Earth Genasi "Meld with stone"

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

Undrhil

Mar 12, 2015 6:18:07

So, the Earth Genasi has a racial ability called "Meld with Stone" which allows them to cast 'pass without trace'.  I don't understand why they didn't simply allow them to cast 'meld with stone', instead.  Or, as a throwback to the 4e Earth Genasi, allow them to cast 'earth tremor'.

 

I'm mainly wondering if this might have been a mistake and they *meant* to have them cast 'meld with stone' like the name of the feature suggests.  Because pass without trace doesn't really 'meld with stone', to me....

#2

mellored

Mar 12, 2015 7:13:44

hard to say.

 

certainly a possibility.

#3

Mechatarrasque

Mar 12, 2015 7:27:45

That is my interpretation.  

#4

Coredump00

Mar 12, 2015 7:59:12

I think it is much more likely that they just made a poor choice for the abiilty name.  Or perhaps in a playtest version it had meld with stone, and it got changed but not renamed.

 

I seriously doubt that PwoT is a mistake.

 

 

#5

QwertyAzerty

Mar 12, 2015 12:18:13

Meld into stone is a spell level 3, it would be too powerful compare to the other race giving access to spell level 2 only at level 5. already pass without trace ( a spell level 2) at level 1 is very powerful.

#6

lawrencehoy

Mar 12, 2015 16:38:59

The earth genasi trait is titled Merge with Stone not Meld into Stone, as the spell. Personally, I think the Pass without Trace spell is better; it can affect the entire party and is easily interpreted as sinking into, and moving through, the earth/stone (merging with it). Meld into Stone provides no movement and opens up the possibility of plenty of damage.