| Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
|---|---|
| #1dionnecuratFeb 17, 2010 15:15:34 | Hopefully, no one will think I want this DM removed from the group or anything. Its the last thing I want. Our DM is a good guy and all, but its been recently apparent that he takes losses personally, especially when it comes to board games and tabletop games. He never really blames himself when he loses; rather, he points blame at someone else and gets mad at them. Now, normally this would be an indicator of a sore loser. However... I recently began to be a target for these particular actions. He told me, "I wonder if your character survives..." At first, I thought he was joking, so I simply passed it off, but after that incident I would jokingly say things like, "Are you gonna kill off X's character?" to which he'd respond, "I guess it depends." This has led me to creating backup characters in the event that my character is killed off. I'd rather not run a new character, especially after only one session in his campaign. And it isn't so much my problem as it is his for letting losses in board games affect his DMing. I guess my question is should I bring this up to him and let him know of my concern, or should I just pass it off? |
| #2Ka_D-ArgoFeb 17, 2010 15:59:19 | Just my opinion, but your examples are kind of vague at best. And you may just be reading too much into it. Now, if your character always seems to be the first attacked, solely focused on for the duration of battle, or is the only one dying despite doing everything you can not to...then, I'd say the DM is likely taking "revenge" for losing in another game. |
| #3CybitFeb 17, 2010 17:50:15 | Aye, I spend a good chunk of the talk at the table during a fight taunting players and telling them which one is going to die. My players know better then to take me seriously, unless they're being idiots, at which point, they might end up getting themselves killed. It's one of the little joys of being a DM, messing with players. :-p Considering most players will spend their characters' existence by screwing up your best laid plans (THOSE MEDDLING KIDS!), it's my little revenge. :D |
| #4dionnecuratFeb 17, 2010 18:58:18 | Just my opinion, but your examples are kind of vague at best. And you may just be reading too much into it. Now, if your character always seems to be the first attacked, solely focused on for the duration of battle, or is the only one dying despite doing everything you can not to...then, I'd say the DM is likely taking "revenge" for losing in another game. I guess I may be reading into it too much, since I'm playing a squishy that rarely gets touched...in fact, I think I haven't been hit yet. I'll just pass it off. Thanks. |
| #5deacon_liadonFeb 18, 2010 12:09:01 | I start every session by telling the player's they're going to die. They never know if I'm joking or not. |
| #6tequila_sunriseFeb 18, 2010 16:11:54 | I start every session by telling the player's they're going to die. They never know if I'm joking or not. I'm reminded of the pirate caption who every day told what's-his-name-the-pretty-boy from Princess Bride that he would die. And then the pretty boy became caption. /non-sequitor
You've only played one session with this DM? Yeah, give it time. He's just as likely joking around with you. |
| #7itsme4eva1Feb 18, 2010 20:11:59 | Well it is not as bad as one time my DM said he would do everything possible to kill of our characters but would not go overboard and make it unfun. To say the least our DM put us against a CR 8 dragon at level 4 almost killing 2 of our characters surviving only due to buffs I placed on them that allowed them to kill them. The very next battle at level 5/6 we went up against 1 CR 10 5 CR 7 and about 8 CR 2 or 1, our group consisted of a Fighter, Paladin, Rogue, Ranger, and Wizard(me). And he even admitted to us that he tried pretty hard to kill 1 of us off just because he wanted to see some new characters though mine was safe because he liked my little halfling who was the most unpredictable saving a few of our characters from sheer death. |
| #8firnurielFeb 18, 2010 22:27:38 | Dion: It's unclear - is this the first time this guy has DMed for you? Or is it the first encounter/session in a new campaign under him? At any rate, leave him be for awhile....see what happens next. |
| #9NyarlathotepFeb 21, 2010 21:19:43 | I've always joked with my players about out of game things (good and bad) affecting what I do to them during the game. It's a joke and everyone knows it. I suspect thats the case here too. |
| #10Hibiki54Feb 22, 2010 2:40:49 | Do not all DMs say their players are going to die? Seriously, this is what we do. DMs don't kill players. Players allow other players to die. |
| #11The-Magic-SwordFeb 23, 2010 18:36:18 | heh, i indicate they're going to die at the beginning of every encounter, and whenever they're being idiots/getting off-topic, i say "alright, so Orcus appears out of nowhere and kills you all..." ;) imo, they like it |
| #12mistwolfMar 01, 2010 21:21:31 | I'm reminded of the pirate caption who every day told what's-his-name-the-pretty-boy from Princess Bride that he would die. And then the pretty boy became caption. /non-sequitor That was the Dread Pirate Robert talking to Wesley DMs don't kill players... Of course we don't! As much as we'd like to it's not worth going to prison over ![]() |
| #13corpselightMar 02, 2010 19:45:10 | I always maintained that the DM never killed anyone; they were simply applicants for the Darwin Awards. Maybe the DM needs to consider running a session of Paranoia? |
| #14mistwolfMar 07, 2010 2:18:03 |
Ah, yes. Best of all is to make no threats but develop a situation to the point the player begs and pleads with you to simply kill the character. Without having made a single dice roll |
| #15deacon_liadonMar 08, 2010 18:08:09 | Maybe the DM needs to consider running a session of Paranoia? Mmmm. Paranoia. When in doubt, kill everyone. Then do it again. |
| #16corpselightMar 10, 2010 19:44:59 | Mmmm. Paranoia. And again, and again, and again... ![]() |
| #17corpselightMar 10, 2010 19:49:17 | Ah, yes. Best of all is to make no threats but develop a situation to the point the player begs and pleads with you to simply kill the character. Without having made a single dice roll I told you to stop reading from my playbook...I need to booby-trap that thing better. ![]() |
| #18mistwolfMar 11, 2010 11:37:00 | Ah, yes. Best of all is to make no threats but develop a situation to the point the player begs and pleads with you to simply kill the character. Without having made a single dice roll Reading from your playbook? I remember when a certain Jack Kerouac let Francis Goodon arrange a meeting for him with Moses somewhere in the abandoned warehouse district. "You're trying to kill me, aren't you?" exclaimed the player when discovering the outcome. Before the session was over the player was saying "Please! Just- kill me now!" I will admit you're good and only borrow pages for your playbook from a master ![]() |
| #19corpselightMar 12, 2010 11:33:52 | Reading from your playbook? I remember when a certain Jack Kerouac let Francis Goodon arrange a meeting for him with Moses somewhere in the abandoned warehouse district. Theoretically speaking, I’m sure that player was having the best game ever. Theoretically speaking. But I thought this thread was about unwanted death threats levied from the DM, not players being tortured to the point of begging for their character's death. Of course, that may just be a common tactic used by all sadistic DMs (I think I may have posted something on another thread about sadistic DMs…) ![]() |
| #20mistwolfMar 12, 2010 16:33:37 | I was speaking more about the play book ;) |