SilentSin wrote:
#12

MechaPilot

Dec 31, 2014 18:06:54

Devils-Advocate wrote:
#13

Noon

Dec 31, 2014 21:19:24

I'd have some 'Make a mental note : just because it didn't make sense to me doesn't mean it doesn't make sense at all - I may not have grasped it and should check on this again latter'.

 

On 'Are you okay with it' I'd instead have 'Keep in mind even if you're not okay with it, maybe that is this game - like none of us liked the taste of bitter beer at first but came to love it, maybe the taste of the game is bitter - but you'll come to get why if you follow rather than ignore the rules'

 

Granted, that's a lot of text.

#14

Oraibi

Dec 31, 2014 23:24:12

Apart from this being a joke, there also needs to be a step that asks if you understand the rule before you change it, and also understand what unintentional effects could result from the rule.

 

#15

AaronOfBarbaria

Jan 01, 2015 3:29:18
I have loved the taste of beer from the very first sip, but otherwise agree with noon on this: not being okay with it now isn't necessarily never being.
(Reply to #13)

EzechielDantan

Noon wrote:
#17

Brock_Landers

Jan 01, 2015 5:21:09

AaronOfBarbaria wrote:
#18

Leugren

Jan 01, 2015 5:45:44

Hey, folks, this entire thread and the flowchart that goes with it was intended as a lark!  Read post #6.  Mistwell is not seriously advocating the use of a flowchart for purposes of interpreting the rules.  

#19

Noon

Jan 01, 2015 20:19:24

So he doesn't consider things like that at all? Seems like what a lot of gamers might think, even if they don't write it down in flowchart form.

 

 

EzechielDantan wrote:
#20

Rastapopoulos

Jan 02, 2015 14:29:54

Leugren wrote:
#21

Rastapopoulos

Jan 02, 2015 14:34:07

Noon wrote:
#22

Noon

Jan 03, 2015 16:07:45

Rastapopoulos wrote:
#23

Orethalion

Jan 04, 2015 10:24:09

Noon wrote:
#24

Noon

Jan 04, 2015 18:03:39

When the third option is 'Buy an RPG...then play something else other than it', it might be worth considering going back to just two options.

 

Yep, it's not the one released - so you buy an RPG, then never play it. Not like 'Never got the time to fit it in' but deliberately never play it.

#25

Orethalion

Jan 04, 2015 18:29:13

Noon wrote:
#26

Noon

Jan 04, 2015 20:47:43

Orethalion wrote:
#27

Orethalion

Jan 04, 2015 21:41:12

Noon wrote:
#28

Mecheon

Jan 04, 2015 23:28:53

Noon wrote: