What's your favorite spellcasting system?

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

emkj

Feb 25, 2011 13:36:04
I've never been a big fan of D&D's Vancian spellcasting system, so I'm wondering what other RPGs out there have "better" or at least significantly different spellcasting systems than you can find with D&D.  I'm sure a lot of things have been tried in the past, but what I guess I'm most interested in hear which systems you thought:

A.  Were the most unique.
B.  Were the easiest the play.
C.  Made the most sense. 
#2

emkj

Mar 23, 2011 15:37:50
In case anyone is interested, here's a compiled list of what people recommended (on another forum):

7 Votes:
 - Mage: the Ascension (1e & 2e)


5 Votes:
 - Ars Magica (esp 5e)


3 Votes:
 - Deadlands
- Dungeons & Dragons (aka Vancian)
 - True Sorcery


2 Votes:
 - Arcana Evolved
 - Dungeons & Dragons: 3.5e (Psionics/Sorcerers)
 - Elements of Magic
 - Mage: the Awakening
 - Palladium (1e)
 - Rolemaster 1e
 - Shadowrun 2e
 - Star Wars: Saga Edition


1 Vote:
 - Advanced Dungeons & Dragons + Spells & Magic options
 - Dark Ages: Mage
 - Dungeons & Dragons: 2e (Wild Mage)
 - HERO 
 - Lyceian Arcana
 - Mythic Earth
 - Powers & Perils
 - RuneQuest
 - Talislanta
 - Trailblazer
 - Warrior, Rogue & Mage
 - World of Darkness (Monte Cook's)
#3

arderkrag

Apr 16, 2011 11:51:05
I've never been a big fan of D&D's Vancian spellcasting system, so I'm wondering what other RPGs out there have "better" or at least significantly different spellcasting systems than you can find with D&D.  I'm sure a lot of things have been tried in the past, but what I guess I'm most interested in hear which systems you thought:

A.  Were the most unique.
B.  Were the easiest the play.
C.  Made the most sense. 



Check out the Conan d20 spell system. I prefer it over a great many.
#4

fayelampshire

Jul 06, 2011 12:08:45
Well, i've not got to cast spells in Mage yet, but I like the system in Slayers d20